Is Autotrader the only option?
Is Autotrader the only option?
Author
Discussion

XJR500bhp

Original Poster:

1,205 posts

238 months

Tuesday 6th April 2021
quotequote all
Just wondered peoples thoughts, but does anyone feel they have a monopoly on that sector now? I just listed a private advert and it was £48 for two weeks. Judging by the number of cars for sale (I know the trade pay less but they don’t pay that much less, and I know this for a fact) they must be making a hefty sum, even when factoring in running the site. I wonder if anyone sees an opening for a competitor, but I guess I’m not sure what they could offer? Just seems very expensive to me, and I also now think that auto trader is over complicated.

Mammasaid

5,491 posts

125 months

Tuesday 6th April 2021
quotequote all
The irony is strong in this one


XJR500bhp

Original Poster:

1,205 posts

238 months

Tuesday 6th April 2021
quotequote all
Mammasaid said:
The irony is strong in this one

Yes I’m fully aware pistonheads exist and has a well populated classified section. But it’s not a touch on the amount of car auto trader list. And when selling a £3k focus, buyers of that car will rarely use PH

Ferruccio Fan

440 posts

68 months

Tuesday 6th April 2021
quotequote all
Ebay
Gumtree
Postcard in the newsagents window .
Leave it on the road with a sheet of paper "For sale " in the window .

sherman

15,186 posts

243 months

Tuesday 6th April 2021
quotequote all
Do you still get a free advert or 2 for being a member too. rofl?

Ferruccio Fan

440 posts

68 months

Tuesday 6th April 2021
quotequote all
As it's a 3K Focus , my last idea ^^ isn't that silly .

XJR500bhp

Original Poster:

1,205 posts

238 months

Tuesday 6th April 2021
quotequote all
Ferruccio Fan said:
Ebay
Gumtree
Postcard in the newsagents window .
Leave it on the road with a sheet of paper "For sale " in the window .
eBay isn’t cheap
Gumtree full of t”””s
Postcard I. Newsagent window isn’t a thing anymore
Leaving it on the road is almost impossible these days, tax etc, pissing off the council, insurance.

defblade

8,041 posts

241 months

Tuesday 6th April 2021
quotequote all
Ferruccio Fan said:
Ebay
Gumtree
Postcard in the newsagents window .
Leave it on the road with a sheet of paper "For sale " in the window .
Ferruccio Fan said:
As it's a 3K Focus , my last idea ^^ isn't that silly .
Yes it is. No-one needs the words "FOR SALE" on that bit of paper in the window. We know it's for sale, it's got a bit of paper in the window!

What we need on that bit of paper is the price, large enough to read while driving past.
Then some details and a contact number in a small font underneath.


(I've also knocked up a flag for the aerial, and a banner across the roof before now... but they each just had the price on!)

Edit: car&calssics is free, but has relatively few people looking as far as I can tell.

MiniMan64

19,300 posts

218 months

Tuesday 6th April 2021
quotequote all
Facebook Marketplace

Belle427

11,805 posts

261 months

Wednesday 7th April 2021
quotequote all
I’d stick it on Faceache marketplace and see what happens, you will still get some idiots contacting you but you can generally have some fun with them.
I personally don’t look on Pistonheads classifieds for everyday cheaper cars.

ChrisH72

3,068 posts

80 months

Wednesday 7th April 2021
quotequote all
Probably less bother to use webuyanycar.

But if you really want to sell privately then I'd say AT is the go to for most buyers. I sold my last car on AT in June last year. Went in 2 weeks to the first viewer. No hassle.

sociopath

3,433 posts

94 months

Wednesday 7th April 2021
quotequote all
XJR500bhp said:
Mammasaid said:
The irony is strong in this one

Yes I’m fully aware pistonheads exist and has a well populated classified section. But it’s not a touch on the amount of car auto trader list. And when selling a £3k focus, buyers of that car will rarely use PH
Which is why you pay the AT price surely?

Its not a monopoly by definition, and you're paying for a higher potential rate of hits.

AJB88

15,649 posts

199 months

Wednesday 7th April 2021
quotequote all
Facebook is easy but does come with a lot of agro, but my Leon FR 2005 on there the other week, in the end luckily a local lad had it.

I live in MK, had a bloke from Inverness messaging me.

Rozzers

3,046 posts

103 months

Wednesday 7th April 2021
quotequote all
Low value, try gumtree first then escalate, EBay next then AT last resort. Anything interesting I have goes on here.

Inspectorclueso

787 posts

280 months

Wednesday 7th April 2021
quotequote all
For what it's worth, I've used all methods on here barring faceache and gumtree'd over the years. Generally I've found an advert in the car / on the drive, good for very low value i.e. £2k or less, Pistonheads good for the more unusual cars, something that an enthusiast will be looking for and Autotrader good for average / mainstream upwards. I just sold an e class on Autotrader in a week, I've always found coverage to be very good. The way I look at it, £48 (I paid about £30 from memory so depends what package you go for I guess) is 1.6% of your asking price. You won't actually find many options with a sales cost that low and penetration so high in my experience.

Chris32345

2,141 posts

90 months

Wednesday 7th April 2021
quotequote all
Mammasaid said:
The irony is strong in this one

But virtually nobody uses that and others then the forum member's I bet most people haven't heard of this place for sellit cars

Ben Lowden

7,331 posts

205 months

PH Marketing Bloke

Wednesday 7th April 2021
quotequote all
Members of 10 years or more get free classifieds listings here, so certainly no harm in putting it on PH even if people do typically come here for performance/premium cars.

I've sold a few cheap cars on PH in the past including a Peugeot 306 shed – the buyer didn't want the hassle of sifting through cars elsewhere and assumed I'd taken good care of it as a PHer. Which is the very reason I started buying from PH many moons ago!

Richard-390a0

3,465 posts

119 months

Wednesday 7th April 2021
quotequote all
XJR500bhp said:
eBay isn’t cheap
eBay classified advert is £19.99 for a month with no further fees payable & yet you've paid £48 for two weeks on Autotrader?.

So more than double the cost for half of the timeframe & yet you say eBay isn't cheap!?!... confusedlaughjesterwobble

Wagonwheel555

909 posts

84 months

Wednesday 7th April 2021
quotequote all
Low value (sub £5k), I tend to stick it on Gumtree and Facebook MP first off, have had a couple of sales over the years. They are fine as long as you expect the eejits, chancers and scammers but just avoid responding to them. Worth a shot and its free so nothing to lose.

If I get no interest in a week or two, I tend to punt for Ebay and stick the starting price around what I want as a minimum. Ive sold a couple outside Ebay face to face where they messaged via Ebay and asked to buy privately so I just ended the listing once it was sold.

Last resort is Autotrader for me due to the cost involved but each to their own.

griffter

4,143 posts

283 months

Wednesday 7th April 2021
quotequote all
Autotrader has one of the best search interfaces IMHO. It could be a lot better but for identifying cars with features as opposed to make and model (obviously it does that too) it’s better than eBay, FB, Gumtree, exchange and mart, motors.co.uk, carandclassic etc. PH has some very helpful selectable features but doesn’t have the volume.

I think because AT is so relatively usable and accessible for enthusiast and non-enthusiast alike it’s popular with buyers and therefore they have the larger market segment and it appeals to sellers.