Anything better than a twin cab pick up?

Anything better than a twin cab pick up?

Author
Discussion

Pflanzgarten

Original Poster:

4,900 posts

32 months

Friday 28th April 2023
quotequote all
Time to replace a twin cab pick up, but what with?

Main duties are lugging around diggers and plant, throwing tools in the back, occasionally using as a family vehicle (school drop off or taking bikes etc to the woods).

Problem is of course, trying to run it through the books of a limited company (construction).

An Ineos Grenadier really appeals but it grates that my company will use and abuse it but I’ll pay for the upkeep out of my own pocket.

A Defender Hard Top might look the part but only has three seats and cost something like £70k!

A standard defender ran as a company car means loads on BIK, although better than a Grenadier if I went PHEV version).

I’d really rather not go down the dedicated van and second car route if possible but I can’t see a whole lot of options.

MDMA .

9,207 posts

108 months

Friday 28th April 2023
quotequote all
Land Rover Discovery commercial. With a rear seat conversion (fold flat). Kids won’t be able to drop the rear windows though, if it matters.

Edited by MDMA . on Friday 28th April 17:30

Flyin Banana

2,178 posts

245 months

Saturday 29th April 2023
quotequote all
Stick with the pick up, put it through the business and claim 100% of it back at the end of the year, if you want a Isuzu D-Max just let me know

Rob

sunbeam alpine

7,079 posts

195 months

Saturday 29th April 2023
quotequote all
Flyin Banana said:
Stick with the pick up, put it through the business and claim 100% of it back at the end of the year...
^^This. It's exactly what a pickup is made for.

Pflanzgarten

Original Poster:

4,900 posts

32 months

Saturday 29th April 2023
quotequote all
sunbeam alpine said:
Flyin Banana said:
Stick with the pick up, put it through the business and claim 100% of it back at the end of the year...
^^This. It's exactly what a pickup is made for.
The problem is, my Amarok is getting increasingly old and really at the point I would like to change it. To put it bluntly, no other pick up I've driven is as good at doing the work stuff and being a comfy well equipped family car.

About the minus I'd want to get away with in a Land Rover is currently £71k (less the VAT) plus another £3k for the rear seat conversion.

sunbeam alpine

7,079 posts

195 months

Saturday 29th April 2023
quotequote all
Pflanzgarten said:
The problem is, my Amarok is getting increasingly old and really at the point I would like to change it. To put it bluntly, no other pick up I've driven is as good at doing the work stuff and being a comfy well equipped family car...
Sorry - I read your OP as "occasional" use. I have a Hilux which gets used pretty much like yours does, but I wouldn't want to use it regularly as a family car, or it to be my only vehicle. Have they stopped making the Amarok?

DirktheDaring

522 posts

19 months

Saturday 29th April 2023
quotequote all
Surely the new Amarok/Ranger?

Pflanzgarten

Original Poster:

4,900 posts

32 months

Saturday 29th April 2023
quotequote all
sunbeam alpine said:
Pflanzgarten said:
The problem is, my Amarok is getting increasingly old and really at the point I would like to change it. To put it bluntly, no other pick up I've driven is as good at doing the work stuff and being a comfy well equipped family car...
Sorry - I read your OP as "occasional" use. I have a Hilux which gets used pretty much like yours does, but I wouldn't want to use it regularly as a family car, or it to be my only vehicle. Have they stopped making the Amarok?
I think occasional use fits the bill, I do the school run and if we go camping/holidays take the truck. We have an EV that also works perfectly for us but if we go across country I wouldn't use it.

FWIW the children love "daddies truck" and would like to use it more!

Pflanzgarten

Original Poster:

4,900 posts

32 months

Saturday 29th April 2023
quotequote all
DirktheDaring said:
Surely the new Amarok/Ranger?
I'm not so keen and of three friends who've run the previous model Rangers, all have had fairly serious problems with them reliability-wise.

I understand the irony of complaining about reliability whilst posting about a possible Land Rover purchase!

DirktheDaring

522 posts

19 months

Saturday 29th April 2023
quotequote all
Pflanzgarten said:
I'm not so keen and of three friends who've run the previous model Rangers, all have had fairly serious problems with them reliability-wise.

I understand the irony of complaining about reliability whilst posting about a possible Land Rover purchase!
Yep, same, got a friend with the 3.2 that had a new engine under warranty (oil pressure issue?) and then needed another at 4 years old.

The new Amarok looks epic, but I’m not sure which oily bits are Ford and which are VW.


Pflanzgarten

Original Poster:

4,900 posts

32 months

Saturday 29th April 2023
quotequote all
DirktheDaring said:
Pflanzgarten said:
I'm not so keen and of three friends who've run the previous model Rangers, all have had fairly serious problems with them reliability-wise.

I understand the irony of complaining about reliability whilst posting about a possible Land Rover purchase!
Yep, same, got a friend with the 3.2 that had a new engine under warranty (oil pressure issue?) and then needed another at 4 years old.

The new Amarok looks epic, but I’m not sure which oily bits are Ford and which are VW.
The new Amarok is all Ford underneath, for better or worse.

Smint

1,984 posts

42 months

Sunday 30th April 2023
quotequote all
Have regretted selling our 3 litre auto Hilux many times when we no longer needed its carrying capacity, it drove car like and with the fixed hardtop giving a little more unladen weight over the back had perfectly acceptable ride and handling, albeit tyre choice makes all the difference to how a pick up handles and rides as is typical for any mainly RWD vehicle.

I'd have another auto Hilux if i needed a dual purpose vehicle, don't have the ticking time bomb mechanical issues of some other brands, decent resale value at any age.

s p a c e m a n

11,000 posts

155 months

Monday 1st May 2023
quotequote all
Can you claim back on American trucks? Seen loads of new dodge rams around here recently..

https://51stateautos.com/

Pflanzgarten

Original Poster:

4,900 posts

32 months

Monday 1st May 2023
quotequote all
Smint said:
Hilux
Try getting one, minimum one year wait for a new one as they can't import/sell enough to satisfy demand. The ten year warranty is the major selling point although they don't drive as nice or have as much capacity as the Amarok.

Ivan stewart

2,792 posts

43 months

Wednesday 3rd May 2023
quotequote all
Pick up , just had yet another Hilux maybe not the best to drive but 100% no nonsense , looked at the Ranger nice but everything Ford commercial I’ve had recently has been trouble and the dealers are swamped with problems, looked at Isuzu look great but only available with the tiny engine and the reliability around DPF’s seems dubious also the dealers seem to have an “arrangement with each other “ shall we say !! Or they did when I was looking at a truck !!

MDMA .

9,207 posts

108 months

Wednesday 3rd May 2023
quotequote all
Pflanzgarten said:
Smint said:
Hilux
Try getting one, minimum one year wait for a new one as they can't import/sell enough to satisfy demand. The ten year warranty is the major selling point although they don't drive as nice or have as much capacity as the Amarok.
It’s 5 months for a Hilux. October delivery if you order today. Plenty new ones for sale in the classifieds. If you want a firm date/lead time, my mate knows the DP of a big Toyota dealership in the North West.