F1 Digital+

Author
Discussion

fatsteve

Original Poster:

1,143 posts

284 months

Sunday 3rd March 2002
quotequote all
Did anyone else subscribe to the Oz F1 this weekend on Sky's F1 Digital+ channel.

I'm not totally convinced, and wonder if anyone else has any comments on it.

Generally the actual coverage, ie angles, shorts, replays etc were better than ITV, but the commentary was dire.

Steve

richb

52,738 posts

291 months

Tuesday 5th March 2002
quotequote all
Yep I decided to invest £12 on this. Like you I thought the camera shots were pretty good, in fact when Ralf ran over Baraccello I nearly jumped out of my skin! When I saw ITV’s coverage (recorded the highlights) it wasn't nearly so dramatic. I agree regarding the commentary, well there wasn't one really, just Perry & Damon chatting as if they were watching it in a pub. I thought it refreshing that they were totally non-PC in their comments though. ITV always have to be so balanced and non critical of anything. Loved the bit when PM asked if Damon would like to have a go at stuffing Shuie’ into the barriers for old times sake! "Be rude not to" was Damon’s reply! All in all I could happily listen to PM and DH but it needs a decent commentator over the top to keep the continuity going. And I must say I thought Brundle was much more professional on ITV. Did anyone bother with switching around the screens? Once the race started I didn't bother. Rich...

markbigears

2,337 posts

276 months

Tuesday 5th March 2002
quotequote all
it was lucky that we were on the incar camera when the accident happened, looked amazing didnt you think. Given that we only knew 3 weeks before the event it was all a bit kick bollox scramble to get it on Sky.
Didnt think it was that bad for a first attempt?
mark

>> Edited by markbigears on Tuesday 5th March 15:02

richb

52,738 posts

291 months

Tuesday 5th March 2002
quotequote all
Mark, I see you work in/for F1 is that in th eindustry or do you mean at Sky/Digital? Rich...

markbigears

2,337 posts

276 months

Tuesday 5th March 2002
quotequote all
rich, i work for the digital TV company, mark

richb

52,738 posts

291 months

Tuesday 5th March 2002
quotequote all
Well you say my comments pretty much on agreement with you, although I wasn't aware it had to be prepared in just 3 weeks! All in all a decent effort - I'd say keep the two boys in the studio and get Matthew Lorenzo (or whoever) to do a proper running commentry. I'll certainly give it another try. Rich...

markbigears

2,337 posts

276 months

Tuesday 5th March 2002
quotequote all
rich, i didnt see the final show that you get in uk, so are you saying there isn't a running commentary?
also, did you flick through the various channels? just interested from a punters point of view. cheers mark.
also any suggestions you want me to pass on, i will.

richb

52,738 posts

291 months

Tuesday 5th March 2002
quotequote all
OK well regards flicking through the 8 x channels I did this during practice and yes it's a great idea, you can flick around when one feed gets boring and pick on an interview or something else. During the race however I decided to stay pretty well with the main feed because I couldn't be bothered to swap around. Regards the commentry I would say Perry McArthy and Damon Hill did 80% of the chat and Matthew Loenzo just filled in with questions and observations when it went quiet. Perry & Damon were in fact very funny in a droll sort of way, sort of schoolboy banter and as I said it was refreshingly non-PC, but I would prefer ML to do more of a proper commentry allowing PMcA and DH more time to think about what they are going to say. Rich...

markbigears

2,337 posts

276 months

Tuesday 5th March 2002
quotequote all
i'll pass on your views rich, no doubt there will be changes in time and as everyone finds their feet im sure it will get slicker. cheers mark

McNab

1,627 posts

281 months

Tuesday 5th March 2002
quotequote all
Being so accustomed to going to bed early I watched the warm-up and recorded the rest.

By sheer chance I heard an announcement that the John Watson/Ben Edwards commentary would be on the Super Channel, leaving the Master Channel to the studio team.

So before switching off I selected the Super Channel (the second box on the top line), and left the thing to sort itself out.

When I woke up on Sunday afternoon I played it back, and sure enough I got the John & Ben Show. And very good they were too.

Obviously I couldn't use the various options once I had recorded it, and a warning is also necessary if you choose to watch the repeats after the race.

The repeats don't have the multi-view option (which I thoroughly enjoyed during all the practices and the qualifying).

Great production though, and well worth the £12 charge. The real value will emerge when they get back to Europe.

I hope what I have said is correct - someone please tell me if I'm wrong!

mags

1,138 posts

286 months

Wednesday 6th March 2002
quotequote all
A bit off the topic but has any seen the Motor TV channel? its a couple before F1+ on Sky. I noticed it last night but it only had Nascar type stuff on at the time.

Cotty

40,283 posts

291 months

Wednesday 6th March 2002
quotequote all
Got his from the ITV F1 website (not the F1 news), made me chuckle so I thought I'd share it with yo all:

And finally, still at Jaguar, there are red faces all round after it was revealed that hackers breached their security in Valencia and interfered with the pits to car telemetry. It wasn’t the fact that the hackers got past their firewalls that irritated the Jaguar management, it was the fact that they could make the car two seconds quicker…

s2ooz

3,005 posts

291 months

Wednesday 6th March 2002
quotequote all
I quiet like the motor TV channel, it covers a lot of biking as well, which suits me fine. Its nice to see other races besides the few channel 4 cover at a weekend.

completed OT now ;
www.lyngsat.com/dig/skyuk.shtml

a list of how to get even more sky digi channels, dont promise you will want them tho!

s2ooz

3,005 posts

291 months

Wednesday 6th March 2002
quotequote all
I quiet like the motor TV channel, it covers a lot of biking as well, which suits me fine. Its nice to see other races besides the few channel 4 cover at a weekend.

completed OT now ;
www.lyngsat.com/dig/skyuk.shtml

a list of how to get even more sky digi channels, dont promise you will want them tho!