The absolute state of HGV medicals...

The absolute state of HGV medicals...

Author
Discussion

Getragdogleg

Original Poster:

9,100 posts

190 months

Wednesday 24th July
quotequote all
Just had my "your 50 so need another medical" letter through from DVLA/DVSA. Go get another medical done because you are 5 years older.

Ok, No problem, phone the Doctors to be told that they cannot do it for 8 weeks ! But its ok, there is a private company doing medicals fairly close by and they are quicker.

Go online and arrange a medical with them, 10 days later, so much faster than my GP can manage and its half the price. Bargain.

The day comes, I go to the hotel that the medical is getting done at and wait with others in a corridor, place is busy, £60 a go.

Get called in and the doctor is a Chinese man, not brilliant at English so is hard to understand, asks me if i drink/do drugs or have anything wrong with me, i say no to all, he then speedruns my medical form using a rubber stamp in many places, does an eye test with a board on the wall, does blood pressure and then 7 minutes after my appointment started I'm out the door and the next guy is being ushered in.

I am pretty sure that this is not what the Govt had in mind when they decided they want us checked over every 5 years, I could have been lying my arse off and had loads of conditions I was not telling them about, so long as my blood pressure was ok and I could read the chart that was the total extent of the "examination".

This is a total waste of £60 and a two hour round trip and the money is going to a private company who must be doing 6 drivers an hour based on the speed the two guys in front and my own "medical" took.

What a lash up.


hidetheelephants

27,821 posts

200 months

Wednesday 24th July
quotequote all
MCA medicals for seafarers are the same; some examiners are really just certificate mills, unless you have a wooden leg or literally have a coronary in their office you'll come out with a new ticket in 30 minutes in exchange for £120 or whatever it is now. Some of the blimps I see waddling up gangways in Aberdeen I wonder how the medics don't get busted, when they turn red and start wheezing after a single flight of stairs or struggle to fit through doors they're a danger to themselves and anyone unlucky enough to share a ship with them.

Smint

1,984 posts

42 months

Thursday 25th July
quotequote all
Speak to other drivers in your area, there will probably be a doctor (not part of company) who specialises in industrial medicals.

I use one such, half the price my own NHS doctor would charge (funny how you can't get a NHS appointment to see a real doc but instantly available for £140ish medical), but by specialising in such medicals always gets the paperwork right and does a thorough job.



Stick Legs

5,910 posts

172 months

Thursday 25th July
quotequote all
hidetheelephants said:
MCA medicals for seafarers are the same; some examiners are really just certificate mills, unless you have a wooden leg or literally have a coronary in their office you'll come out with a new ticket in 30 minutes in exchange for £120 or whatever it is now. Some of the blimps I see waddling up gangways in Aberdeen I wonder how the medics don't get busted, when they turn red and start wheezing after a single flight of stairs or struggle to fit through doors they're a danger to themselves and anyone unlucky enough to share a ship with them.
Yeah and there are others who restrict an ENG.1 at the drop of a hat. Chap I sailed with, easily one of the fittest people I have ever met, rugby player at a good level & runner got restricted ENG.1 for his BMI being >30.

rolleyes

markymarkthree

2,545 posts

178 months

Thursday 25th July
quotequote all
Last time i had a HGV medical (7 years ago), the quack said i had to go to an opticians for the eye test.

Getragdogleg

Original Poster:

9,100 posts

190 months

Thursday 25th July
quotequote all
Its a lash up all round. Its a money spinner and very little else now.

Nothing to do with its original purpose and now just money from me to them as often as possible.

towser44

3,665 posts

122 months

Friday 26th July
quotequote all
Mate of mine had his in a van in a layby for £45 a couple of months ago.

s p a c e m a n

11,000 posts

155 months

Tuesday 30th July
quotequote all
Medical? I've just spent £165 and have to sit indoors for the next 3 Sundays to stare at my phone trying to stay awake for 7 hours whilst some bloke bores me with CPC bullst hehe

hidetheelephants

27,821 posts

200 months

Tuesday 30th July
quotequote all
s p a c e m a n said:
Medical? I've just spent £165 and have to sit indoors for the next 3 Sundays to stare at my phone trying to stay awake for 7 hours whilst some bloke bores me with CPC bullst hehe
The MCA have that beaten too; seafarers have regular mandatory death by powerpoint sessions, except we still have to turn up and sit in a classroom.

nismocat

768 posts

15 months

Wednesday 31st July
quotequote all
markymarkthree said:
Last time i had a HGV medical (7 years ago), the quack said i had to go to an opticians for the eye test.
And did you?

the-norseman

13,400 posts

178 months

Wednesday 31st July
quotequote all
My last medical which was my first one, was quite thorough. Cant remember how much now but it was at a proper private doctors.

markymarkthree

2,545 posts

178 months

Wednesday 31st July
quotequote all
nismocat said:
markymarkthree said:
Last time i had a HGV medical (7 years ago), the quack said i had to go to an opticians for the eye test.
And did you?
Yes and i think they took £25 from me for the eye test part.

ArmaghMan

2,517 posts

187 months

Wednesday 25th September
quotequote all
Smint said:
Speak to other drivers in your area, there will probably be a doctor (not part of company) who specialises in industrial medicals.

I use one such, half the price my own NHS doctor would charge (funny how you can't get a NHS appointment to see a real doc but instantly available for £140ish medical), but by specialising in such medicals always gets the paperwork right and does a thorough job.
Funny but you are absolutely wrong.
Mrs. AM is a GP partner.
Each partner does 1 HGV medical per week.End of.
Money genuinely has nothing to do with it.
Proper HGV medical takes ages and earns pittance.


ymwoods

2,186 posts

184 months

Wednesday 25th September
quotequote all
ArmaghMan said:
Each partner does 1 HGV medical per week.End of.
Money genuinely has nothing to do with it.
Proper HGV medical takes ages and earns pittance.
Thats the point though. Very easy not to get a "proper" one...even if you wanted to.

My first one was as some describe above where I went into a makeshift office in a doctor's garage on a Sat. In and out in less than 10 minutes with no actual checks done.

I seem to remember a HGV medical company being shut down for it a few years ago and anyone that had medicals with them that had not already submitted them were told they were void and they needed to go elsewhere. The problem is that there is dozens of these companies using hundreds of doctors to do "friendly" medicals. Most of the time not even at the driver's request, just to get as many punters through the door.

grumpy52

5,716 posts

173 months

Tuesday 1st October
quotequote all
Pretty much the same situation with motorsport medicals