From TVR to Porsche

From TVR to Porsche

Author
Discussion

tvrdavid

Original Poster:

105 posts

208 months

Monday 5th May 2014
quotequote all
Thinking of chopping in my tvr chimaera for a Porsche 928 due to expanding family. Anyone been down his route? Any advice - I've got about 7000 to spend? Thanks in advance

mollytherocker

14,384 posts

221 months

Monday 5th May 2014
quotequote all
tvrdavid said:
Thinking of chopping in my tvr chimaera for a Porsche 928 due to expanding family. Anyone been down his route? Any advice - I've got about 7000 to spend? Thanks in advance
My advice is keep the Chimera and buy a Passat estate for family duties.

M A C

56 posts

215 months

Monday 5th May 2014
quotequote all
Hi
I went from a Chimera to a 996 cab about 4 yrs ago. Missed the noise, but the Porsche is much easier to live with and more reliable. Was out today in Porsche and followed a Chimera on to the M62, would not change back although still loved my TVR

medieval

1,499 posts

223 months

Thursday 8th May 2014
quotequote all
Had seven TVRs and five Porsches over the too many years and would have to say they are very different beasts

The TVRs to my mind are a wonderful piece of theatre and I found more of an event on each outing but the Porsches just seem so much more robust and better built I some ways and this comes from someone who owns a grenade engined 996 if you believe all of the hype

Both makes excellent but daft as it sounds it depends on which one is in your blood and the only way to find out is to explore both marques

Good luck and let's be honest it's a nice issue to have to address

Edited by medieval on Wednesday 14th May 20:54

tvrdavid

Original Poster:

105 posts

208 months

Friday 9th May 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for replies. Hi Craig I almost bought your green griff 500 a few years ago so great to hear from someone who has experience of both. Best regards. David

medieval

1,499 posts

223 months

Wednesday 14th May 2014
quotequote all
Good to hear from you David and I really wish I had never sold the 500 but good luck with your search sir and best wishes


KEVS500

86 posts

246 months

Thursday 15th May 2014
quotequote all
Don't sell it! You'll live to regret it.Get a cheap runabout and enjoy your (appreciating) chimaera. I've recently acquired a 997 GTS, but kept the Chim 500 for days like today - lid off, proper gear change,real noise and happy in the knowledge it's earning more than any ISA. GTS great for a whole host of reasons and I love it, but it's a completely different type of driving experience; TVRs are unique and you shouldn't let it go.

cramorra

1,673 posts

247 months

Tuesday 20th May 2014
quotequote all
moved from a t350 to a 964 (both targas)
Love them both, but porsche significantly more usable (feels better built and more modern, although 10 years older) - less drama positive and negative
tvr sounds better but porshe with g-pipe/sports zorst sounds super in a very different way
928 are totally different beats again
Extremely competent and very fast continent crushing cars - can bust ANY wallet
Whilst you might get one for 7k you could spend this and more in your first year maintaining it
Have both eyes wide open (and fingers crossed) buy a late model
http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/p...
have you considered a cerb (had one was great)
I have other daily drivers - so the idea keep the chim and buy one appeals, to

Edited by cramorra on Wednesday 21st May 22:42

gemini

11,352 posts

276 months

Wednesday 21st May 2014
quotequote all
I feel youll miss the Chimaera.
Its individualism (even a Chim), the noise and the theatre.
I too suggest you buy a family car and keep the TVR.

tvrdavid

Original Poster:

105 posts

208 months

Thursday 22nd May 2014
quotequote all
I don't doubt for a second I'll miss the tvr and I do have an x5 for family duties but I really need something interesting that will get the family in inc dog. I do love cerbs but fancy a change from the tvr. Appreciate your comments greatly though. Thanks guys

tonycordon

286 posts

242 months

Friday 23rd May 2014
quotequote all
I had a Chimaera 450 for about two years, did lots of trips including Le Mans Classic 2010. As others have said, positives; Performance, drama, sound, relative practicality. Negative; never REALLY felt secure/planted (inspite of having rebuilt suspension Gaz golds etc set up by TVR Power).
After selling it I bought a 993 C4 coupe, about 30 months ago. Very practical,4 seats(ish) if needed,Feels much more planted, (yes I know it's a C4) and generally has a much more 'solid' feel.
Don't misunderstand me I really did like the Chim, but the 993 is just..............better, in my opinion.

mollytherocker

14,384 posts

221 months

Friday 23rd May 2014
quotequote all
The thing with a Chim, and pretty much any TVR, is it is more of an event, its theatre, they just make you laugh out loud. Not that anyone would hear you.

I drove a Griffith 500 a few years ago in the rain and I was actually quite surprised at how secure it was. It didn't bite my arms off at all, it played nicely. I really, really liked it.

My mate still has it, and I cant see him ever selling it.