Home charger advise

Author
Discussion

Paul Drawmer

4,938 posts

272 months

Friday 28th June
quotequote all
SpidersWeb said:
Have you ever encountered any electricians?
They do tend to know how to charge.

Paul Drawmer

4,938 posts

272 months

Friday 28th June
quotequote all
JD said:
Running at 10A continuously for a few hours, a 13A socket/plug will get extremely hot to the touch, and the pins can sometimes scorch the socket.

As above mentioned, you should not be running 13A continuously from a socket, it invites disaster.
That's not true. If the electrics are OK 10A continuous is fine.

When I had to use a 10A granny charger for a few weeks, I was advised to plug it in and then check the plug and socket to see if it was getting warm after 30min and then 1Hr.
It shouldn't get warm; but worn or loose contacts can do so, and for extended load times need monitoring.

TheDrownedApe

1,157 posts

61 months

Friday 28th June
quotequote all
Paul Drawmer said:
JD said:
Running at 10A continuously for a few hours, a 13A socket/plug will get extremely hot to the touch, and the pins can sometimes scorch the socket.

As above mentioned, you should not be running 13A continuously from a socket, it invites disaster.
That's not true. If the electrics are OK 10A continuous is fine.

When I had to use a 10A granny charger for a few weeks, I was advised to plug it in and then check the plug and socket to see if it was getting warm after 30min and then 1Hr.
It shouldn't get warm; but worn or loose contacts can do so, and for extended load times need monitoring.
so having used it plenty of times i can say that:

long coiled extension leads don't like the constant power and melt.
short, cheap extension leads............melt
good quality extension leads are fine.
every plug socket has been fine.

smn159

13,303 posts

222 months

Friday 28th June
quotequote all
Paul Drawmer said:
SpidersWeb said:
Have you ever encountered any electricians?
They do tend to know how to charge.
They'll be using current rates though

andyspiers

52 posts

200 months

Friday 28th June
quotequote all
the-norseman said:
She came down last weekend and had about 46% charge left when she got here
She used 54% of her battery to get to your house.

So, to get back home she also only needs 54% of battery, but it would be sensible to add a 10% margin for safety, so let's say she needs to charge back up to 64% from 46% to get home safely - in other words she needs to add 18%.

A full charge (0-100%) on a granny charger may take 32 hours but she only needs to add 18% - that would take just under 6h.

I suggest you definitely don't need to spend £1000 on a home charger for her if you have a decent quality 3-pin socket reachable from your drive (see other comments about checking it doesn't get warm/hot the first time you use it).

LaserTam

2,132 posts

224 months

Friday 28th June
quotequote all
andyspiers said:
the-norseman said:
She came down last weekend and had about 46% charge left when she got here
She used 54% of her battery to get to your house.

So, to get back home she also only needs 54% of battery, but it would be sensible to add a 10% margin for safety, so let's say she needs to charge back up to 64% from 46% to get home safely - in other words she needs to add 18%.

A full charge (0-100%) on a granny charger may take 32 hours but she only needs to add 18% - that would take just under 6h.

I suggest you definitely don't need to spend £1000 on a home charger for her if you have a decent quality 3-pin socket reachable from your drive (see other comments about checking it doesn't get warm/hot the first time you use it).
Or, if only a relatively small charge is required, use a fast charger somewhere. Will only take 10 mins and cost will be relatively low.

the-norseman

Original Poster:

13,177 posts

176 months

Friday 28th June
quotequote all
We have a waterproof socket on the drive way so she can charge, I will try the 3 pin plug charger next time shes down here.

the-norseman

Original Poster:

13,177 posts

176 months

Saturday 13th July
quotequote all
Haven't tried the 3 pin plug yet.

Our nearest "fast charger" which is 120kw is 0.85p per kwh, yesterday we found a 300kw charger for 0.63p a few minutes walk from ASDA so parked up and left it there for an hour, went from 23% to 100% in an hour.

SpidersWeb

4,065 posts

178 months

Saturday 13th July
quotequote all
the-norseman said:
yesterday we found a 300kw charger for 0.63p
So about the same price as petrol - not worth you spending £1,000 getting a charger installed for that for the occasions when your mother visits and needs to charge her car.

the-norseman said:
Our nearest "fast charger" which is 120kw is 0.85p per kwh
Although that is 35% more expensive than petrol, which as an aside, it is a pretty good demonstrations of why EVs (unless you are doing salary sacrifice) only make sense economically if you somewhere at home which you can charge them.

Hard to see that the government will be content to allow that two tier situation to persist in the long term.

Phunk

2,009 posts

176 months

Saturday 13th July
quotequote all
One thing to remember is that at this time of year she’ll be getting good efficiency, come winter she’ll use a 1/4 more to get to you.

I’d recommend downloading the Tesla app and see if there is a charger on her route to/from you. Charge costs are approx 40p a kWh. Should only take 10 minutes as she’ll only need enough to get home not a full charge.

Another option is to look at getting a 32amp commando socket installed which’ll be significantly cheaper than a dedicated home charger. My parents did this and their entire install including the charge cable was under £500.

SpidersWeb

4,065 posts

178 months

Saturday 13th July
quotequote all
Phunk said:
I’d recommend downloading the Tesla app and see if there is a charger on her route to/from you. Charge costs are approx 40p a kWh. Should only take 10 minutes as she’ll only need enough to get home not a full charge.
To save around £10 would I be suggesting that a parent with a mobility car did that, rather than just charging it for them when they visited me - I don't believe I would.

Phunk said:
Another option is to look at getting a 32amp commando socket installed which’ll be significantly cheaper than a dedicated home charger. My parents did this and their entire install including the charge cable was under £500.
The OP didn't say how often his mother made the 2 1/2 hour journey to see them but would take around 30 visits to break even doing that, and it seems doubtful that it would make economic sense to incur that cost.

the-norseman

Original Poster:

13,177 posts

176 months

Saturday 13th July
quotequote all
Mum comes down often to see us because our lad who is 2 is her first grand child, the car is on Motability so shes got it for 3 years.

If she made 10 trips a year for 3 years that would be the same as the home charger I suspect she will make more than 10.

Phunk

2,009 posts

176 months

Saturday 13th July
quotequote all
SpidersWeb said:
Phunk said:
I’d recommend downloading the Tesla app and see if there is a charger on her route to/from you. Charge costs are approx 40p a kWh. Should only take 10 minutes as she’ll only need enough to get home not a full charge.
To save around £10 would I be suggesting that a parent with a mobility car did that, rather than just charging it for them when they visited me - I don't believe I would.

Phunk said:
Another option is to look at getting a 32amp commando socket installed which’ll be significantly cheaper than a dedicated home charger. My parents did this and their entire install including the charge cable was under £500.
The OP didn't say how often his mother made the 2 1/2 hour journey to see them but would take around 30 visits to break even doing that, and it seems doubtful that it would make economic sense to incur that cost.
Whilst a granny charger may give enough range for the return journey at the moment. Come the depths of winter I doubt it would. Hence the other options.

SpidersWeb

4,065 posts

178 months

Sunday 14th July
quotequote all
Phunk said:
SpidersWeb said:
Phunk said:
I’d recommend downloading the Tesla app and see if there is a charger on her route to/from you. Charge costs are approx 40p a kWh. Should only take 10 minutes as she’ll only need enough to get home not a full charge.
To save around £10 would I be suggesting that a parent with a mobility car did that, rather than just charging it for them when they visited me - I don't believe I would.

Phunk said:
Another option is to look at getting a 32amp commando socket installed which’ll be significantly cheaper than a dedicated home charger. My parents did this and their entire install including the charge cable was under £500.
The OP didn't say how often his mother made the 2 1/2 hour journey to see them but would take around 30 visits to break even doing that, and it seems doubtful that it would make economic sense to incur that cost.
Whilst a granny charger may give enough range for the return journey at the moment. Come the depths of winter I doubt it would. Hence the other options.
They hadn't used a granny charger the last time, but simply took the car to a nearby commercial charger to top up.

Granny chargers are for when you are in the absolute middle of nowhere when you have zero charge and can't get to a commercial. charger, which these days is pretty rare and why a lot of EV manufacturers no longer supply them with the car.

Phunk

2,009 posts

176 months

Sunday 14th July
quotequote all
the-norseman said:
Haven't tried the 3 pin plug yet.

Our nearest "fast charger" which is 120kw is 0.85p per kwh, yesterday we found a 300kw charger for 0.63p a few minutes walk from ASDA so parked up and left it there for an hour, went from 23% to 100% in an hour.
Be careful with leaving the car to charge fully, some rapid charge sites have overstay fees if you leave it plugged in whilst full.

Best to move away from the same mentality of filling the car full like you would with a petrol car and just get what you need.

The charge rate on the BZ4X drops off below 50kw after around 70%, so I’d aim roughly for that or what you need to get home.

Actual

959 posts

111 months

Sunday 14th July
quotequote all
TheDrownedApe said:
every plug socket has been fine.
Charging at 10A with a 3 pin "should" be fine if used within rated capacity,

It is obvious if the plugs, sockets and leads are getting hot or melting.

If using an EV tariff which starts at midnight then more savings can be made by using the dishwasher, washing machine and tumble dryer so set all running at max and go to bed.

What you can't see is what is happening to your ring final wiring buried in your walls and running through your ceilings and using the dodgy junction box that was installed years ago.

What could possibly go wrong?

We have 2 PHEV and we charge both using 3 pin plugs from midnight every night and we get max use of the dishwasher, washing machine and tumble dryer and it is safe because the required protected ring final circuits have been added to the electrical consumer unit.

the-norseman

Original Poster:

13,177 posts

176 months

Sunday 14th July
quotequote all
Plugged it into the 3 point last night, was going to take 14 hours to get it from 71% to 100% so just unplugged it again, 70% will get her home later.

the-norseman

Original Poster:

13,177 posts

176 months

Sunday 14th July
quotequote all
the-norseman said:
Haven't tried the 3 pin plug yet.

Our nearest "fast charger" which is 120kw is 0.85p per kwh, yesterday we found a 300kw charger for 0.63p a few minutes walk from ASDA so parked up and left it there for an hour, went from 23% to 100% in an hour.
So I worked out when it was full that mum had paid around £34 for the 23% to 100% charge at 0.63p but... they took a £30 pre-authorisation which has been refunded today and they have now charged £48.. looks like they charged her for staying plugged in once it was charged.

SpidersWeb

4,065 posts

178 months

Monday 15th July
quotequote all
the-norseman said:
but... they took a £30 pre-authorisation which has been refunded today
Exactly the same as when you pay by card at a petrol pump.

the-norseman said:
and they have now charged £48.. looks like they charged her for staying plugged in once it was charged.
Exactly the same as if you left your car at a petrol pump after filling up.

The first is irrelevant as the money comes back, and for the second, I suggest that she checks the settings in the app for her car as most will send you a notification when the car is 10-15 minutes away from the charge target you have set in order that you have time to get back and move it.

the-norseman

Original Poster:

13,177 posts

176 months

Monday 15th July
quotequote all
The Toyota app is poor to be honest.