Is discount for no part exchange a thing?
Is discount for no part exchange a thing?
Author
Discussion

GasEngineer

Original Poster:

2,335 posts

89 months

Thursday 1st June 2023
quotequote all
As header.

If sell my current car via WBAC or privately, is it realistic to expect a discount on the price of the car I'm considering buying from a dealer or car supermarket?

eg I'm looking at cars around £30k, WBAC valuation for my current is £8k, private sale maybe £11k.

anonymous-user

81 months

Thursday 1st June 2023
quotequote all
I doubt it, I suspect if you don't have a part exchange and you are paying cash they don't actually want your business. A bit different to the old days where they tried to make out they were doing you a favour offering to take your car as part exchange.


SydneyBridge

11,487 posts

185 months

Thursday 1st June 2023
quotequote all
Having a px might give you more room for negotiation on the cost to change, guess it depends if they want your px and can make a decent profit

Whataguy

1,129 posts

107 months

Thursday 1st June 2023
quotequote all
Best discounts come from contributions from dealer finance like free servicing/cash discount/etc.

You then pay the finance off after the minimum term has passed - sometimes 6 months.

Great tip I found out, you don't have to take finance on the whole car balance - so just take minimum finance to qualify & pay cash on the rest.

Plenty of people were buying £23k Honda Jazz but only financing £5k in order to get 5 year warranties and free servicing offer. Just pay off the £5k after 6 months.

Jamescrs

6,249 posts

92 months

Thursday 1st June 2023
quotequote all
Having no PX won't get you a discount on the window price of a car, if anything many dealers still want the stock coming in if it's the type of thing they would retail.

Expect the dealer to play hardball and not offer any discount at all, they may be more inclined to do something if you take out finance as part of the purchase

GasEngineer

Original Poster:

2,335 posts

89 months

Thursday 1st June 2023
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies - much as I thought.

WBAC ads seem to be based on getting a better deal when you don't PX.

Edible Roadkill

2,227 posts

204 months

Thursday 1st June 2023
quotequote all
I think generally the price is the price nowadays, you’ll be incentivised to take dealer finance though so if there’s anything deal that way take the finance then pay it off after a week or so.

Edited by Edible Roadkill on Thursday 1st June 16:47

SFTWend

1,402 posts

102 months

Thursday 1st June 2023
quotequote all
Agree with above. No px and cash does not help negotiate a discount.

I've enquired about 3 cars from franchised dealers. No discount on 2 of them although they were recent stock so no surprise. 3rd was close to a 90 day car and a 6 or 7% discount was on the table.

Strangely only a few days after being told no discount by one dealer they dropped the advertised price. I'm wondering if sales managers don't get to make decisions on price and more and it's all done by head office?

georgeyboy12345

4,556 posts

62 months

Friday 2nd June 2023
quotequote all
GasEngineer said:
WBAC ads seem to be based on getting a better deal when you don't PX.
Yeah that's a load of tosh.

Dan W.

1,196 posts

105 months

Saturday 3rd June 2023
quotequote all
car dealer here, No part exchange does not mean a better deal in the current climate.

as others have said if your car is a nice bit of stock we will pay good money for it,

if you come in saying i have no px what discount will i get, none why would you.

Its smart marketing from wbac to say you could get a better deal thats all

Aunty Pasty

786 posts

65 months

Saturday 3rd June 2023
quotequote all
The better deal for cash / no px used to be the perceived wisdom 30 odd years ago. I'm not even sure it was true back then but that's what everybody said at the time.

Pierre2k

54 posts

72 months

Saturday 3rd June 2023
quotequote all
I'd have said in the past, before such a reliance on finance deals to fund cars, particularly PCP, you could get a better deal with cash.

Now the dealers make most of their money from the finance, at least as I understand it (I'm not in the trade). They want you to buy with Finance, both to get the commission, and to somewhat lock you in to a cycle of refreshing the PCP every few years.

I do note the dealer comment above stating, no discount for cash, why would you? In principle, fair comment. However, think the challenge there has been brought on by the dealers themselves, as it's become almost a culturally accepted norm that you negotiate on car prices. They aren't fixed, they regularly do move, and deals are regularly on offer. Many still price this in, high balling the list price with an expectation of being knocked down. Maybe less so right now with sticky car prices, but certainly in the recent past.

I've always been a cash buyer, am an admittedly dreadful negotiatior, and even I've never paid sticker price on new or used cars.

Dan W.

1,196 posts

105 months

Saturday 3rd June 2023
quotequote all
Pierre2k said:
I'd have said in the past, before such a reliance on finance deals to fund cars, particularly PCP, you could get a better deal with cash.

Now the dealers make most of their money from the finance, at least as I understand it (I'm not in the trade). They want you to buy with Finance, both to get the commission, and to somewhat lock you in to a cycle of refreshing the PCP every few years.

I do note the dealer comment above stating, no discount for cash, why would you? In principle, fair comment. However, think the challenge there has been brought on by the dealers themselves, as it's become almost a culturally accepted norm that you negotiate on car prices. They aren't fixed, they regularly do move, and deals are regularly on offer. Many still price this in, high balling the list price with an expectation of being knocked down. Maybe less so right now with sticky car prices, but certainly in the recent past.

I've always been a cash buyer, am an admittedly dreadful negotiatior, and even I've never paid sticker price on new or used cars.
All good valid points.

tim0409

5,880 posts

186 months

Saturday 3rd June 2023
quotequote all
Aunty Pasty said:
The better deal for cash / no px used to be the perceived wisdom 30 odd years ago. I'm not even sure it was true back then but that's what everybody said at the time.
I used to work for a car trader many years ago; we underwrote trade ins from main dealers then either took them straight to auction or sold them to smaller dealers (I used to buy the best cars and sell them privately as well). Back then garages definitely used to inflate the trade in price to make it more palatable to customers, who always thought their car was worth more, and this came out of the (inflated) margin. Customers without a trade in could ( normally) expect a discount.

This has obviously changed in recent years as there is pressure on dealers to be more competitive due to the internet, and the response to covid has changed the market dramatically.

Edited by tim0409 on Saturday 3rd June 22:16

cayman-black

13,261 posts

243 months

Sunday 4th June 2023
quotequote all
Yes things have changed big time, no discounts for the cash buyer and more chance of a better deal with your trade in car.

Andy86GT

1,027 posts

92 months

Sunday 4th June 2023
quotequote all
For me, not having a part exchange made it easy to get a really good price on an Vitara for my wife through CARWOW. About £1700 off in 2015 if I recall. Conversely my daughter wanted a 500 (obviously) and AC had them at the really low prices preregistered, when we went to view / buy the car I couldn't even get generic mats thrown in despite saying we would have to leave it then. (Obviously we went back as it was still a good deal)

Pica-Pica

16,401 posts

111 months

Sunday 4th June 2023
quotequote all
Andy86GT said:
For me, not having a part exchange made it easy to get a really good price on an Vitara for my wife through CARWOW. About £1700 off in 2015 if I recall. Conversely my daughter wanted a 500 (obviously) and AC had them at the really low prices preregistered, when we went to view / buy the car I couldn't even get generic mats thrown in despite saying we would have to leave it then. (Obviously we went back as it was still a good deal)
It’s best not to ask for things, maintain a silence and wait for their offers.

PositronicRay

28,855 posts

210 months

Sunday 4th June 2023
quotequote all
SFTWend said:
Strangely only a few days after being told no discount by one dealer they dropped the advertised price. I'm wondering if sales managers don't get to make decisions on price and more and it's all done by head office?
Depends on the group, many are managed centrally.

Wacky Racer

41,137 posts

274 months

Sunday 4th June 2023
quotequote all
GasEngineer said:
Thanks for the replies - much as I thought.

WBAC ads seem to be based on getting a better deal when you don't PX.
Try Cazoo for a possible better price.

Andy86GT

1,027 posts

92 months

Sunday 4th June 2023
quotequote all
Pica-Pica said:
Andy86GT said:
For me, not having a part exchange made it easy to get a really good price on an Vitara for my wife through CARWOW. About £1700 off in 2015 if I recall. Conversely my daughter wanted a 500 (obviously) and AC had them at the really low prices preregistered, when we went to view / buy the car I couldn't even get generic mats thrown in despite saying we would have to leave it then. (Obviously we went back as it was still a good deal)
It’s best not to ask for things, maintain a silence and wait for their offers.
That's a good point actually. This is essentially what happened when I bought my '86. I was aware of another ex-demo one at my maximum budget (again with no part-ex involved) and they basically kept reducing the price and adding extras till I said yes.