Any ideas?

Author
Discussion

currymonster

Original Poster:

3,928 posts

274 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2002
quotequote all
A mate of mine needs a new motor. He has the princeley sum of £4000 to spend and wants a reliable tin top. I have tried to steer him in the direction of a Beemer or a Nissan 200SX (supposedly a pretty good car) anyone got any better suggestions? Cheers, Curry.

ohidunno

506 posts

277 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2002
quotequote all
High mileage MKIII Golf GTi?

Cotty

40,062 posts

289 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2002
quotequote all
Your on the right track with the Bimmer I have just picked up a 325i Touring for £3,795 (the saloon/coupe are around the same price) you can get a very good one for £4,000.
Mine is a 1992 J with 54,000 on the clock is almost factory fresh and goes like s**t off a shovel.

DIGGA

41,086 posts

288 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2002
quotequote all
This is great - a sub £4k discussion - love it. Too many people (particularly this site) forget that you don't need shed loads of cash to enjoy motoring!

Don't have too much specific advice, but it always surpises me how the larger saloons, with bigger engines depreciate. Provided insurance, and parking aren't issues, you can get a lot of good metal if you go for the 'larger than the Mondeo' cars. I have been told by various people that the Vauxhall Omega and Senator were good drivers, only spoiled by the badge.

Jason F

1,183 posts

289 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2002
quotequote all
I second the BMW idea. They are pretty cheap at the moment too..

dan

1,068 posts

289 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2002
quotequote all
How about a leggy VR6 Golf.

Ended up selling my 94 5dr VR6 with 138,000 for less than 4K, the guy that bought it was laughing all the way to his insurance company, who charged him 1,600 quid.

Damn fine car, if I could justify the fact that the insurance was almost as much as the Griff I would have kept it...

... Oh hang on I'm not really selling this idea am I...

... I'll get me coat.

mags

1,137 posts

284 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2002
quotequote all
I have to agree with the beemer route, I recently bought a FBMWSH, totally mint 535i '90 full leather, goes like stink (does like a drink though!)
£2400 well worth the money, a lot of car for not much cash, and its quicker than most tin tops.

Mags

Paul V

4,489 posts

282 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2002
quotequote all
How’s about an older Porsche 944 or a 924 turbo, still something a bit different.

currymonster

Original Poster:

3,928 posts

274 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2002
quotequote all
Mags and/or Cotty, what sort of insurance money are you chaps shelling out?

MattW

1,076 posts

289 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2002
quotequote all
How about a Ford Probe?

Admittedly they won't set the world on fire but you should be able to get a fairly decent 24v v6 one for £4k - should be well spec'd as well with leather, air con, cruise etc.

Alternatively you could go for its soul mate the Mazda MX-6. There’s a good one on the Autotrader site at the moment - 2.5v6, leather, aircon, 32k, Auto all for £3,750

The Xedos 6 (2.0 V6) is quite cheap as well although I have no idea what they are like - seem well spec'd though.

Matt

mags

1,137 posts

284 months

Tuesday 22nd January 2002
quotequote all
Currymonster, Its a bit difficult to say really, I sold my old E30 M3 and I hadn't had the current policy for long, When I went to change/cancel/get a refund they basically stiched me up rotten (no surprise there!) and it worked out cheaper for me to just carry on with the policy, with a small refund.
So after all that bollox, I think its roughly £500 fully comp with FNCB, car on driveway, no alarm (the M3 was about £700)
I hope to reduce this a a fair bit at renewal time.
I think the bigger engined BM's are quite high on insurance, but they loose value quickly and hence become a right bargain.(unless they go wrong!) I was luckey though, I nearly bought one for almost the same price in nowhere near as good condition.
I was supposed to be buying a Cerb this year, but my miserable xmas bonus canned that, so the BM is a stop gap (hopefully)
Still, at least I still have a job, at the mo'

currymonster

Original Poster:

3,928 posts

274 months

Thursday 24th January 2002
quotequote all
£500 sounds alright to me, particularly with no alarm... I am still trying to persuade this pal of mine that he doesnt want a Datsun Cherry. Anyone got any experience of the aforementioned Nissan 200 SX??

mags

1,137 posts

284 months

Thursday 24th January 2002
quotequote all
To be honest I am not a fan of Jap cars, I can't stand the dodgy interiors and the lack of comfort etc.
I drove a mates Scooby STI and whilst impressed by its speed and handling, I spend more time in my car driving in traffic than I do punting down lanes, so I would rather have a bit of luxury than just stripped out racer. Thats why I would rather have a TVR over a evo7/scooby any day, a bit of luxury and leather (ooerr!)

currymonster

Original Poster:

3,928 posts

274 months

Thursday 24th January 2002
quotequote all
The chap in question is currently punting round in some god-awful 900cc Mitsubishi hatchback his gran gave him. It's got a puddle in the footwell you could fish in and about as much power as a lawnmower. Compared to that, almost anything would seem like luxury.

trefor

14,654 posts

288 months

Thursday 24th January 2002
quotequote all
I had an N reg'd (so the current shape) 200sx. The Turbo was uprated to produce around 260bhp. Very nice car, and in my eyes good looking in a grown up kinda way. 30mpg if driving normally. Went like stink, RWD handling, comfy for a lanky git like me. Very reliable and quite rare. Not cheap insurance though (same as TVR for me).

Swapped it for a Chimaera 4 years ago - the TVR is easier to drive fast in the wet and we know the other benefits.

If you get one, get a manual, Touring version (Leather, air, CD). (I've never understood why people bother with Turbos on an Automatic).

T/.

atg

21,141 posts

277 months

Thursday 24th January 2002
quotequote all
I second the 200sx option. Value for money wise, they are very hard to beat. They are getting long in the tooth, but the older model is supposed to be a better drive than the (not-very) new shape.

craigw

12,248 posts

287 months

Thursday 24th January 2002
quotequote all
original BMW M3 ?

jna

87 posts

277 months

Thursday 24th January 2002
quotequote all
Currymonster, I have a N reg 200sx Auto, had it about six months as a stop gap, goes like stink I have used it most days to go to work in on M3 and M25 hence auto choice, servicing is cheap body work seems to last well alloys are still mint and interior has lasted very well, at the time I bought it it was the newest fun car with aircon, leather and all the toys that I could get for the money.
Its done 62k now and I am selling it for about £5,200, as I have got another couple of cars now and I am not using it.
Gets my vote as you get all the toys and its quicker than a 328 for less money.

John_S

22 posts

282 months

Friday 25th January 2002
quotequote all
Firstly, can anybody help me out too. I need a big 4/5door family/tow car. I can't decide between ST24, a PUG406 V6 or Laguna V6 ? Any ideas ? Anybody had one of these ? Is the 406 faster than the ST24 ? Please help me spend my 6 grand !!
As for 4 grand, I would go with the above, and say Porsche944/924, Nissan 200ZX or a nice BMW. Now if your mate can afford the insurance, I could also mention that some RS Saphire Cosworths and the odd 3dr Sierra Cosworth can be found around the 4 grand mark. Perhaps a PUG 205 GTi or Mazda 323 4x4 Turbo ?
Regards John S

cirks

2,478 posts

288 months

Friday 25th January 2002
quotequote all
Like Trevor I used to have an N reg 200SX and would agree with everything he said (except one bit;see below) but definately the bit about the TVR being easier in the wet. The 200 was actually quite scary at times and nowhere near as predictable. Very quick though.

>(I've never understood why people bother with Turbos on an Automatic).
Um, Saab 95 Aero AUTO estate (my day-to-day car) does 0-60 in 7.1 (or 7.3 depending on mag). The Turbo helps quite a lot and in sport mode will wipe the floor with just about anything between 50 and 100! Unless, of course, you have shagged front tyres like mine does currently in which case all 230bhp and a lot of torque just helps you do a ver stationary 0-60 with the front wheels spinning beautifully...