How do you know which used car dealers to trust?
How do you know which used car dealers to trust?
Author
Discussion

Acuity30

Original Poster:

835 posts

46 months

Saturday 29th October 2022
quotequote all
I've always bought private but these days private and trade sellers seem to want the same prices whereas before you could snatch a bargain from a private seller. However how do you know which used car dealers are just out to sell you a lemon and which are genuine?

Rene Souffle

3,678 posts

241 months

Saturday 29th October 2022
quotequote all
I always start with trust pilot. Seems to be a fairly good window into any company’s doings smile

JonDerz

156 posts

155 months

Saturday 29th October 2022
quotequote all
Word of mouth from people you trust, read reviews.

I will say though that sometimes people bend the truth when they moan in reviews so take it with a pinch of salt.

If you’re really concerned about a car you’re looking at, see if they’ll let you have an aa inspection or something similar.

Inspire

425 posts

207 months

Sunday 30th October 2022
quotequote all
I think there is also an element of trusting your gut instinct. If you get a bad feeling then it’s time to walk away.

Thanks

Rob

paradigital

1,095 posts

180 months

Sunday 30th October 2022
quotequote all
Just assume that they are all awful, all lying in some way about the car, and that the warranty (unless manufacturer backed) is worthless.

I’m not suggesting all used dealers are useless, nor that you shouldn’t buy from one, but if you assume the worst and thus perform your due diligence with this in mind, you are less likely to be stung by something you could have caught before signing on the dotted.

Monkeylegend

28,935 posts

259 months

Sunday 30th October 2022
quotequote all
The dealers who gives you the keys and tell you to take as long a test drive as you want, and then makes no attempt to hard sell you anything, and makes no attempt to tell you how great the car is, only give factual information, and allows you to make your own decision with no pressure, they are the ones I trust.

The person selling the car is just as important to judge as the car itself and I think you get that instant gut feeling when you first meet them.

It has worked for me so far with both main dealers and the small guy.

Glenn63

3,864 posts

112 months

Sunday 30th October 2022
quotequote all
Tbh there’s not much to see on purchase anyway. Check history, bodywork etc but unless you can take a ramp with you to fully inspect and get a few hours test drive your not going to find out much.
Usually just from the online advert I get the feeling whether to keep looking elsewhere or not.
Or if its a more performance orientated/ rare car post the advert up on the model owners website/FB see if anyone knows the car.

Hugo Stiglitz

41,242 posts

239 months

Sunday 30th October 2022
quotequote all
Focus on the car itself. I've had bad experiences with both Toyota and Citroën main dealers and better with some indie. It appears the main dealers got a px in washed it and straight out the door warts and all.

It's all about the car.

nick1871

427 posts

140 months

Sunday 30th October 2022
quotequote all
As mentioned above, assume everything they say may be a lie. You need to check and double check all the details yourself, ask to see the history, ask for a pic of certain options that are important to you, a dealer saying it has these things is not enough.

Not saying all dealers will lie to you but you have got to look after your own interests because you can be sure they are looking after theirs.

ChrisH72

3,025 posts

80 months

Sunday 30th October 2022
quotequote all
Maybe I'm too trusting but I think most established dealers are okay. Its not in their interests to sell dodgy cars and they'd soon be out of business. However, there are good and bad cars and to be fair many dealers won't spot complex or potential issues which can occur down the line. It's all about after service if problems arise which you may get from reviews.

I know lots of people go for distance sales now to get better deals but I've always tried to buy fairly local so I don't have far to go back if necessary. Its worked well for me so far. My last two cars were from long established dealers in my home town.

I haven't bought privately for a while. But I did sell my last two cars privately. Although I did get better than trade price for them it was a stressful experience. Seems many private buyers expect dealer levels of service and also like to poke round your car for much longer than any dealer would put up with. They then feel like a hefty discount is obligatory. One even called me 6 months later to complain that the battery had died on a 10 year old car!

Trevor555

5,365 posts

112 months

Sunday 30th October 2022
quotequote all
I've bought quite a few cars in my time, understatement...

My worst experience was with a Bmw main dealer, closely followed by an Audi main dealer.

As stated already above, focus on the car it's self.

Even poor dealers get some good cars, along with the "not so good" ones.





Edited by Trevor555 on Sunday 30th October 10:19


Edited by Trevor555 on Sunday 30th October 10:20

popeyewhite

23,008 posts

148 months

Sunday 30th October 2022
quotequote all
Do your research, go in with eyes open. Both trade and private purchases have had serious issues appear once I've got the car home. Don't bother with a warranty unless it's a new Range Rover, put the money towards a repair fund. Keep a copy of all relevant adverts, text messages correspondence etc which may contain details of the car you've bought - details which later may turn out to be factually inaccurate. Basically cover your arse. I've just won a £3000 small claims case against dealer, my second sc case in 10 years. Remember your legal rights are different for a private sale, which is why I rarely bother.

QJumper

3,238 posts

54 months

Sunday 30th October 2022
quotequote all
Not sure there's much you can do beyond spotting the obviously dodgy ones. All I do is check over the car, and its history, as much as I can prior to purchase. A pre purchase inspection is a good idea too. Then, if I decide to buy, I try to be even more thorough going over everything in the first 30 days, when I still have the right to reject.

With prices similar between private and dealer sales, I'd always feel more comfortable with the consumer protection that comes with the latter.

ZX10R NIN

30,422 posts

153 months

Sunday 30th October 2022
quotequote all
Acuity30 said:
I've always bought private but these days private and trade sellers seem to want the same prices whereas before you could snatch a bargain from a private seller. However how do you know which used car dealers are just out to sell you a lemon and which are genuine?
You judge the car your buying not the dealer, even the best dealers in the world will have sold a few lemons it's the law of averages.

So do your checks as you would do when buying private & you'll be fine.



Hugo Stiglitz

41,242 posts

239 months

Sunday 30th October 2022
quotequote all
I buy privately when I can. My last night car last year was a 2015 120D 3 door. The one lady owner really looked after it. Premium tyres, serviced at a reputable BMW indie, no marks or scratches. I now regret selling it to my BIL!

Louis Balfour

28,176 posts

250 months

Sunday 30th October 2022
quotequote all
Rene Souffle said:
I always start with trust pilot. Seems to be a fairly good window into any company’s doings smile
Trustpilot: An infallible barometer of a company's quality.

Zumbruk

7,848 posts

288 months

Sunday 30th October 2022
quotequote all
paradigital said:
Just assume that they are all awful, all lying in some way about the car, and that the warranty (unless manufacturer backed) is worthless.

I’m not suggesting all used dealers are useless, nor that you shouldn’t buy from one, but if you assume the worst and thus perform your due diligence with this in mind, you are less likely to be stung by something you could have caught before signing on the dotted.
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^

This. Very much this.

FastEdd11e

205 posts

84 months

Sunday 30th October 2022
quotequote all
It's really hard, in our small experience.
We're not used to buying used cars so have tried small dealers for our last two. Both tried, one is still trying to scam us over a knackered car.

It's hard. Knowing the Consumer credit act is good, as is getting a proper inspection of the car.

Either way we are going to use a car broker next time.

Know the law and how to use it in your favor is the best thing I could mention. Make it know at point of sale.



popeyewhite

23,008 posts

148 months

Sunday 30th October 2022
quotequote all
FastEdd11e said:
It's really hard, in our small experience.
We're not used to buying used cars so have tried small dealers for our last two. Both tried, one is still trying to scam us over a knackered car.

It's hard. Knowing the Consumer credit act is good, as is getting a proper inspection of the car.

Either way we are going to use a car broker next time.

Know the law and how to use it in your favor is the best thing I could mention. Make it know at point of sale.
Consumer Rights (2015) !

037

1,368 posts

175 months

Sunday 30th October 2022
quotequote all
my limited experience is that they can't tell the truth. Also assume a blind person will prep your car for collection.