10k car for parent
Author
Discussion

Up and down Gears

Original Poster:

5 posts

33 months

Yesterday (22:59)
quotequote all
Evening,

Looking at a car for parent. Retired, now does low mileage, very odd longer trip, would maybe like something slightly 'higher up' to get in and out but not essential. Ideally 10k and under but can go slightly higher.

Renault Captur
Nissan Micra
Honda Jazz
Dacia - not sure on individual models

I have suggested electric due to low miles, but unsure on if it or battery goes 'wrong' in a few years, cost wise to repair. Nissan Leaf or MX30 would be ideal I would think.

What other suggestions do you think?

InitialDave

15,056 posts

147 months

Yesterday (23:24)
quotequote all
The Jazz is a stereotypical elderly transport for good reason.

I'd also consider a Yaris Hybrid.

biggbn

32,358 posts

248 months

My 80 year old dad just bought an i3 and is hugely impressed with it, as am I...

Evanivitch

26,264 posts

150 months

Hyundai Kona.

Easy 250 mile range on 64kWh model (there are a few 40kWh around at that price). Slightly higher up than a typical granny hatch. Decent spec and active safety equipment.

I'd probably just charge it off a 3-pin plug for low mileage use.

Leaf also cheap but then got to address the lack of Chademo chargers if they're out and about.

Jag_NE

3,334 posts

128 months

If it’s low mileage I don’t think I’d bother bringing an EV into the equation.

From that list I’d be going for the Renault

edc

9,594 posts

279 months

Seat Arona, Merc B class.

Neil-nvaua

295 posts

9 months

My Mum was in a similar situation and we bought her the Renault Captur which replaced an ageing Nissan Note.

Overall happy with the choice and its a surprisingly nice car to drive with just enough tech - auto hill-hold, auto lights, auto wipers whilst being simple enough to drive and live with.

Her only complaint if its a consideration is poor rear access to child seats - smallish rear doors that dont open particularly wide.

Russet Grange

2,902 posts

54 months

The first thing I would do is get them both to drive an EV (on the assumption that they can charge at home). The smoothness and simplicity might be a revelation, in which case, you're looking for a £10k EV.

Quite a few to choose from, just whack the price and EV requirement into autotrader and you'll see plenty of options.

I wouldn't worry about battery degradation too much, something up to 70-80k miles and no more than perhaps six or seven years old will surely be fine.

Davie

6,154 posts

243 months

In no particular order, grandparents here have a 1.2 Renault Caotur, a 1.4 Corsa 5 door and a 1.2 Dacia Duster. There's a common theme centering around a lack of tech...

Up and down Gears

Original Poster:

5 posts

33 months

Thanks all. The Captur is their favourite at the minute. They are more worried about buying a 'turd' as the car have now has been so reliable for 130k and only required consumables.

A500leroy

8,304 posts

146 months

Fiat panda.

CMTMB

1,790 posts

23 months

My parents have a Kia Niro which they've been really pleased with. Mum has a dodgy hip and finds it easy to get in and out of. It's a hybrid auto so a very easy to drive and economical.

Evanivitch

26,264 posts

150 months

Up and down Gears said:
Thanks all. The Captur is their favourite at the minute. They are more worried about buying a 'turd' as the car have now has been so reliable for 130k and only required consumables.
Probably going back a while, but the Captur diesel automatic was the worst car I've ever driven.

InitialDave

15,056 posts

147 months

Up and down Gears said:
Thanks all. The Captur is their favourite at the minute. They are more worried about buying a 'turd' as the car have now has been so reliable for 130k and only required consumables.
On that basis, why buy now? Why not wait until it dies of something terminal or disproportionately hard/expensive to fix?

What do they have now, and what makes it unsuitable for their needs?

"Fancy something else" is perfectly valid, but they shouldn't rationalise themselves into a potentially unnecessary change for no good reason.