Mpg "equivalent" on a plug-in hybrid - why so difficult?

Mpg "equivalent" on a plug-in hybrid - why so difficult?

Author
Discussion

clockworks

Original Poster:

5,944 posts

150 months

Wednesday 8th November 2023
quotequote all
3 weeks into owning my first PHEV, a 2021 XC40 T5

Very happy with the car, and I can do most of my driving in Pure electric mode, at less than 4p a mile. The range display tallies pretty close to the actual mileage driven, and the smart plug/granny charger combo tells me that charging losses are averaging around 16%. All pretty straightforward - as long as I'm doing a short journey just using the battery.

Today I did a 46 mile round trip, with 5 stops. Obviously too far for just the battery (27 mile range), so I used pure electric mode for the low speed parts, and hybrid for the faster parts.

At the end, the car told me I'd averaged 66mpg, and had 5 miles of battery range left. The app "driving journal" breaks it down into 6 individual trips, and shows mileage, kwh used, kwh regenerated, and a rough guess of petrol used for each leg.

To accurately work out a cost for the trip, or an "mpg equivalent", I need to add the trip mpg and the kwh taken to recharge overnight, and do some maths. Not too bad for a single day, but would get messy over a full tank of fuel, which might last a couple of months.

Very easy on an ICE car, just reset the trip computer each time the tank is brimmed, 30 seconds with a calculator to work out the true mpg, and compare with what the car thinks the average mpg was. Do that a few times, get an average "correction factor", and then I can just apply that to what the car says - for example, if car says I got 50mpg, and I know it's 5% optimistic, I actually got 47.5mpg. Job done.

On today's example, it will probably work out at the equivalent of around 55mpg, but I won't know for sure until tomorrow when the car has been recharged.

The whole efficency thing with plug-ins is a mess. Official figures are pure fantasy, and I can see why now.
Maybe I should just not "worry" about it, but it's hard to change what I've done for 45 years in ICE cars.

Big Nanas

1,825 posts

89 months

Wednesday 8th November 2023
quotequote all
I feel your pain. I had a Vauxhall Ampera for four years from new a few years ago and really enjoyed. However the MPG calculation was very basic. Essentially my 'lifetime MPG' when I handed it back was 175mpg, but that doesn't take into account how much I spent charging.
Still, the 50 mile range was sufficient for the vast majority of my journeys.