Volvo 750 v Scania 730

Author
Discussion

rb51

Original Poster:

92 posts

191 months

Sunday 27th November 2016
quotequote all
Has anyone any experience of driving both these trucks back to back
And how they compare to each other in Performance and drivability
Also is there much difference in price of same spec tractor units.



caelite

4,282 posts

119 months

Monday 28th November 2016
quotequote all
Cant comment on performance, I know the topline Scania's certainly trump the globetrotter Volvo's for living space. My guess would be the Scania costing a fair whack more because V8 badges.

rb51

Original Poster:

92 posts

191 months

Monday 28th November 2016
quotequote all
Scania can put any price on there flag ship people will
Always buy them as you say for the V8 badge.

martin mrt

3,831 posts

208 months

Tuesday 29th November 2016
quotequote all
Company local to me has both for running the continent.

I'm not a fan of the FH4 cab layout and much preferred the R series Topline cab, more room and useable space, however with griffin spec the Scania falls short on Storage space using up 2 top lockers for the microwave and coffee maker, the under bunk drawer is substituted for the fridge freezer.

The Volvo comes with 3 cupboards along the back wall which is a massive bonus and certainly helps if doing multiple nights out.

As for performance, the 750 has the edge, the I shift gearbox being the main factor, scanias opticruise just can't match it.




rb51

Original Poster:

92 posts

191 months

Friday 2nd December 2016
quotequote all
Never thought of the transmission factor I shift realy
Is king.

bigfatnick

1,012 posts

209 months

Friday 2nd December 2016
quotequote all
It'll be nice if one day the i-shift dual clutch can be spec'ed with the fh16, that'll be a weapon!

Unrelated to power but recently I went from a v8 R500 topline to a FH3 460. (More money, less hours, less fancy truck). The FH is ergonomically superior but so much smaller than the Topline! As stated above, transmissions are a world apart, I find in the scania gearbox is fine, so long as you use it in manual mode 100% of the time (especially if you have noisy exhausts like I used to - nothing makes you look like a tit like a revving the tits off your noisy scania and jolting in and out of the wrong gear)

That 40bhp makes such a difference at these power levels, but you have to ask yourself if 20bhp makes even a noticeable difference at those big numbers!

Edited by bigfatnick on Friday 2nd December 21:42