Self parking cars - which brand?

Self parking cars - which brand?

Author
Discussion

okgo

Original Poster:

39,266 posts

205 months

Sunday 16th June
quotequote all
Put bluntly, my wife isn’t a great parker. Came to driving late and we live in London which means relatively little driving - so some skills that others using their car daily would build quickly just haven’t happened for her.

A new house purchase means the road is narrower and likely to mean a tight parallel park almost every time, we fancy a new car so figure may as well get one that can park itself. Save the wheels wink

What brands have got the best system? I wanted a Macan but I don’t think Porsche do it. Size wise, smaller than a 5 series, a bit bigger than a Golf, ideally - not a brand snob but would prefer it to be vaguely pokey/nice place to be.

Where should I be looking?


Boleros

648 posts

13 months

Sunday 16th June
quotequote all
I had a 3 Series Touring that had it, quite effective as it goes although I’m ok at parking so rarely used it apart from demonstrating it to others. It was a bit hit and miss identifying a space but still. Late 2015 model so imagine that the systems are more refined nowadays.

CT05 Nose Cone

25,217 posts

234 months

Sunday 16th June
quotequote all
I had it in an E Class Coupe, but every time I tried it the system got confused and left me jutting out at an angle like it was my first day driving.

ecsrobin

17,813 posts

172 months

Sunday 16th June
quotequote all
CT05 Nose Cone said:
I had it in an E Class Coupe, but every time I tried it the system got confused and left me jutting out at an angle like it was my first day driving.
A friend has an E class estate, tried to show off the self parking and it just kept going backwards and forwards. He then tried to show someone else a few days later and did the same so he’s given up trying that rofl

HTP99

23,274 posts

147 months

Sunday 16th June
quotequote all
By and large self parking is crap, it is slow and can be hit and miss, it is one of those things that you have as it is already in the car, you show it to your mates and then never use it again.

Also generally they guide using the cars you are parking next to or with, if they are parked badly your car will park badly, if their wheels are on a kerb yours will be too.

blank

3,574 posts

195 months

Sunday 16th June
quotequote all
It really isn't very good. Lots of VW Group stuff has it. Tiguan may have it as standard in higher spec trims?


Might be better looking for something with a "birds eye" camera view?

TwigtheWonderkid

44,642 posts

157 months

Sunday 16th June
quotequote all
Had self parking on a Citroen C4 Cactus. It was superb. Spot on parking, every single time. Also got it on current Mercedes GLC. pretty good 90% of the time but not 100% like the Cactus.

okgo

Original Poster:

39,266 posts

205 months

Sunday 16th June
quotequote all
Actually seems Porsche do have a version of it - thanks for the tips on it being ste on most cars hehe

Is the Tesla one any better? Could be tempted.

fatjon

2,298 posts

220 months

Sunday 16th June
quotequote all
Tried it on 2020 Audi A8 and 2023 Kia EV6. Both terrible, ponderously slow to the point of being unusable.
They struggle to identify a space and unless it’s so easy that they are not needed anyway, they can’t park in it.
Just a gimmick and of no real world use.


MikeM6

5,215 posts

109 months

Sunday 16th June
quotequote all
Is all alternative option not to develop the skill? No reason why someone can't learn to park perfectly if they dismantle any self limiting beliefs and put in some time and energy.

Unless she is just not willing to, in which case fair enough.

okgo

Original Poster:

39,266 posts

205 months

Sunday 16th June
quotequote all
Well yes. That’s the ideal, but the issue has always been that we just don’t drive enough for anything to truly stick for a new driver. She passed her test at around 36 years old, then had two years of lock down. And since then basically the only driving we ever do is to my son’s nursery if the weather is awful.

I’ve said many times you need to find a reason to drive but it also is a vast waste of time in London given even 1 mile can take ten minutes. So I’ve almost given up on that track hence this.


Boleros

648 posts

13 months

Sunday 16th June
quotequote all
Why not get a small (proper small) city car like a Smart? Not as the main car, obvs.

okgo

Original Poster:

39,266 posts

205 months

Sunday 16th June
quotequote all
Boleros said:
Why not get a small (proper small) city car like a Smart? Not as the main car, obvs.
We barely drive one car, having two seems silly.

Vasco

17,342 posts

112 months

Sunday 16th June
quotequote all
Boleros said:
Why not get a small (proper small) city car like a Smart? Not as the main car, obvs.
Quite - just a baby car. Not sure that anybody that can't park should even be driving.

WestyCarl

3,456 posts

132 months

Sunday 16th June
quotequote all
okgo said:
Is the Tesla one any better? Could be tempted.
Useless to the point of unusable (according to my wife, of course being a powerfully built driving god male I've never tried to use it wink

okgo

Original Poster:

39,266 posts

205 months

Sunday 16th June
quotequote all
Vasco said:
Quite - just a baby car. Not sure that anybody that can't park should even be driving.
The driving is fine by and large. And obviously she can park to a degree. But the street we are moving to is one car width with parked cars either side, basically will require perfect parallel parks every time. Which she has struggled with historically.

Two cars isn’t an option.

Nomme de Plum

6,008 posts

23 months

Sunday 16th June
quotequote all
okgo said:
Vasco said:
Quite - just a baby car. Not sure that anybody that can't park should even be driving.
The driving is fine by and large. And obviously she can park to a degree. But the street we are moving to is one car width with parked cars either side, basically will require perfect parallel parks every time. Which she has struggled with historically.

Two cars isn’t an option.
I had a Merc C Class estate which could self park quite well. On many cars it will be an option rather than included with base model.

Telsla 3 or Y would work if you have access to charging. Probably best to determine the size of the car and what you will use it for first. If it's mostly city driving then having a great SuV would be a pain.

raspy

1,789 posts

101 months

Sunday 16th June
quotequote all
okgo said:
The driving is fine by and large. And obviously she can park to a degree. But the street we are moving to is one car width with parked cars either side, basically will require perfect parallel parks every time. Which she has struggled with historically.

Two cars isn’t an option.
You could try a modern BMW. I've got one. You can even record a parking manoeuvre once, and then each time you reach that place, the car offers to perform the manoeuvre, exactly the same. You can get it perform it from inside the car or just get out and use the app.

I use it to automatically reverse onto my driveway on a narrow road when I get home.

gotoPzero

18,139 posts

196 months

Sunday 16th June
quotequote all
Had it on my merc, could never get it to work.

Then had it on an audi and after RTFM it worked perfectly. This was 2015/16 technology too.

I have heard Tesla model 3 is even better but only included on cars with enhanced auto pilot package.

Waiting for someone like ENH to do a module.

Robertb

2,061 posts

245 months

Sunday 16th June
quotequote all
My CLS self parks very well, and the novelty is always amusing. But as said above, it does take bearings off the cars parked adjacent… not sure if it uses the parking sensors etc to ‘see’ the kerb.

I’d imagine any Merc with it would be fine.

That said, when my daughter learned to drive there was a distinct ‘formula’ which seemed to work reliably. Have a look for some videos on YouTube. We used to go out in the evening and find spaces on quiet roads to practice in.