"BEVs are complete bulls**t," he says.

"BEVs are complete bulls**t," he says.

Author
Discussion

unsprung

Original Poster:

5,739 posts

129 months

Saturday 29th June 2019
quotequote all
"Nobody wants EVs, says BMW"

“Customers in Europe do not buy EVs. We pressed these cars into the market and they’re not wanted. We can deliver an electrified vehicle to each person but they will not buy them.”

https://www.motoring.com.au/nobody-wants-evs-says-...


DanT86

91 posts

64 months

Saturday 29th June 2019
quotequote all
That's because they're still to expensive for the average buyer and people who do long distance want something that will do the journey without the inconvenience of having to find a charging station and if it will be working ect.

grumbledoak

31,742 posts

238 months

Saturday 29th June 2019
quotequote all
I think that was a very rational summary. We aren't overflowing with space for double garages, so most people need a car that does everything. Including long range and being affordable, which are mutually exclusive at present.

MaxSo

1,910 posts

100 months

Saturday 29th June 2019
quotequote all
Chicken and egg springs to mind...

"What they [Transport and Environment] ignore is that the European customer is not prepared to take the risk on an EV because the infrastructure is not there"

So why didn't BMW do as Tesla did and build the infrastructure...


unsprung

Original Poster:

5,739 posts

129 months

Saturday 29th June 2019
quotequote all


the tone and manner -- in public -- of that BMW guy was just a bit shocking, to me

and there is a moment, in this article, at which a government official goes on a whinge about what he believes to be selfish profiteering by the private sector

the reader truly gets a sense for the friction that can build up between OEMs and government




Mike335i

5,184 posts

107 months

Saturday 29th June 2019
quotequote all
Very interesting, I like the frank speaking in this. I completely agree with Frölich on this though, I don't have space for multiple vehicles and I don't want to spend the extortionate amount that BEVs currently cost, for what is for me an interior product. Petrol is still relatively cheap so I shall enjoy it whilst I can.

RobDickinson

31,343 posts

259 months

Saturday 29th June 2019
quotequote all
No one wants a BMW ev because they are expensive and ugly.

They only have 1 ev model they purposely set out as a test bed for a bunch of new and expensive things, even then they've sold a fair few despite its looks.

BMW are getting ass fked in USA by Tesla because Tesla invested in ev infrastructure and built an ev that people do want.

Tesla are not the only ones doing that but they are the only one with actual volume supply.

BMW have consigned themselves to history with this.

David87

6,742 posts

217 months

Saturday 29th June 2019
quotequote all
No, this bloke is wrong. I don’t want a BMW EV. hehe

Griff74

144 posts

66 months

Saturday 29th June 2019
quotequote all
He has a point, everyone I know with a BEV, myself included (an i3) has at least 2 cars and even when we replace ours next year for one with much better range it will still be our 2nd car for running around town and short journeys.

RobDickinson

31,343 posts

259 months

Saturday 29th June 2019
quotequote all
Because the i3 is effectively a city car, with slow charging. Not equivalent to a long range fast charging bev.

This is the longest road trip I've done in the past few years, planned with a lr model 3.

22min stop in 8 hours of driving.



Tesla have sold 400k+ model 3s, if it had a BMW badge and kidney grills how many would BMW have sold?

rodericb

7,033 posts

131 months

Sunday 30th June 2019
quotequote all
RobDickinson said:
No one wants a BMW ev because they are expensive and ugly.

They only have 1 ev model they purposely set out as a test bed for a bunch of new and expensive things, even then they've sold a fair few despite its looks.

BMW are getting ass fked in USA by Tesla because Tesla invested in ev infrastructure and built an ev that people do want.

Tesla are not the only ones doing that but they are the only one with actual volume supply.

BMW have consigned themselves to history with this.
Did you read the article?

RobDickinson

31,343 posts

259 months

Sunday 30th June 2019
quotequote all
Yes. Last Thursday.

Ah wrong guy the CEO might be out in April but this guy might take over lol rip.

Edited by RobDickinson on Sunday 30th June 00:26

Wills2

23,857 posts

180 months

Sunday 30th June 2019
quotequote all
Ignore the tesla fanboy he's a bit odd.


RobDickinson

31,343 posts

259 months

Sunday 30th June 2019
quotequote all
Yeah whatever.

Genuine question. Tesla some twice as many model 3s as 3 series in the USA last year.

If BMW had an equivalent do you think that would have happened?

The root here is customers don't want bevs, that is pure bullst.

Griff74

144 posts

66 months

Sunday 30th June 2019
quotequote all
RobDickinson said:
Because the i3 is effectively a city car, with slow charging. Not equivalent to a long range fast charging bev.

This is the longest road trip I've done in the past few years, planned with a lr model 3.

22min stop in 8 hours of driving.



Tesla have sold 400k+ model 3s, if it had a BMW badge and kidney grills how many would BMW have sold?
I kind of agree with the city car bit cos that's what we mostly use ours for but the i3 is not slow to charge, it comes with CCS fast charging as standard (80% charge in 30 mins) and here in the UK we have 240v in to our homes so 7.2kw is the standard for home chargers on type 2.

RobDickinson

31,343 posts

259 months

Sunday 30th June 2019
quotequote all
But 80% is what 100 miles?

to3m

1,228 posts

175 months

Sunday 30th June 2019
quotequote all
RobDickinson said:
Yeah whatever.

Genuine question. Tesla some twice as many model 3s as 3 series in the USA last year.

If BMW had an equivalent do you think that would have happened?

The root here is customers don't want bevs, that is pure bullst.
Regarding differences between Europe and the USA, from the article:

“Europeans are very reluctant to buy a BEV, but the Europeans have fewer cars in the garage than a BMW customer in the US.

“In the US they can have different cars for different purposes, like pick-ups and SUVs and smaller cars, but often the households in Europe have only one car so they are reluctant to rely purely on a BEV."


rodericb

7,033 posts

131 months

Sunday 30th June 2019
quotequote all
RobDickinson said:
Yeah whatever.

Genuine question. Tesla some twice as many model 3s as 3 series in the USA last year.

If BMW had an equivalent do you think that would have happened?

The root here is customers don't want bevs, that is pure bullst.
Rob I think you are quite correct in thinking that BMW would have sold barely thousands of the model 3, if it was a BMW. Tesla isn't BMW. BMW (and all other established manufacturers) are so much more conservative than Tesla. Tesla thus doesn't have the constraints of the other manufacturers either, nor the cultural, engineering, people, processes and systems baggage. Tesla also comes out of a culture of spinning up a product on the slightest whiff of a promise - Silicon Valley. This same factory gave you facebook, Theranos, Nest, Juicero....

But back to BMW, they've taken the approach of dumping a lot of R&D into the i3 and i8. Carbon fibre chassis, composite panels, interior materials made from things like bamboo. They've made a city car in the i3 and you could say they've gone after a hard target as they're up against non-BEV's (and REx's) which are half the price and (according to the linked article) more expensive to run!

Mike335i

5,184 posts

107 months

Sunday 30th June 2019
quotequote all
RobDickinson said:
Yeah whatever.

Genuine question. Tesla some twice as many model 3s as 3 series in the USA last year.

If BMW had an equivalent do you think that would have happened?

The root here is customers don't want bevs, that is pure bullst.
Article is about why Europeans don't want BEVs, in contrast to Americans. In which he is correct.

RobDickinson

31,343 posts

259 months

Sunday 30th June 2019
quotequote all
Mike335i said:
Article is about why Europeans don't want BEVs, in contrast to Americans. In which he is correct.
https://thedriven.io/2019/04/30/european-q1-new-car-market-results-out-ice-down-ev-way-up/

Data released this week by vehicle data collation organisation JATO showed that Q1 (Jan – Mar) new car sales in the whole of Europe were down by 3.2 per cent over the same period a year earlier.

Bucking the trend however, total EV sales for the first time exceeded 100,000 in one quarter (hitting 125,400). Breaking these figures down further: plug-in electric (BEV & PHEV) sales were up 31% and pure electric (BEV) sales were up 85%.

http://carsalesbase.com/european-sales-2019-q1-pre...
Sales of midsized luxury cars in Europe continue their downward trend in the first quarter of 2019, with deliveries down 3% to just over 160.000 units. And if it hadn’t been for the thunderous arrival of the Tesla Model 3, the segment would have been down by 14%. In March alone, Tesla delivered more Model 3’s than any midsized namplate except for the Mercedes-Benz C-Class, and that also includes all mainstream midsized models like the VW Passat.

Premium midsized car segment 2019-Q1 2018-Q1 Change
BMW 3-series 26.165 28.466 -8%