Italy, small hire car or big hire car?

Italy, small hire car or big hire car?

Author
Discussion

boredofmyoldname

Original Poster:

22,655 posts

206 months

Tuesday 1st February 2011
quotequote all
For my sins I have to spend 2 weeks of the summer with my good ladys family in Italy, I cannot cope for 2 weeks without a car but do I go for the tight arsed option of hiring the smallest thing I can and then proceed to drive like an italian or do I pay 50% more and get something bigger that might have a proper engine and more impact protection when someone drives into me?

IanMorewood

4,309 posts

255 months

Tuesday 1st February 2011
quotequote all
Fiat 500 or Punto and drive it like its a Ferrari, after all thats the Italian way.

Ug_lee

2,224 posts

218 months

Tuesday 1st February 2011
quotequote all
Depends on where you're staying in Italy and the main type of roads you're going to be on.

I spent a week around Lake Como and felt the FIAT Panda was about as big as I wanted to go and glad I didn't get the Bravo. Squeezing between walls/big trucks/other cars all driven by complete lunatics on narrow tight twisty roads I was glad to have a fairly narrow car. (still scraped the mirrors a number of times taking evasive action)

If it's mainly Autostrada stuff then Mondeo sized stuff is fine.

boredofmyoldname

Original Poster:

22,655 posts

206 months

Tuesday 1st February 2011
quotequote all
I am thinking small may be best, I have no idea what kind of roads I will be on but looking at the map I doubt much if any motorway work would be involved.

Lanby

1,106 posts

221 months

Tuesday 1st February 2011
quotequote all
Small is better.

When we went in the Maserati there were a LOT of times when I breathed in to fit through the gap!!

edited to add we headed for in Portofino as well

Edited by Lanby on Tuesday 1st February 17:46

r11co

6,244 posts

237 months

Tuesday 1st February 2011
quotequote all
boredofmyoldname said:
For my sins I have to spend 2 weeks of the summer with my good lady's family in Italy...
You make it sound like a chore! I'll bet there'll be great food and wine on tap for the duration, not to mention fantastic weather..

I'm in Italy annually (it's my folks who are over there) and last two years I've hired rather than taking my own car (for reasons too long to explain).

2 years ago it was a 320d touring which we took up the Riviera to Monaco - most overrated car ever.

Last year I had a Panda for a week and a Twingo for another and frankly both were more than adequate. The Panda was by far the better drive and incredibly quiet and refined - especially on the autostrada. The Twingo had a trick stereo/bluetooth thingy but crap steering and was as noisy as you'd expect a town car to be.

Go small!

boredofmyoldname

Original Poster:

22,655 posts

206 months

Tuesday 1st February 2011
quotequote all
r11co said:
boredofmyoldname said:
For my sins I have to spend 2 weeks of the summer with my good lady's family in Italy...
You make it sound like a chore! I'll bet there'll be great food and wine on tap for the duration, not to mention fantastic weather..
I'm an antisocial git 50% of the time so don't relish the prospect of being with a host of other people for 2 weeks.

It does look like small is the order of the day though.

skodamanpat

367 posts

186 months

Tuesday 1st February 2011
quotequote all
We did the riviera a couple of years ago down to Portofino in the MX-5 and that felt very wide in some of the towns.

Caruso

7,467 posts

263 months

Tuesday 1st February 2011
quotequote all
Small car with Aircon (Punto?) will do the job nicely.

jsg612

571 posts

175 months

Tuesday 1st February 2011
quotequote all
Anything much bigger than a Fiat 500 is a pain to drive around. We had use of a 5 Series last year, this year it will be a Fiat Panda.

MrCippo

590 posts

202 months

Tuesday 1st February 2011
quotequote all
in a similar dilemma here for north of Italy, looked around and the Fiat 500 is my preferable option.

r11co

6,244 posts

237 months

Tuesday 1st February 2011
quotequote all
You'll pay over the odds for the hire of a 500 because of its 'premium' image. Go for the Panda - it is the better all-round car.

theturbs

949 posts

243 months

Tuesday 1st February 2011
quotequote all

Another vote for the Panda

va1o

16,055 posts

214 months

Tuesday 1st February 2011
quotequote all
Fiat 500 here - would make the perfect hire car in Italy IMO!

powwerr

1,978 posts

179 months

Tuesday 1st February 2011
quotequote all
Im doing the same in June be it for 1 week.

IIm looking at C-max and Galaxy type stuff, am i mad? theres only 2 of us flying over but will be meeting up with otherfolk when we get there.

Which companies are you guys looking at renting from?

Diabolik

1,222 posts

168 months

Tuesday 1st February 2011
quotequote all
Another vote for small. Wouldn't even consider a big car unless the space is neccessary.

munroman

1,882 posts

191 months

Tuesday 1st February 2011
quotequote all
I was travelling to Lugano years ago, got off the plane at Milan Malpensa to find the boss's secretary had booked me a 1.0 Corsa.

I bricked it going on the Autostrada, driving like a Brit.

After a few days 'going native' I found it could easily do 90 slipstreaming!

Small every time, just drive 'Con Brio'!

boredofmyoldname

Original Poster:

22,655 posts

206 months

Tuesday 1st February 2011
quotequote all
The Crack Fox said:
Italy you say ? Small rentalcar you say ? You're no petrolhead if you miss an opportunity to do something like this - http://www.sucksqueezebangblow.net:/folder/?p=75smile
Looks great but I am going quite a bit further south. Booked the smallest thing on the list which is 'Fiat Panda or similar' so small and basic driving a billy bargain at £105 for 2 weeks IMO.

Olf

11,974 posts

225 months

Tuesday 1st February 2011
quotequote all
boredofmyoldname said:
Looks great but I am going quite a bit further south. Booked the smallest thing on the list which is 'Fiat Panda or similar' so small and basic driving a billy bargain at £105 for 2 weeks IMO.
The potenially bad news is that Fiat Panda or similar might just mean tin can Lancia... Proceed with care!

boredofmyoldname

Original Poster:

22,655 posts

206 months

Tuesday 1st February 2011
quotequote all
Olf said:
The potenially bad news is that Fiat Panda or similar might just mean tin can Lancia... Proceed with care!
I'm not scared, as long as it has brakes and seatbelts that will do.