Does an interesting family car exist??

Does an interesting family car exist??

Author
Discussion

Fanboy35

Original Poster:

7 posts

7 months

Sunday 29th September
quotequote all
Ok so with a new addition to the family due in a few months it's time to hang up the fun daily cars... I think.

I have a mk1 golf that I'm intending to build into a show car for the summers and special occasions so trying to tell myself reliable and family is the way to go. Only problem is I struggle to fond the happy medium; latest cars on the list vary from v10 Audi S8 and 4.2 RS4s through to Hyundai Tucson and Kia Sportages but every time I look at the former the running make me feel I shouldn't be that selfish and the later just bore me.

We have a 2016 Astra in the family that is apparently adequate although the pram now takes up the whole boot on the test fit.

Anyway rambling on here. Criteria are:
Budget max 25k flr the right car or a shed up to 10k
Petrol or electric ideally
Daily commute is 8 miles
Enough room to keep all the baby requirements out of the cabin
Fun enough to entertain me and not feel like I've given everything up.

Sounds a bit depressing but the struggle is real. Any advice appreciated.

TB404

122 posts

185 months

Sunday 29th September
quotequote all
Well you might just find an EV6 at your range, perhaps something like this:
https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202409164...

325 BHP, 5.1 seconds to 60, stunning looks, super-fast charging and genuinely practical (we did many continental trips) last but not least, actually fun to drive.

you're welcome.

ChrisH72

2,351 posts

59 months

Sunday 29th September
quotequote all
Surely there are a whole range of suitable options between an RS4 and a Kia Sportage??

I'll start off with this.

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/2024072420...

But really, any large hatch or estate with decent performance would do the job.

Personally I feel that high performance and exciting handling are wasted in a family motor but that's just me. We have my wife's Hyundai MPV for family stuff which is spacious, comfy and cheap as chips to run. I have an mx5 ND2 which I use for work when it's just me or for fun when I take our 8 year old son out in it.

Boringvolvodriver

10,074 posts

50 months

Sunday 29th September
quotequote all
The question is how many occasions will you need to have all the baby stuff in the car? Whilst a tight fit with the pram, they won’t be in that for that long in the scheme of things.

Will you make longish journeys? If so how often? Maybe a fun car with a roof box as and when required is the answer.

If so, then you have increased your options quite a bit - there is little point having a big boring car when the majority of the time you don’t need it.

When I retired, we decided we would go off camping and I considered an estate but in the end opted for a roof box when we went away. Cheaper than changing the car!

DickyC

51,709 posts

205 months

Sunday 29th September
quotequote all
RS4

And on a Point of Order, Mr Chairman, eight miles is driving to work, not commuting.

reddiesel

2,473 posts

54 months

Sunday 29th September
quotequote all
X350 Jaguar XJR . Depending what you want to spend it can be shed money or best in class . You will seldom see another , won't lose much money and a V8 with 400bhp is always guaranteed to put a smile on anyones face .

CLK-GTR

1,223 posts

252 months

Sunday 29th September
quotequote all
C63 estate. Just budget some extra for the tyres and fuel.

ZX10R NIN

28,381 posts

132 months

Sunday 29th September
quotequote all
Fanboy35 said:
Ok so with a new addition to the family due in a few months it's time to hang up the fun daily cars... I think.

I have a mk1 golf that I'm intending to build into a show car for the summers and special occasions so trying to tell myself reliable and family is the way to go. Only problem is I struggle to fond the happy medium; latest cars on the list vary from v10 Audi S8 and 4.2 RS4s through to Hyundai Tucson and Kia Sportages but every time I look at the former the running make me feel I shouldn't be that selfish and the later just bore me.

We have a 2016 Astra in the family that is apparently adequate although the pram now takes up the whole boot on the test fit.

Anyway rambling on here. Criteria are:
Budget max 25k flr the right car or a shed up to 10k
Petrol or electric ideally
Daily commute is 8 miles
Enough room to keep all the baby requirements out of the cabin
Fun enough to entertain me and not feel like I've given everything up.

Sounds a bit depressing but the struggle is real. Any advice appreciated.
Kia Stinger GT, very good steer & family car, As well as 4 years warranty left on the first one:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202409274...

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202409234...

XF S, they drive/ride well & have a peach of a drivetrain:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202408193...

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202408112...

CLS400 Shooting brake:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202408303...

Maserti Ghibi:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202409043...

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202409123...

S:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202405029...

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202409123...

Full fat options:

CLS 63:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202409134...

E63:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202409234...

Panamera Turbo:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202405139...

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202404088...

GTS:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202409164...

S:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202409244...

V8 S8:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202404279...

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202402146...

M6 GC:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202405280...

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202407292...

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202407051...

maz8062

2,608 posts

222 months

Sunday 29th September
quotequote all
It’s a waste of time mate, you’re better off getting a weekend car that you can use to get your fix of vroom vroom. Big engined cars are noisy, you’ll want the baby to sleep because they tend to moan, cry and shout when they’re awake. Most of the time your mrs will also be in the car and she won’t welcome any boy racer type antics, she’ll want peace and safety for all of you. It’s a different world having a baby - you now have precious cargo, speed is irresponsible and won’t come naturally to you with the baby at the back.

Get an SUV type vehicle with plenty of space, wide doors and an elevated driving position. Autos work and something that your mrs can work with seamlessly as a mother. Big engine, fuel greedy cars that could leave her stranded because the high pressure fuel pump or something like that creates problems for you when you get back from work.

Spend the rest on an Elise, MX5, or something that won’t make her accuse you of having fun while she’s taking care of business at home.

Super Sonic

7,282 posts

61 months

Sunday 29th September
quotequote all
DickyC said:
RS4

And on a Point of Order, Mr Chairman, eight miles is driving to work, not commuting.
Insurers would disagree

ChrisH72

2,351 posts

59 months

Sunday 29th September
quotequote all
maz8062 said:
It’s a waste of time mate, you’re better off getting a weekend car that you can use to get your fix of vroom vroom. Big engined cars are noisy, you’ll want the baby to sleep because they tend to moan, cry and shout when they’re awake. Most of the time your mrs will also be in the car and she won’t welcome any boy racer type antics, she’ll want peace and safety for all of you. It’s a different world having a baby - you now have precious cargo, speed is irresponsible and won’t come naturally to you with the baby at the back.

Get an SUV type vehicle with plenty of space, wide doors and an elevated driving position. Autos work and something that your mrs can work with seamlessly as a mother. Big engine, fuel greedy cars that could leave her stranded because the high pressure fuel pump or something like that creates problems for you when you get back from work.

Spend the rest on an Elise, MX5, or something that won’t make her accuse you of having fun while she’s taking care of business at home.
Pretty much exactly what I was saying but a bit more blunt!

Couldn't agree more. SUVs are popular fir a reason and it has nothing to do with driving dynamics.

Is this your first child?

If so, I'd recommend you just use the Astra which will be absolutely fine. If the pram doesn't fit, buy a smaller pram. It's cheaper than a bigger car!

DoubleSix

12,003 posts

183 months

Sunday 29th September
quotequote all
340i Touring

Does everything. Tip runs, family holidays and decent dose of driver involvement.

darreni

3,997 posts

277 months

Monday 30th September
quotequote all
Macan turbo? There are also some c7 RS6’s around the money you’re looking to spend.

roadie

771 posts

269 months

Monday 30th September
quotequote all
Golf GTI Clubsport?

blue_haddock

3,866 posts

74 months

Monday 30th September
quotequote all

grudas

1,339 posts

175 months

Monday 30th September
quotequote all
I've been looking into too..

there's suprisingly not much unless it has a chunky bork factor.

CLS 350 shooting brake is on my list, C63 estate is on the list(risk of bork), cayenne 4.2 TD or V8 is on the list(risk of bork again) rs4/s4/s6 avants..

and then maybe something a bit left field, like elgrand 3.5 v6 or a vellfire/alphard toyota with the 3.5

fflump

1,759 posts

45 months

Monday 30th September
quotequote all
Fanboy35 said:
Ok so with a new addition to the family due in a few months it's time to hang up the fun daily cars... I think.

I have a mk1 golf that I'm intending to build into a show car for the summers and special occasions so trying to tell myself reliable and family is the way to go. Only problem is I struggle to fond the happy medium; latest cars on the list vary from v10 Audi S8 and 4.2 RS4s through to Hyundai Tucson and Kia Sportages but every time I look at the former the running make me feel I shouldn't be that selfish and the later just bore me.

We have a 2016 Astra in the family that is apparently adequate although the pram now takes up the whole boot on the test fit.

Anyway rambling on here. Criteria are:
Budget max 25k flr the right car or a shed up to 10k
Petrol or electric ideally
Daily commute is 8 miles
Enough room to keep all the baby requirements out of the cabin
Fun enough to entertain me and not feel like I've given everything up.

Sounds a bit depressing but the struggle is real. Any advice appreciated.
I used a Ghibli V6S (about 410 bhp) as a family car which was far from dull and did all the practical things easily.




Mouse Rat

1,886 posts

99 months

Monday 30th September
quotequote all
maz8062 said:
It’s a waste of time mate, you’re better off getting a weekend car that you can use to get your fix of vroom vroom. Big engined cars are noisy, you’ll want the baby to sleep because they tend to moan, cry and shout when they’re awake. Most of the time your mrs will also be in the car and she won’t welcome any boy racer type antics, she’ll want peace and safety for all of you. It’s a different world having a baby - you now have precious cargo, speed is irresponsible and won’t come naturally to you with the baby at the back.

Get an SUV type vehicle with plenty of space, wide doors and an elevated driving position. Autos work and something that your mrs can work with seamlessly as a mother. Big engine, fuel greedy cars that could leave her stranded because the high pressure fuel pump or something like that creates problems for you when you get back from work.

Spend the rest on an Elise, MX5, or something that won’t make her accuse you of having fun while she’s taking care of business at home.
^^THIS^^ and you will soon get frustrated with loose items everywhere, spilt milk, vomit, food, smells, dog poo on pram wheels, baby seat, door pranged as your missus frustratingly struggles to clip baby in seat while its hammering down outside B&M.



braddo

11,253 posts

195 months

Monday 30th September
quotequote all
Fanboy35 said:
Ok so with a new addition to the family due in a few months it's time to hang up the fun daily cars... I think.

...
We have a 2016 Astra in the family that is apparently adequate although the pram now takes up the whole boot on the test fit.
There's no need for anyone to give up on life and get a SUV just because a baby is coming. By all means have a car that you won't be too precious about, but it doesn't mean the car has to be a shed or a filthy mess or no fun to drive when your family isn't in the car.

A compact estate will do the job nicely. Pick your poison whether it's BMW/Merc/Audi or Focus/Golf/Seat/Astra etc. I'd avoid stuff with really stiff suspension like C63s. At newborn stage a non-SUV is easier with load height - both fitting the car seat (with baby in it) to a seat base and loading stuff in and out of the boot. When time comes to move to a front-facing seat (e.g. 12-14 months), get a car seat which swivels, so that the child is facing you when securing their belts etc.


  • Get a high quality compact buggy** - it means you'll only ever buy one buggy, which is quite rare as most people buy a massive one for the first year and then get sick of how big and unwieldy they are. They're light - so way easier for mums to fold and pack, you can take on holiday etc.
A YOYO with the lie-flat option, then switch to a normal stroller seat after 9-12 months.
https://www.johnlewis.com/stokke-yoyo-pushchair-fr...


braddo

11,253 posts

195 months

Monday 30th September
quotequote all
Just to add I used an AMG C43 saloon (W202, 1998) for 4 years as our first family car, with a Bugaboo Bee (it folded to compact suitcase size, weighed 7-8kg).