63 - 73 Sweet Spot

63 - 73 Sweet Spot

Author
Discussion

Andyboy

Original Poster:

99 posts

207 months

Saturday 1st October 2022
quotequote all
What is considered to be the best engine and model of the age range mentioned in the title?

Ta

julian987R

6,840 posts

66 months

Saturday 1st October 2022
quotequote all
1973 RS

Koln-RS

3,964 posts

219 months

Saturday 1st October 2022
quotequote all
How deep are your pockets?
Normally it’s the ‘S’ models - 2.0, 2.2 and 2.4 that are most desirable, although the 2.4E is also a quite well regarded ‘sweet spot’.

The 2.7RS used to be one of the most sought after ‘blue chip’ classics, but they seem to have a lesser following these days and don’t seem to command the top level prices they used to. Perhaps the current market is more nouveau-riche, and those people would rather have a Singer.

Andyboy

Original Poster:

99 posts

207 months

Sunday 2nd October 2022
quotequote all
They’re not deep enough for an RS model but I do want to get the next best thing in both engine and specification. I better start trawling through the adverts.

BorkBorkBork

731 posts

58 months

Sunday 2nd October 2022
quotequote all
Andyboy said:
They’re not deep enough for an RS model but I do want to get the next best thing in both engine and specification. I better start trawling through the adverts.
I know it’s just outside your age bracket, but what about a ‘74 2.7 MFI? Same engine as the ‘73 RS, but in an improved package overall. And less than half the price.

blackmamba

825 posts

243 months

Sunday 2nd October 2022
quotequote all
Any of the MFI engines are very good, throttle response is fabulous. An S or RS spec engine is wonderful, even if in a T or E spec car. Depends on your budget and whether you are looking for something original or modified.

Andyboy

Original Poster:

99 posts

207 months

Sunday 2nd October 2022
quotequote all
Well I’m hoping for a long term investment so originality is important to me, I’ve had a couple of 356’s in the past and always promised myself that the next car I would get would be an early 911.

ChrisW.

6,827 posts

262 months

Sunday 2nd October 2022
quotequote all
The first of the impact bumper '74 / 5 / (6) Carrera had the 2.7RS engine at a much more modest price ... ??

The only real difference was cast alloy rear suspension arms ....

Otherwise 2.4S ??

GTRene

17,774 posts

231 months

Sunday 2nd October 2022
quotequote all
a 911 R could be nice, 800kg but sadly very rare, but I guess very raw as well.

https://www.classicdriver.com/en/article/cars/ferd...

julian987R

6,840 posts

66 months

Sunday 2nd October 2022
quotequote all
There are so few RHD ones for sale.....noticed that?

This one jumps out as a nice one

https://www.carandclassic.com/car/C1481347


julian987R

6,840 posts

66 months

Sunday 2nd October 2022
quotequote all
GTRene said:
a 911 R could be nice, 800kg but sadly very rare, but I guess very raw as well.

https://www.classicdriver.com/en/article/cars/ferd...
That particular one is for sale

https://www.classicdriver.com/en/car/porsche/911/1...


GTRene

17,774 posts

231 months

Monday 3rd October 2022
quotequote all
julian987R said:
lovely, good find thumbup

I just went through hundreds porsche for sale on mobile de :-) also those from 1963-1975 and later higher up.
many lovely examples also some for say around 50k which were restored...
but most good lookers cost more, specially if you looking for a bit more power, but I was amazed that there are still a lot also original and renewed/restored for not crazy money.

today I saw a video posted in another thread about back dating and so on, which was about a big german restaurer with hundreds of examples in all states and how they restore and more, you better not look, because it will trigger you to look into porsche ads again lol.

but those there were a few hundred thousand euro's... so with that in mind, those on mobile look cheap :-) compared to, ofcourse most you can not compare, but still, you can have a lot fun for a lot less.

I also like those ST replicas when well done.

julian987R

6,840 posts

66 months

Monday 3rd October 2022
quotequote all
GTRene said:
lovely, good find thumbup

I just went through hundreds porsche for sale on mobile de :-) also those from 1963-1975 and later higher up.
many lovely examples also some for say around 50k which were restored...
but most good lookers cost more, specially if you looking for a bit more power, but I was amazed that there are still a lot also original and renewed/restored for not crazy money.

today I saw a video posted in another thread about back dating and so on, which was about a big german restaurer with hundreds of examples in all states and how they restore and more, you better not look, because it will trigger you to look into porsche ads again lol.

but those there were a few hundred thousand euro's... so with that in mind, those on mobile look cheap :-) compared to, ofcourse most you can not compare, but still, you can have a lot fun for a lot less.

I also like those ST replicas when well done.
That was me that posted that restoration documentary in the other thread - brilliant isn't it.

Have you tried https://www.elferspot.com/en/find/porsche-for-sale... that is a good place, as if you are looking at mobile.de then I assume you don't mind LHD. The cream of the crop is often listed on Elferspot (including those by the Early911S company featured in the documentary).





gary71

1,981 posts

186 months

Monday 3rd October 2022
quotequote all
Usual answer to this question is 72/73 2.4S, but downside it that they are second to the RS in terms of value.

2.4 ‘72 Last of the chrome horn grilles/lights and external oil filler
2.4 ‘73 very last small bumper car (and 7R crankcase like the RS)

But any of the LWB cars (‘69 onwards) can hold its own in modern traffic and any of the engine derivatives will still provide endless enjoyment. Just pick your power level/budget.

SWB cars are still perfectly competent, but more towards the ‘character’ end of the classic market.

Ultimately buy on condition, not the exact model as costs on body and engine restoration can spiral rapidly if you get a bad one.

RiccardoG

1,664 posts

279 months

Monday 3rd October 2022
quotequote all

Silly question, but were there also non MFI 2.7s? I seem to recall that a few years ago these were the runt of the litter in terms of earlier 911s, followed by the 964 (which I had at the time).

Or are all 2.7s impact bumper 911s the same engine?

Robbo66

3,875 posts

240 months

Monday 3rd October 2022
quotequote all
Koln-RS said:
How deep are your pockets?
Normally it’s the ‘S’ models - 2.0, 2.2 and 2.4 that are most desirable, although the 2.4E is also a quite well regarded ‘sweet spot’.

The 2.7RS used to be one of the most sought after ‘blue chip’ classics, but they seem to have a lesser following these days and don’t seem to command the top level prices they used to. Perhaps the current market is more nouveau-riche, and those people would rather have a Singer.
This. I sold my 73RS back in 2021 as had an offer I couldn't refuse, and became too valuable to thrash about. I'd had it for 12 years, taken to the Alps, tracked it etc...fantastic car. However, no way on earth would I pay for one at todays value. They are good, but not £400k better than a 911S.

I also agree that the noveau-riche brigade have swapped to the Singer, with its otters pelt arm rest and Kardashian backside etc, and stalled the values of the 73RS.

The whole market is way too 'toppy' IMV, but if it weren't I would secure a good 911S or SWB 65 all day long. For now though, powder dry....winter is coming in more ways than one.

Cheib

23,755 posts

182 months

Monday 3rd October 2022
quotequote all
BorkBorkBork said:
Andyboy said:
They’re not deep enough for an RS model but I do want to get the next best thing in both engine and specification. I better start trawling through the adverts.
I know it’s just outside your age bracket, but what about a ‘74 2.7 MFI? Same engine as the ‘73 RS, but in an improved package overall. And less than half the price.
Funnily enough I was away this weekend with someone that owned a 73 RS for 12 years and has also owned two '74 2.7 MFI's and various other Porsche's of the era. To quote him "I couldn't put my finger on it as on paper there are not vast differences but the '74 is nowhere near the car of the RS" He said he'd have a 2.4S before a 74 MFI.

If the 74 MFI was an improved package the competition drivers would have been using them....but they weren't. 73 RS was being used in competion long after they stopped making the 74 MFI

Prestonese

801 posts

112 months

Monday 3rd October 2022
quotequote all
I have a 1970 2.2T with a few choice mods which has provided me with the most enjoyable road trip I've done so far. It's not fast (it's only about 155bhp) but it's engaging and fun. I'd love to have one with a 2.7 engine in there but it's probably not worth the extra outlast. It didn't cost me the world probably because it is not all original but it's not a car I'd ever sell as it's already provided me with plenty of good memories in the two years I've owned it. If you have a large budget then go for but you can find strong runners which don't cost you the earth but offers a lot of usability. Speak to Adrian Crawford or Phil Raby if you want to source something specific. Or better still, make friends with the guys over on DDK and see if anyone has a car for sale.

BertBert

19,697 posts

218 months

Monday 3rd October 2022
quotequote all
I've got my 69 ex-T finally working with its 2.4S mfi motor at about 190bhp. I think that 190-220 bhp is a wonderful place. I've also added front and rear arbs, S spec brakes and slightly stiffer rear torsion bars. So an S'ish spec with a 901 box. It's mega and I love the MFI response. It goes like a scalded cat!!

GTRene

17,774 posts

231 months

Monday 3rd October 2022
quotequote all
julian987R said:
That was me that posted that restoration documentary in the other thread - brilliant isn't it.

Have you tried https://www.elferspot.com/en/find/porsche-for-sale... that is a good place, as if you are looking at mobile.de then I assume you don't mind LHD. The cream of the crop is often listed on Elferspot (including those by the Early911S company featured in the documentary).
ah thumbup
and thanks for that link, will save it for some searches.

also some mentioning the MFI 2.7 engine, also installed so it seems in the 2.7 RS
When I searched at those oldies for sale (to max bj 75) I came across some ads saying, they had the same engine (2.7i) in their porsche 911 (swaps) as in the 2.7 RS and then I looked at the price of their cars, some around 60k euro (in Germany) and those cars looked nice, ok not all original cars, but if those engines (also 210 or so hp) are the same-ish used as in the 2.7 RS carrera's then around 60k for a nice example pre 1975 must be almost cheap :-) I guess for real collectors upgraded changed cars are not interesting, but if you not that rich as collectors can be and you just want the experience and drive it, then, who cares if its not original or number matching car?

at least thats how I think about it.