Need a replacement 4x4. Hummer H2 or Cadi Escalade?

Need a replacement 4x4. Hummer H2 or Cadi Escalade?

Author
Discussion

Martial Arts Man

Original Poster:

6,625 posts

191 months

Monday 17th January 2011
quotequote all
I acquired a 4.0 '98 Ford Explorer last year for tip runs and snow driving.

Cost peanuts to buy. Anyway, I've fallen in love!. Had an ML Merc years ago but absolutely love this Ford; I think it's 'cause I've never had a big petrol engined wagon before. Even though it's a V6, the engine note makes me giggle as I burble around the carpark at home.

Despite its ludicrous mpg, I have started using it for day-to-day general city centre pootling. So, I think I should replace it with something considerably more luxurious. Or something ridiculous.

I like American cars a great deal, so I reckon it boils down to the two big fellas in the title. The Cadi is a little silly yet pretty luxurious. The H2 is not so luxurious yet very very silly. I'll be looking to spend about £15K ish so I should be able to get one of either in good nick.








Pros? Cons? Any advice for aiding the hunt?

Cheers!

easytiger123

2,624 posts

214 months

Monday 17th January 2011
quotequote all
Escalade gets my vote. Would advise you to think about stumping up an extra 5k or so to go for the far superior newer model (much better interior, better looking, better ride), if you could stretch that far? Engine is bullet-proof. Looked at the Hummer too and found it just too agricultural for me. Plus interior room was minimal for a car that size.

Synchromesh

2,428 posts

171 months

Monday 17th January 2011
quotequote all
Chevy Suburban for me...

DanGPR

989 posts

176 months

Monday 17th January 2011
quotequote all
Of the two, would get the Caddy, you will look an absolute helmet driving around in a Hummer...

Surely a Range Rover would give more luxury? Or a Lexus RX?

Hitch78

6,117 posts

199 months

Monday 17th January 2011
quotequote all
Escalade new gen for me - or the Chevy Tahoe it is based on. Much much better than the old one.

Hummers are fun for about five minutes, especially the faux H3 one.

Ed.

2,174 posts

243 months

Monday 17th January 2011
quotequote all
Grand Cherokee SRT not an option? closer in size to the explorer easier round town.

Martial Arts Man

Original Poster:

6,625 posts

191 months

Monday 17th January 2011
quotequote all
easytiger123 said:
Escalade gets my vote. Would advise you to think about stumping up an extra 5k or so to go for the far superior newer model (much better interior, better looking, better ride), if you could stretch that far? Engine is bullet-proof. Looked at the Hummer too and found it just too agricultural for me. Plus interior room was minimal for a car that size.
Not sure I want to spend so much on what is ultimately a plaything. Is it really that much better? How shall I spin it to the Mrs in a "we'll SAVE money in the long run" biggrin

A friend of mine had an H2. The interior was very low rent. I think it adds to the charm in many ways.

Martial Arts Man

Original Poster:

6,625 posts

191 months

Monday 17th January 2011
quotequote all
Synchromesh said:
Chevy Suburban for me...
0 on AT. No idea what my budget would allow. Any ideas?

Martial Arts Man

Original Poster:

6,625 posts

191 months

Monday 17th January 2011
quotequote all
DanGPR said:
Of the two, would get the Caddy, you will look an absolute helmet driving around in a Hummer...

Surely a Range Rover would give more luxury? Or a Lexus RX?
They're way too boring. I want a toy really. The Mrs wants a RR in the summer anyhow.

I'm not too fussed about looking a tool; as long as I get the aural stiulation I need smile

Martial Arts Man

Original Poster:

6,625 posts

191 months

Monday 17th January 2011
quotequote all
Ed. said:
Grand Cherokee SRT not an option? closer in size to the explorer easier round town.
I fancy a left hooker. Nice cars though; if I was looking for something more suitable for work my money would be going to Jeep.

JRM Rossi

703 posts

194 months

Monday 17th January 2011
quotequote all
I have had a dodge ram & and now have a h2 the dodge was great covered 250,000 miles with few probs ie gearbox
great pick up NOW for the H2 its on lpg drives very well,they are a bit crap inside but you can buy carbon bits to bring it up to spec! hummers drive nice i looked at 7 before i brought mine look out for oil leaks & steer clear of bigger wheels as they say it knocks out ball joints & bearings & plays up the air suspension

The hummer does it for me

BigS

867 posts

178 months

Monday 17th January 2011
quotequote all
Martial Arts Man said:
How shall I spin it to the Mrs in a "we'll SAVE money in the long run" biggrin
Not 100% sure, but I think the current model has cylinder deactivation, where 4 cylinders are shut down when they're not needed to save fuel.
The Suburban (same platform as the Escalade, although smaller engine) I had as a hire car last June had it and that managed about 20 US mpg over the 2 weeks I had it.
Would definitely book another one too if I do another roadtrip, unless the Caddy or a vette is available for about the same money smile

Edited by BigS on Monday 17th January 18:23

iain_thornton

17,546 posts

184 months

Monday 17th January 2011
quotequote all
if you can find one, check out the ZJ series Jeep Grand Cherokee 5.9. the sound is blood curdling. all LHD. cool as hell cars. it'll be a lot cheaper than one of those. it's not as showy, or ridiculous, but wonderful nonetheless smile

HowMuchLonger

3,012 posts

198 months

Monday 17th January 2011
quotequote all
Can you get an H1 for your budget?

g3org3y

20,897 posts

196 months

Monday 17th January 2011
quotequote all
Martial Arts Man said:
Hummer H2 or Cadi Escalade
I think you're needed over here: http://pistonheads.co.uk/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&amp...

smile

nyxster

1,452 posts

176 months

Monday 17th January 2011
quotequote all
I would go for the Chevy Tahoe in black for that FBI "murda" look.

Martial Arts Man

Original Poster:

6,625 posts

191 months

Monday 17th January 2011
quotequote all
BigS said:
Martial Arts Man said:
How shall I spin it to the Mrs in a "we'll SAVE money in the long run" biggrin
Not 100% sure, but I think the current model has cylinder deactivation, where 4 cylinders are shut down when they're not needed to save fuel.
Useful info; cheers thumbup

Martial Arts Man

Original Poster:

6,625 posts

191 months

Monday 17th January 2011
quotequote all
iain_thornton said:
if you can find one, check out the ZJ series Jeep Grand Cherokee 5.9. the sound is blood curdling. all LHD. cool as hell cars. it'll be a lot cheaper than one of those. it's not as showy, or ridiculous, but wonderful nonetheless smile
I've never even heard of one of these till now.

If the sound is as you say, I might need to investigate. What year were these produced?

Martial Arts Man

Original Poster:

6,625 posts

191 months

Monday 17th January 2011
quotequote all
HowMuchLonger said:
Can you get an H1 for your budget?
In a former life I used to regularly do business with a fairly successful kickboxing instructor. He had an H1 and used to drive everywhere in it fully donned in camo gear. What a tit.

Martial Arts Man

Original Poster:

6,625 posts

191 months

Monday 17th January 2011
quotequote all
g3org3y said:
Martial Arts Man said:
Hummer H2 or Cadi Escalade
I think you're needed over here: http://pistonheads.co.uk/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&amp...

smile
wink

One has to spend one's 5/10 pound notes somewhere .

biggrin