Which would you buy and why?
Which would you buy and why?
Author
Discussion

TudorSantos

Original Poster:

31 posts

125 months

Wednesday 4th November 2015
quotequote all
Theoretical question here, well kinda, I'm currently trying to decide.

You have the following 911 variants:-

2014 GT3
2015 GTS
2014 Turbo

All are around 10k miles or less and all 3 are priced rather close to each other (I'm not in the UK). FPSH, warranty etc etc. GT3 is comfort spec. GTS is well, GTS spec with some carbon bits and the Turbo is well kitted as standard. GTS & Turbo are PDK too.

It's for a second car for weekends and maybe the odd blast to the office. Maybe the odd track day here and there too.

Which would you choose?

Edited by TudorSantos on Wednesday 4th November 14:52

9e 28

9,954 posts

224 months

Wednesday 4th November 2015
quotequote all
As a weekend car GT3 will be most satisfying due to the high revving ballistic nature of its powerplant.

fastgerman

1,998 posts

218 months

Wednesday 4th November 2015
quotequote all
GT3 because:
- you said weekend car
- track car
- all the same price now, GT3 will be worth the most in 5 years time :-)

ferdi p

1,534 posts

195 months

Wednesday 4th November 2015
quotequote all
GT3

Cheib

25,049 posts

198 months

Wednesday 4th November 2015
quotequote all
The pricing differential between well specced late GTS's and Comfort GT3's isn't too much in the UK too. There was a Targa GTS up at a dealer recently for just under £130k which sold quickly....that is firmly GT3 money.

TudorSantos

Original Poster:

31 posts

125 months

Thursday 5th November 2015
quotequote all
Thanks

I'm thinking that the GT3 would be the best option too.



RSVP911

8,192 posts

156 months

Thursday 5th November 2015
quotequote all
fastgerman said:
GT3 because:
- you said weekend car
- track car
- all the same price now, GT3 will be worth the most in 5 years time :-)
+1 - also manual way more fun for a weekend toy smile

TudorSantos

Original Poster:

31 posts

125 months

Thursday 5th November 2015
quotequote all
RSVP911 said:
+1 - also manual way more fun for a weekend toy smile
991 GT3 isn't manual. I'm not looking at 997's.

smile

AyBee

11,185 posts

225 months

Thursday 5th November 2015
quotequote all
TudorSantos said:
RSVP911 said:
+1 - also manual way more fun for a weekend toy smile
991 GT3 isn't manual. I'm not looking at 997's.

smile
confused 2014 GT3 that isn't a 997 or a 991?

TudorSantos

Original Poster:

31 posts

125 months

Thursday 5th November 2015
quotequote all
AyBee said:
confused 2014 GT3 that isn't a 997 or a 991?
err a 2014 GT3 is a 991 variant.

NAS90

146 posts

135 months

Thursday 5th November 2015
quotequote all
GTS is really a great car and you wouldn't feel short changed using it on a road or the track, but given the other two as company, GTS definitely NO, instant reaction might well be to go for a GT3, but thinking on a bit, how many track days are you actually going to do?

I drove a GT3 Club Sport as a daily driver for 18 months in my 20's and loved it, a little older and a little lazier now if I was doing say one track day a quarter and the rest of the time doing weekend runs, road drives, etc. with it then i'd definitely take the Turbo. It's a much better road car than the GT3 on all surfaces and having done literally hundreds of laps on track in the 991 Turbo/ Turbo S I can say for sure they are very nearly as much fun and surprisingly close in lap times to the GT3 on most circuits.

So whilst the GT3 will surely get the most votes as a weekend toy the replies, the better choice for my money is actually the 991 Turbo

Fl0pp3r

869 posts

226 months

Friday 6th November 2015
quotequote all
If it really is that second car for high days and some track - from those 3 I'd take the GT3. Although it's arguably comfortable enough to be your daily now!

That said, i agree with NAS90 that a 991 Turbo would be very tempting if your of a more relaxed disposition ;-)

Edited by Fl0pp3r on Friday 6th November 00:06

TudorSantos

Original Poster:

31 posts

125 months

Saturday 7th November 2015
quotequote all
Fl0pp3r said:
If it really is that second car for high days and some track - from those 3 I'd take the GT3. Although it's arguably comfortable enough to be your daily now!

That said, i agree with NAS90 that a 991 Turbo would be very tempting if your of a more relaxed disposition ;-)
I'm still in my 30s, so not too bothered about comfort! GT3 does make sense, and will probably hold more value over 3-5 years than a turbo. I like the GTS, but when a GT3 or Turbo is almost the same price I need to question myself!

I'd be only looking to do 3-4 track days a year. So will the Turbo feel special enough for those weekend blasts? Again, maybe this is why I'm thinking GT3 as that engine does sound very special but the Turbo has that outright speed feel (plus a better spec inside)

hmmm

terryb

1,005 posts

267 months

Saturday 7th November 2015
quotequote all
You need to drive a Turbo and a GT3. The PDK-S gearbox and the steering on a GT3 are far superior in my opinion - but that suits my needs and not everyone else's.

If it were my money then it would be GT3 all day long (which is why I own one and absolutely love it).

VPD255M

153 posts

169 months

Saturday 7th November 2015
quotequote all
Has to be GT3 yes