Carbon wrapping

Carbon wrapping

Author
Discussion

JDH1

Original Poster:

1,015 posts

246 months

Sunday 11th July 2021
quotequote all
I've been offered a 720 which has an excellent spec from a functionality perspective but no exterior carbon at all. It's not a deal breaker but wondered if anyone has gone down the route of carbon wrapping the parts normally covered in packs 1, 2 or 3 and if so, any thoughts on the result and recommendations.

davek_964

9,293 posts

182 months

Sunday 11th July 2021
quotequote all
I assume the mirrors would be included in the things you want carbon. At least with PPF, mirrors have to be wrapped in two pieces - so I assume that would be true of carbon wrap too. Not sure that would look great.

captainblakk

269 posts

223 months

Sunday 11th July 2021
quotequote all
I’d be interested in seeing any results, I have Paladium exterior parts mostly, the rear diffuser in particular would be a challenge to carbon wrap for sure

Fezzamania

220 posts

42 months

Sunday 11th July 2021
quotequote all
Wrap or hydro dipping ?
I think both are possibilities.
TBH if I was ordering a new 720S I would go with the MSO black pack.
The gloss black looks good to me at a fraction of price and you don't have to worry to much about damaging an expensive carbon part.

Ok real carbon is wonderful but never worth the added expense from new. Better value 2nd hand though where someone else has burdened the majority of cost

LaurasOtherHalf

21,429 posts

203 months

Sunday 11th July 2021
quotequote all
Isn’t it the sort of thing people snort at if it were a Corsa owned by a teenager?

A contrasting colour if anything but I think fake carbon is the height of naff.

Rocketreid

655 posts

79 months

Sunday 11th July 2021
quotequote all
JDH1 said:
I've been offered a 720 which has an excellent spec from a functionality perspective but no exterior carbon at all. It's not a deal breaker but wondered if anyone has gone down the route of carbon wrapping the parts normally covered in packs 1, 2 or 3 and if so, any thoughts on the result and recommendations.
It would be virtually impossible to replicate the 3 exterior carbon packs entirely with a wrap or dip, although possible to do some parts. Whether the finish is any good depends on who does it etc.

In any event it will almost certainly devalue the resale.

Best to leave as it is or replace with Carbon parts as funds allow

Fezzamania

220 posts

42 months

Sunday 11th July 2021
quotequote all
Rocketreid said:
It would be virtually impossible to replicate the 3 exterior carbon packs entirely with a wrap or dip, although possible to do some parts. Whether the finish is any good depends on who does it etc.

In any event it will almost certainly devalue the resale.

Best to leave as it is or replace with Carbon parts as funds allow
If its easily reversible I personally don't see it devaluing car ar resale as you simply remove it pre sale or as part of the deal.
I'm not a fan of wraps personally but depending on the quality of material and install its hard to spot difference IMHO - its the 1m test, ok up close and under close scruitniatuon you can spot it but from 1m 99% wont

JDH1

Original Poster:

1,015 posts

246 months

Sunday 11th July 2021
quotequote all
Interesting replies. Opinions vary but I'd only be interested if it was done really well, hence the question whether anyone has done it on a 720s and how it looks.

As an aside, what are opinions on carbon parts? Wondering whether I've been brainwashed into wanting it? Wouldn't really think about it on a Porsche, say, and most 'laymen' wouldn't notice it anyway.

LaurasOtherHalf

21,429 posts

203 months

Sunday 11th July 2021
quotequote all
JDH1 said:
Interesting replies. Opinions vary but I'd only be interested if it was done really well, hence the question whether anyone has done it on a 720s and how it looks.

As an aside, what are opinions on carbon parts? Wondering whether I've been brainwashed into wanting it? Wouldn't really think about it on a Porsche, say, and most 'laymen' wouldn't notice it anyway.
It’s like anything that’s nice though isn’t it? I had zero interest in carbon bits on Porsches until I saw a mega spec’d GT2RSwp with all the exposed carbon and against my better judgement thought it looked amazing. Once seen, anything less would have been a bit of a disappointment.


r o n n i e

382 posts

183 months

Sunday 11th July 2021
quotequote all
LaurasOtherHalf said:
Isn’t it the sort of thing people snort at if it were a Corsa owned by a teenager?

A contrasting colour if anything but I think fake carbon is the height of naff.
How’s this any different to when ordering from new?

Exposed Carbon fibre look vs palladium finish look is just that, the external visual look.

Did you think the palladium components are made out of palladium and only the carbon fibre look components are made of CF?!?!

To be clear all these components are made of the same CF materials irrespective of which finish you select.

Fezzamania

220 posts

42 months

Sunday 11th July 2021
quotequote all
My understanding is palladium is just painted plastic hence why the real carbon fibre components are so expensive. Its not just a top coat finish difference from what I have been told.
Ok the carbon is sold as being lightweight but lets face it the difference between a plastic panel and a real carbon fibre panel is negligible

Rocketreid

655 posts

79 months

Sunday 11th July 2021
quotequote all
McLaren carbon parts are pre-preg dry carbon and I don’t think any of the palladium is painted CF, it’s plastic.

My 720S is fully loaded but I did have 2 parts which were not CF and so replaced them.

The weight difference was not massive but actually across the whole car it would add up.

CF is though largely vanity and aesthetics as it’s function is identical to CF

r o n n i e

382 posts

183 months

Sunday 11th July 2021
quotequote all
Maybe it varies with Mclaren model. I know for my 600LT I was just paying extra for exposed carbon fibre visual look.

The sales person and sales brochure is clear that the “palladium” parts are CF:


BlackR8

463 posts

84 months

Sunday 11th July 2021
quotequote all
I believe the likes of Topaz and others now do something called Carbon Skin which is real Carbon Fibre used to cover the parts with matching weave etc. I am sure it wont be as cheap as normal vinyl wrap but could be worth considering.

The Surveyor

7,584 posts

244 months

Monday 12th July 2021
quotequote all
r o n n i e said:
Maybe it varies with Mclaren model. ......
It does... the Palladium sections on my 570s were painted plastic.

Streetbeat

1,071 posts

83 months

Monday 12th July 2021
quotequote all
Fezzamania said:
I'm not a fan of wraps personally but depending on the quality of material and install its hard to spot difference IMHO - its the 1m test, ok up close and under close scruitniatuon you can spot it but from 1m 99% wont
There is absolutely zero chance you will get any carbon wrap or dip to immitate the herring bone carbon on Mclaren bumpers/engine covers.

Flat panels "may" pass from a 1m test, but nothing with a shape (mirrors/side intakes) will come remotely close and if someone does spot its wrap/dip i would be personally be more than a little embarrased that the "carbon" on your 150k plus supercar, isnt!!



Fezzamania

220 posts

42 months

Monday 12th July 2021
quotequote all
Streetbeat said:
There is absolutely zero chance you will get any carbon wrap or dip to immitate the herring bone carbon on Mclaren bumpers/engine covers.

Flat panels "may" pass from a 1m test, but nothing with a shape (mirrors/side intakes) will come remotely close and if someone does spot its wrap/dip i would be personally be more than a little embarrased that the "carbon" on your 150k plus supercar, isnt!!
I was shown a side intake on a 650S that had a Hexus wrap that was an exact match to the mclaren weave and didnt notice the difference to front and rear bumper which was real carbon until the owner pointed it out to me and even then it was hard to tell.

Agree it may not be possible on highly curved parts like the wing mirrors due to the stretching potentially distorting the weave pattern in the wrap but with large flat panels it seemed great to me as a novice.
Maybe I'm easily fooled

MDL111

7,169 posts

184 months

Tuesday 13th July 2021
quotequote all
LaurasOtherHalf said:
Isn’t it the sort of thing people snort at if it were a Corsa owned by a teenager?

A contrasting colour if anything but I think fake carbon is the height of naff.
Like buying a gold Rolex from a street vendor at the corner ....

xcentric

722 posts

226 months

Tuesday 13th July 2021
quotequote all
JDH1 said:
As an aside, what are opinions on carbon parts? Wondering whether I've been brainwashed into wanting it? Wouldn't really think about it on a Porsche, say, and most 'laymen' wouldn't notice it anyway.
It's really down to aesthetics, and often at the expense of practicality - the performance difference is zero for road use, the weight difference probably about what a packet of sandwiches might be. For some things it does look good, but it's a personal preference. For other things, it's a bit of a pain - having a low front splitter (on any car) in carbon is asking for expensive hassle all the time as it bottoms out on a harsh compression, scrapes a speed bump, or similar - parts there need to be more sacrificial in form than jewel-like in appearance. For an engine cover, then the aesthetics make a big difference. Sometimes the carbon packs bring something else (e.g. the 570s interior carbon brings bigger (carbon) paddles which are easier to find. Depends on what you like and want.

The practicality argument works the other way on resale, however: typically Ferraris have to have certain carbon packs for easy resale, and it seems to be the case that some Mc's are in that camp - but my observation would be that most Mc people are keener drivers and so the dynamics is of greater importance to them than the presence or absence of the carbon. Having said that, I would expect the price to reflect the lack of it by being lower.

Red9zero

7,880 posts

64 months

Tuesday 13th July 2021
quotequote all
Not quite the same, but I saw on the Yiannimize (don't judge me laugh) YouTube channel some carbon effect ppf that looked quite good. Might be worth a look.