Very Neigbourly indeed!

Author
Discussion

ruggedscotty

Original Poster:

5,798 posts

216 months

Wednesday 14th August
quotequote all
Had a request to cast my eye over something the other day....

A group of neighbours had managed to source a fast charger, then realised that it can only charge as quick as it can with the right supply...

They got a sparkie in who installed three isolation transformers, and then connected the transformers to the charger. three phases made from three seperate single phases....

All the wiring was good, right cable sizes and done so that their own RCD's were not affected.

checked supply and now they are getting a decent fast charge off of the charger.

Blue Oval84

5,284 posts

168 months

Wednesday 14th August
quotequote all
When you say "fast", how fast are we talking?

SpidersWeb

4,065 posts

180 months

Wednesday 14th August
quotequote all
That sounds like an awful lot of effort for a three phase supply, when very very few EVs can take a 22kW AC charge, so rather surprising that these three neighbours all own such cars.

Nomme de Plum

6,163 posts

23 months

Wednesday 14th August
quotequote all
I had a three phase 415v supply in my last house with the intent of using it for rapid charging but in the event sold the house so someone else will have the benefit. The supply was actually already there as the property had a large garage which was used for manufacturing.

I suppose it could be useful to have a couple in apartment complexes of places where people have no individual offstreet parking. The standard Ohme charger I have now is totally adequate for my needs.




Nomme de Plum

6,163 posts

23 months

Wednesday 14th August
quotequote all
Blue Oval84 said:
When you say "fast", how fast are we talking?
At 240V I think about 48kVA

Sheepshanks

35,059 posts

126 months

Wednesday 14th August
quotequote all
Nomme de Plum said:
I had a three phase 415v supply in my last house with the intent of using it for rapid charging but in the event sold the house so someone else will have the benefit.
....
I read somewhere recently that all new builds have to have three phase now.

motco

16,230 posts

253 months

Wednesday 14th August
quotequote all
How do they apportion the electricity cost among themselves?

Mr E

22,128 posts

266 months

Wednesday 14th August
quotequote all
SpidersWeb said:
That sounds like an awful lot of effort for a three phase supply, when very very few EVs can take a 22kW AC charge, so rather surprising that these three neighbours all own such cars.
All recent (at least 2019 on) teslas can take 22kw on three phase I believe.

Nomme de Plum

6,163 posts

23 months

Wednesday 14th August
quotequote all
Sheepshanks said:
Nomme de Plum said:
I had a three phase 415v supply in my last house with the intent of using it for rapid charging but in the event sold the house so someone else will have the benefit.
....
I read somewhere recently that all new builds have to have three phase now.
That is interesting. Presumably more driven by the eventual move to Heat Pumps. Seems a bit OTT in a modern highly insulated low energy house.

S6PNJ

5,354 posts

288 months

Wednesday 14th August
quotequote all
ruggedscotty said:
They got a sparkie in who installed three isolation transformers, and then connected the transformers to the charger. three phases made from three seperate single phases....
How did they change the phase of the 3 separate feeds? scratchchin

TheRainMaker

6,628 posts

249 months

Wednesday 14th August
quotequote all
S6PNJ said:
ruggedscotty said:
They got a sparkie in who installed three isolation transformers, and then connected the transformers to the charger. three phases made from three seperate single phases....
How did they change the phase of the 3 separate feeds? scratchchin
Sounds like they didn't, how did it get signed off.....

P675

361 posts

39 months

Wednesday 14th August
quotequote all
Charging 1 car at once taking turns etc. When you could just charge 3 at the same time whenever, great idea??

ashenfie

846 posts

53 months

Wednesday 14th August
quotequote all
Three phase power supplies are designed to breakdown into 3 separated 1 phase power supplies. Configured in this way its no longer a 3 phase charger as each user has only a single phase, but could supply up to 100 amp per phase (in the UK).

Assuming they all Tesla's they could do this, but most EVs can only charge at around 7kw from an AC power supply (as others have pointed out). Why you would want to got the expense it a great question. You need a cable running to a nearby 3 phase network outlet, 3 phase distribution board and a 3 phase qualified sparky to balance to power demand across the phases. Ho yes and a 3phase smart meter. They would have got a great solar and battery system for the same money.

Most people simply want to plug the car in over night and take advantage low rate tariffs.

Mr Pointy

11,859 posts

166 months

Wednesday 14th August
quotequote all
TheRainMaker said:
Sounds like they didn't, how did it get signed off.....
Isn't the OP an electrician? I'm sure he would have reported it if there was anything dubious going on.

SpidersWeb

4,065 posts

180 months

Wednesday 14th August
quotequote all
Mr E said:
SpidersWeb said:
That sounds like an awful lot of effort for a three phase supply, when very very few EVs can take a 22kW AC charge, so rather surprising that these three neighbours all own such cars.
All recent (at least 2019 on) teslas can take 22kw on three phase I believe.
I don't believe so - www.tesla.com/en_gb/support/charging/onboard-charg...

As with a lot of such 'three phase' cars a Tesla can only charge at 11kW not the 22kW the EVSE can supply due to the limitations of the onboard charger, and frankly 11kW isn't going to charge an awful lot faster than a 7.4kW EVSE.

Those which can charge at the full 22kW are pretty limited - www.evspecs.org/electric-cars-ac-charging-comparis...

V8 Stang

4,402 posts

190 months

Wednesday 14th August
quotequote all
SpidersWeb said:
I don't believe so - www.tesla.com/en_gb/support/charging/onboard-charg...

As with a lot of such 'three phase' cars a Tesla can only charge at 11kW not the 22kW the EVSE can supply due to the limitations of the onboard charger, and frankly 11kW isn't going to charge an awful lot faster than a 7.4kW EVSE.

Those which can charge at the full 22kW are pretty limited - www.evspecs.org/electric-cars-ac-charging-comparis...
My lowly Nissan Townstar van charges at 22KW, its pretty poor of other EV manufacturers to not make this standard, as its so much quicker. Just over 2 hours does me around 40KW charge.



Sheepshanks

35,059 posts

126 months

Wednesday 14th August
quotequote all
TheRainMaker said:
S6PNJ said:
ruggedscotty said:
They got a sparkie in who installed three isolation transformers, and then connected the transformers to the charger. three phases made from three seperate single phases....
How did they change the phase of the 3 separate feeds? scratchchin
Sounds like they didn't, how did it get signed off.....
There’s usually 3 phase in the street and then the phases are shared out every 3 houses. Don’t know how the electrician would determine that with certainty though.

Mr E

22,128 posts

266 months

Wednesday 14th August
quotequote all
SpidersWeb said:
Mr E said:
SpidersWeb said:
That sounds like an awful lot of effort for a three phase supply, when very very few EVs can take a 22kW AC charge, so rather surprising that these three neighbours all own such cars.
All recent (at least 2019 on) teslas can take 22kw on three phase I believe.
I don't believe so - www.tesla.com/en_gb/support/charging/onboard-charg...

As with a lot of such 'three phase' cars a Tesla can only charge at 11kW not the 22kW the EVSE can supply due to the limitations of the onboard charger, and frankly 11kW isn't going to charge an awful lot faster than a 7.4kW EVSE.

Those which can charge at the full 22kW are pretty limited - www.evspecs.org/electric-cars-ac-charging-comparis...
You’re right. smile
I remembered it could do 3 phase. I forgot it didn’t do it at 7.6kw per phase.

I’ve never used 3 phase.

TheDeuce

25,227 posts

73 months

Wednesday 14th August
quotequote all
Sheepshanks said:
TheRainMaker said:
S6PNJ said:
ruggedscotty said:
They got a sparkie in who installed three isolation transformers, and then connected the transformers to the charger. three phases made from three seperate single phases....
How did they change the phase of the 3 separate feeds? scratchchin
Sounds like they didn't, how did it get signed off.....
There’s usually 3 phase in the street and then the phases are shared out every 3 houses. Don’t know how the electrician would determine that with certainty though.
It's certainly possible but would take some faffing about and fly leads to the main feed in each house, which would be one of the three potential phases, into each. I'm not sure if in some cases the DNO might have the info too..?

My biggest question would be why bother to put the phases back into a 3ph supply to a 22kw charger, instead of 3 discreet 1ph 7kw chargers. One per house... I'd have thought they'd get a lot more overall charging done that way. Perhaps the three houses somehow shared a single off street parking space!?

tr3a

576 posts

234 months

Wednesday 14th August
quotequote all
Mr E said:
SpidersWeb said:
That sounds like an awful lot of effort for a three phase supply, when very very few EVs can take a 22kW AC charge, so rather surprising that these three neighbours all own such cars.
All recent (at least 2019 on) teslas can take 22kw on three phase I believe.
Nope. Some early Model S could, but since the Model 3, all Tesla cars do 11kW max on three phase.