Wife needs a new car - opinions on our short list
Discussion
She's owned VW's for over 15yrs and she currently drives a mk5 1.6 FSi Match. It's done 90k miles and it needs replacing. We have a budget of circa £13k, she wants petrol (hates the smell of diesel) and the short list is as follows.
1. VW Golf MK7 1.4 Match Edition 122hp 2014 -14 plate - 15k miles
2. Seat Leon FR 1.4 150hp - 2015 - 15 plate - 10k miles
3. Vauxhall Astra 1.4 SRi Nav 150hp - 2016 - 66 plate - 3k miles
4. Mini Clubman Cooper S 190hp - 2013 - 13 plate - 20k miles
5. VW Beetle 1.4 TSi Sport 140hp - 2013 - 20k miles
She will be keeping it for 4 - 5 years and she does approx 15k miles a year
1. VW Golf MK7 1.4 Match Edition 122hp 2014 -14 plate - 15k miles
2. Seat Leon FR 1.4 150hp - 2015 - 15 plate - 10k miles
3. Vauxhall Astra 1.4 SRi Nav 150hp - 2016 - 66 plate - 3k miles
4. Mini Clubman Cooper S 190hp - 2013 - 13 plate - 20k miles
5. VW Beetle 1.4 TSi Sport 140hp - 2013 - 20k miles
She will be keeping it for 4 - 5 years and she does approx 15k miles a year
Consider a Mini Cooper 1.5 3 cylinder.
It's reasonably nippy (7.9s) economical and sounds great, really it does. You could for that budget of 13k perhaps get a 2015 with low miles and reasonably specced up. My OH drives one and it really is a great car, worth taking one out for test.
It's reasonably nippy (7.9s) economical and sounds great, really it does. You could for that budget of 13k perhaps get a 2015 with low miles and reasonably specced up. My OH drives one and it really is a great car, worth taking one out for test.
smiffy555 said:
You mean wait until the facelift is out and then the pre facelift cars will fall in value?
Potentially yes - or at least there might be more options around that time. Not sure what SEAT are doing but VW and Skoda are refreshing the octavia and golf with new tech inside with some styling tweaks.I am not a market expert though and you might find more choice rather than lower prices if you know what I mean.
Personally I didn't get on with the Leon inside, I just felt it was behind both skoda and VW. In the price range I was looking at meant you could be in a golf for similar money.
It is absolutely personal taste on the Leon, it did however drive sharper than the golf IMHO and felt more keen.
coldsnap said:
Consider a Mini Cooper 1.5 3 cylinder.
It's reasonably nippy (7.9s) economical and sounds great, really it does. You could for that budget of 13k perhaps get a 2015 with low miles and reasonably specced up. My OH drives one and it really is a great car, worth taking one out for test.
That's not a bad shout, BUT, she needs a boot. I had a R56 JCW 5 yrs ago and we found the boot 'limiting'. The rear seats were permanently down.It's reasonably nippy (7.9s) economical and sounds great, really it does. You could for that budget of 13k perhaps get a 2015 with low miles and reasonably specced up. My OH drives one and it really is a great car, worth taking one out for test.
I've had an Astra J for the last 2 years albeit the 160bhp diesel. Also had a 1.4 H in the past.
The J (10-16) is a huge step up in interior quality, in just over 2 years I'd replaced a glow plug beyond basic maintenance, it clocked 60k yesterday.
The 1.4's and turbo's aren't really that good for fuel economy, the 1.6 is better but if you're wanting economy then you wouldn't be looking at petrols.
We looked at focus's and golfs of the same age and the astra just offered so much more, we have the SE with half leather and bluetooth, got it 1k cheaper than a basic model petrol golf.
In terms of the H we had, it done 130k, we put 60k on it and it only needed the oil pickup pipe cleaning
The J (10-16) is a huge step up in interior quality, in just over 2 years I'd replaced a glow plug beyond basic maintenance, it clocked 60k yesterday.
The 1.4's and turbo's aren't really that good for fuel economy, the 1.6 is better but if you're wanting economy then you wouldn't be looking at petrols.
We looked at focus's and golfs of the same age and the astra just offered so much more, we have the SE with half leather and bluetooth, got it 1k cheaper than a basic model petrol golf.
In terms of the H we had, it done 130k, we put 60k on it and it only needed the oil pickup pipe cleaning
strain said:
I've had an Astra J for the last 2 years albeit the 160bhp diesel. Also had a 1.4 H in the past.
The J (10-16) is a huge step up in interior quality, in just over 2 years I'd replaced a glow plug beyond basic maintenance, it clocked 60k yesterday.
The 1.4's and turbo's aren't really that good for fuel economy, the 1.6 is better but if you're wanting economy then you wouldn't be looking at petrols.
We looked at focus's and golfs of the same age and the astra just offered so much more, we have the SE with half leather and bluetooth, got it 1k cheaper than a basic model petrol golf.
In terms of the H we had, it done 130k, we put 60k on it and it only needed the oil pickup pipe cleaning
Thanks for that glowing report on the Astra. I think the one we will be looking at is the new shape, K, I think it isThe J (10-16) is a huge step up in interior quality, in just over 2 years I'd replaced a glow plug beyond basic maintenance, it clocked 60k yesterday.
The 1.4's and turbo's aren't really that good for fuel economy, the 1.6 is better but if you're wanting economy then you wouldn't be looking at petrols.
We looked at focus's and golfs of the same age and the astra just offered so much more, we have the SE with half leather and bluetooth, got it 1k cheaper than a basic model petrol golf.
In terms of the H we had, it done 130k, we put 60k on it and it only needed the oil pickup pipe cleaning
The boot on the clubman is more useful than the hatch. It's also 80mm longer in the wheelbase and rides bumps much better.
Out of that list it would be the Leon, however have you considered the Focus ? We have just sold a Zetec S 1.0 125ps with the upgraded wheels, it was a 2013 car and went for £7999. It was a very nice car, drives better than the golfs although the plastics are not of the same quality.
Out of that list it would be the Leon, however have you considered the Focus ? We have just sold a Zetec S 1.0 125ps with the upgraded wheels, it was a 2013 car and went for £7999. It was a very nice car, drives better than the golfs although the plastics are not of the same quality.
Gassing Station | Car Buying | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff