GT4RS Intake wind noise

GT4RS Intake wind noise

Author
Discussion

MeisterH

Original Poster:

846 posts

108 months

Sunday 16th June
quotequote all
Having now been out in my PTS 4RS for its first drive yesterday, i wanted to ask if anyone else has experienced wind noise from what i can only describe as side carbon intakes?

It was a windy day and i noticed from 55-75 (Within UK limits ) lower speeds nothing..

I am used to all types of noises in my GT car i own but this was a rather (oh that's crap)

MannyLon

1,812 posts

213 months

Sunday 16th June
quotequote all
Drive it a bit more. The intake makes all sorts of sounds. Not noticed wind noise, but the intakes sound like they’re sucking air at times.

elan362

168 posts

44 months

Sunday 16th June
quotequote all
  1. firstworldproblem

KittyLitter

1,073 posts

7 months

Sunday 16th June
quotequote all
MeisterH said:
i noticed from 55-75 (Within UK limits )
errrr

MannyLon

1,812 posts

213 months

Sunday 16th June
quotequote all
elan362 said:
#firstworldproblem
Which world do you live in?

MeisterH

Original Poster:

846 posts

108 months

Monday 17th June
quotequote all
Not sure why I bother…. This forum has really gone down the drain.

Shame .

bigmowley

2,082 posts

183 months

Monday 17th June
quotequote all
To be fair it is a difficult one to give any sensible comment on. For what it’s worth my 4RS did not suffer from any unusual wind noise issues. It had lots and lots of NVH issues but not wind noise. At motorway speeds and on light throttle openings there was a lot of tyre noise, and general engine noise but none of the intake blare that love it or hate it is the signature of this car. The build quality of my last couple of Caymans, a GT4 and a 4RS, have been fairly poor to be fair. Certainly felt much less well screwed together than my old Cayman R. Not sure if that is just a bit of bad luck or signs of a deteriorating build quality?
Sounds like something is not quite aligned if it’s that noticeable.

TDT

5,430 posts

126 months

Monday 17th June
quotequote all
The WP package has intake with scoops that do protrude out into the air stream… so might be a side effect of that?!

MeisterH

Original Poster:

846 posts

108 months

Monday 17th June
quotequote all
TDT said:
The WP package has intake with scoops that do protrude out into the air stream… so might be a side effect of that?!
My thoughts exactly, thanks

ab8

205 posts

147 months

Tuesday 18th June
quotequote all
I have the WP and do not notice this

kmpowell

3,140 posts

235 months

Tuesday 18th June
quotequote all
ab8 said:
I have the WP and do not notice this
Is yours a PTS though…?

ChrisW.

6,844 posts

262 months

Tuesday 18th June
quotequote all
I would always try to add a potentially useful 2p but I also am a bit lost with this one.

I saw it said here (so it must be true) that the minimum noise level difference that the human ear can define (subject to frequency) is 3dB which is a doubling of the energy in the noise, distance from the noise rapidly reducing this.

Certainly the air intakes on the GT4 are very close to the ear and carbon fibre is extremely rigid potentially transmitting and resonating higher frequencies quite efficiently .... ???

So maybe Weissach does make a difference to this ? I am guessing that Porsche will know and to be fair ... the noise was something that they celebrated at launch.

MannyLon

1,812 posts

213 months

Tuesday 18th June
quotequote all
GT4 clubsport was a noisy beast inside the cabin. The RS is more so in an exciting way. The roll cage will ping, sometimes rattle. The carbon air box is noisy, I love it, part of the experience. 4RS was not designed for a quiet ride.

23wn_4f2

163 posts

62 months

Tuesday 18th June
quotequote all
kmpowell said:
ab8 said:
I have the WP and do not notice this
Is yours a PTS though…?
Lol

av185

19,446 posts

134 months

Tuesday 18th June
quotequote all
ChrisW. said:
I would always try to add a potentially useful 2p but I also am a bit lost with this one.

I saw it said here (so it must be true) that the minimum noise level difference that the human ear can define (subject to frequency) is 3dB which is a doubling of the energy in the noise, distance from the noise rapidly reducing this.

Certainly the air intakes on the GT4 are very close to the ear and carbon fibre is extremely rigid potentially transmitting and resonating higher frequencies quite efficiently .... ???

So maybe Weissach does make a difference to this ? I am guessing that Porsche will know and to be fair ... the noise was something that they celebrated at launch.
Interesting theory Chris.

Perhaps Finmac could advise what his non WP 4RS is like.

finmac

1,588 posts

245 months

Tuesday 18th June
quotequote all
av185 said:
ChrisW. said:
I would always try to add a potentially useful 2p but I also am a bit lost with this one.

I saw it said here (so it must be true) that the minimum noise level difference that the human ear can define (subject to frequency) is 3dB which is a doubling of the energy in the noise, distance from the noise rapidly reducing this.

Certainly the air intakes on the GT4 are very close to the ear and carbon fibre is extremely rigid potentially transmitting and resonating higher frequencies quite efficiently .... ???

So maybe Weissach does make a difference to this ? I am guessing that Porsche will know and to be fair ... the noise was something that they celebrated at launch.
Interesting theory Chris.

Perhaps Finmac could advise what his non WP 4RS is like.
I have been following this thread with interest and hoping my no WP car is a little quieter as the intakes don’t stick out the same as the WP ones. (One of the attractions of the non WP car for me at least). I will advise once my car gets PPF and I take delivery later in the month

ab8

205 posts

147 months

Tuesday 18th June
quotequote all
kmpowell said:
Is yours a PTS though…?
rofl

Maxym

2,192 posts

243 months

Tuesday 18th June
quotequote all
23wn_4f2 said:
kmpowell said:
ab8 said:
I have the WP and do not notice this
Is yours a PTS though…?
Lol
Another LOL from me. smile

PaulJC84

978 posts

224 months

Tuesday 18th June
quotequote all
Maxym said:
23wn_4f2 said:
kmpowell said:
ab8 said:
I have the WP and do not notice this
Is yours a PTS though…?
Lol
Another LOL from me. smile
And me

981SPYGANG

426 posts

57 months

Tuesday 18th June
quotequote all
PaulJC84 said:
Maxym said:
23wn_4f2 said:
kmpowell said:
ab8 said:
I have the WP and do not notice this
Is yours a PTS though…?
Lol
Another LOL from me. smile
And me
Yes very good rofl