M15 or 997 Gt3 rs ?
M15 or 997 Gt3 rs ?
Author
Discussion

wizz72

Original Poster:

575 posts

257 months

Thursday 1st February 2007
quotequote all
What wud u go for between an M15 or 997Gt3 rs or maybe even R8? Now im not using my 996 GT3 a lot i was thinking about a change to something faster after Le Mans this year (well i owe what ive already got a trip there and back b4 i change it), havent driven any of them , has anyone else? I suppose the R8 will be rarer than rocking horse poo for some time too, or the darkhorse Gallardo snipping in at under 80k if u know where u looking.I would imagine the 997 to be most reliable as these machines go but i was wondering what everyone opinions were? There is of course another option, giving up on cars altogether and using my fiat punto around town until i move, i must admit ive enjoyed the £10 per week fuel bill, quite a novelty !

alex_123_fra

355 posts

265 months

Thursday 1st February 2007
quotequote all
Not sure about the M15...who knows if it'll even materialise. I'd have the R8 over the GT3. Mid-engined, rarer, arguably better build quality. V10 version I am sure will prove phenomenal but with the obligatory ridiculous price tag.

mr noble

6,538 posts

262 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
Agree with above.

Until we know what the final incarnation of the M15 will be its hard to say.

It needs a V8 and a minimum of 500 ponies to really compete in the current competition.

I would say a Gallardo at under 75k would be the best bet, but then you like Parkers Chris, so the new GT3RS would be your best bet I would say.


How cool is this one.

Greg




Ash M400

3,836 posts

270 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
GT3 RS, everytime.

gizard

2,272 posts

312 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
Well I have got a 997 GT3 coming in May (hopefully) I couldn't justify the extra cash for the RS all you get is a dodgy paint job wider arches and about 2 seconds a lap at the Ring (suposedly)
Not so sure about the Audi build quality...

And agree with the Noble - I would be really hacked off by now if I had a deposit down on one - and nearly need on the lauch day of the M14 I was on the phone to the factory for another reason and they offered me a place at the front of the queue I thought about it and said no thanks.

Anyway I could probably sell the GT3 in a year or two and buy a second hand M15 that will have depreciated far more than the GT3....

nickytwohats

2,093 posts

270 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
Well ... put it this way.

I have a deposit on the M15/16/??.

In the absence of any news (despite promises of a call to keep me in the loop) ....

I'm test driving a Porsche tomorrow.

I don't want to grow up and buy one but I might have to.

joolski

813 posts

254 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all

I think he's getting worried Obes Audi is going to give his Porker a run for it's money........

:-)


But getting back to the question...

GT3 RS. without a doubt. I've had a deposit on the 'next' noble for so long I've forgotten which one it was for.....

--Jools

epsomjames

790 posts

275 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
Gallardo without a doubt, as long as you can afford the huge running costs.

I think the orange with black detailing is a much better colour combo on the 997 GT3 RS.

Davey S2

13,394 posts

283 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
Probably just buy the standard GT3 and keep the £15k difference for track days

GT3RS is 4 seconds a lap faster at the Ring. And thats with Walter Rohl driving. No difference for us mere mortals.

Humpy

1,171 posts

248 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
RS apparantly . Or alternatively, keep the Punto for tootling around town and spend £9k (perhaps 12mths ownership & depreciation costs on the Lambo?) on an Ecurie 25 5000mile membership and drive all these

Nice choice to have to make

Edited to add - you could always go for the new Noble when it arrives anyhow. So go for the 6 mth Ecurie package

H

Edited by Humpy on Friday 2nd February 23:02

obes

3,298 posts

273 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
joolski said:

I think he's getting worried Obes Audi is going to give his Porker a run for it's money........


It's Haze's Audi mate

Wizzie, I had a bit of a natter with the guy down at sixfields about the R8. They will be getting a demonstrator so i think me and thee need to make a visit

I've got to admit though, I think the performance figures on the R8 are a tad dissapointing. M15 vagueness aside, it's 997 GT3RS all the way in that choice

mikey_p

1,283 posts

243 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
Saw a silver 997 GT3 RS for the first time today (parked near Castle Sports cars in Stansted Mountfitchet).

What an awsome looking machine. One of the only times I have thought 'damn, that is gorgeous' about a Porsche. (apart from that Electric Blue one that was parked just up past all the Nobles at Le Mans last year, for those who saw it).

Doesn't really answer your question though. Just flick a coin to choose. It's much simpler then comparing numbers.

M400 NBL

3,552 posts

241 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
I wonder how much money Noble have in deposits for M14,M15 and any other models that they're developing.

Of course this is not exclusive to Noble. It says a lot for a car manufacturer when customers put down hard cash months (year+ in some cases) in advance.

wizz72

Original Poster:

575 posts

257 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
I think to be honest for me it would be a 997 gt3 rs in green with black decals, fantastic ! i am going to have a look into but it wont be for a bit yet if at all as im considering moving abroad in which case id be trading up to a speed boat !!!!! However if i do stay in uk and get a new house with a garage i think thats what i would like to see sitting in it....for the next 30 years, its iconic like the original and i dont think u wud ever get bored of something like that...makes the 996 seem tame

V6GTO

11,579 posts

271 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
wizz72 said:
I think to be honest for me it would be a 997 gt3 rs in green with black decals(


But there again you never did have any taste...BMW...Porsche...Justin...rofl

M.

joust

14,622 posts

288 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
epsomjames said:
Gallardo without a doubt, as long as you can afford the huge running costs.
I think the orange with black detailing is a much better colour combo on the 997 GT3 RS.
Can't agree, I found the Gallardo ultimatly dissapointing when I had one for 3 days and 100's of miles in many different conditions recently.

J

joust

14,622 posts

288 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
Humpy said:
1st Gallardo or 2nd RS. Or alternatively, keep the Punto for tootling around town and spend £9k (perhaps 12mths ownership & depreciation costs on the Lambo?) on an Ecurie 25 5000mile membership and drive all these
Given the number of cars I've decided I don't want to purchase due to those wonderful peeps at Ecurie, it's worth it's cost twice over to get the choice right!

I'm also debating with ecurie if it's worth having more than one main car on my P&L anymore....

J

joust

14,622 posts

288 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
V6GTO said:
But there again you never did have any taste...BMW...Porsche...Justin...rofl
I'll take that as a compliment.........

DanH

12,287 posts

289 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
wizz72 said:
makes the 996 seem tame


Ironic that driving it is the opposite lol

As to the R8, I don't really see that as a credible alternative to a 911 if you are actually into driving rather than having the latest shiney toy.

alex s

2,105 posts

265 months

Friday 2nd February 2007
quotequote all
DanH said:
wizz72 said:
makes the 996 seem tame


Ironic that driving it is the opposite lol

As to the R8, I don't really see that as a credible alternative to a 911 if you are actually into driving rather than having the latest shiney toy.


Isnt the R8 around £20K cheaper than the GT3RS ?