Mannol Oil

Author
Discussion

Tony1963

4,950 posts

165 months

Monday 10th June
quotequote all
dirky dirk said:
Ive always used it
In a 120k peugeot 107, a new beetle, a golf been fine in everything
My mate used bus oil as it was free it was fine
An oil that doesn’t destroy an engine, and an oil that allows an engine to operate as designed might well be two very different things. With an old car that has little resale value, cheap oil can make sense. But in a newer car, with a complex engine and great value to the owner? The extra few quid on the correct oil is money well spent.

WhiskyDisco

816 posts

77 months

Monday 10th June
quotequote all
Is there a case for using different grade of oil on an older car that has covered a few miles?

My Mini uses the LL04 spec 5W 30 but it's nearly 20 years old and newly 70k miles. Would you consider a lower viscosity or stick with the spec?

Belle427

9,217 posts

236 months

Monday 10th June
quotequote all
WhiskyDisco said:
Is there a case for using different grade of oil on an older car that has covered a few miles?

My Mini uses the LL04 spec 5W 30 but it's nearly 20 years old and newly 70k miles. Would you consider a lower viscosity or stick with the spec?
Stick to the recommended.
Sometimes people may change to a slightly thicker grade if the engine burnt a lot of oil but care must be taken when doing this.

Tony1963

4,950 posts

165 months

Tuesday 11th June
quotequote all
WhiskyDisco said:
Is there a case for using different grade of oil on an older car that has covered a few miles?

My Mini uses the LL04 spec 5W 30 but it's nearly 20 years old and newly 70k miles. Would you consider a lower viscosity or stick with the spec?
On most cars, 70k miles isn’t a lot. Unless you’ve ragged it on most journeys, start to finish.

Yazza54

18,891 posts

184 months

Tuesday 11th June
quotequote all
Use engine and gear oil from mannol in my truck, as well as a few cars. I wouldn't use it in a performance vehicle but saying that it would probably be fine.

DegsyE39

579 posts

130 months

Friday 21st June
quotequote all
Been using it in my pd130 golf for the past 3 years £350 shed mind you..

Engine has done 234,000 though.. I change my own oil and filter every 3 thousand miles, I'm actually gonna plump for some shell helix or something in future now the car has proved it's reliability! Lets see if the ££££ stuff is better than mannol (which has been fine tbf) tank

Yazza54

18,891 posts

184 months

Friday 21st June
quotequote all
DegsyE39 said:
Been using it in my pd130 golf for the past 3 years £350 shed mind you..

Engine has done 234,000 though.. I change my own oil and filter every 3 thousand miles, I'm actually gonna plump for some shell helix or something in future now the car has proved it's reliability! Lets see if the ££££ stuff is better than mannol (which has been fine tbf) tank
rofl the poor thing has finally proved itself to you hahhaa

DegsyE39

579 posts

130 months

Friday 21st June
quotequote all
Yazza54 said:
DegsyE39 said:
Been using it in my pd130 golf for the past 3 years £350 shed mind you..

Engine has done 234,000 though.. I change my own oil and filter every 3 thousand miles, I'm actually gonna plump for some shell helix or something in future now the car has proved it's reliability! Lets see if the ££££ stuff is better than mannol (which has been fine tbf) tank
rofl the poor thing has finally proved itself to you hahhaa
I bought the car off of gumtree really badly written ad terrible pictures got there and there wasn't even oil registering on the dipstick! frown

But car take back had offered me £295 for it anyway so just had to get the old dog home, 3 years later still runs fine hence next oil change im gonna stick something premium in! Great cockroach like cars the mk4 golfs

g3org3y

20,772 posts

194 months

Saturday 22nd June
quotequote all
Interesting thread, like the OP I've seen Mannol oil advertised on eBay and it is A LOT cheaper (half price) compared to next cheapest BMW LL04 equivalent.

Smint

1,808 posts

38 months

Saturday 22nd June
quotequote all
DegsyE39 said:
, I'm actually gonna plump for some shell helix
I bought some of that when it was on offer, Prado sounded like a bag of nails.
Quiet running resumed and has been the case with Exol, Fuchs etc.


Edited by Smint on Saturday 22 June 14:54

Belle427

9,217 posts

236 months

Saturday 22nd June
quotequote all
Ive just splashed out £15 on some to try in my Audi with 163k on it, will see how it sounds.
Big spender me.

g3org3y

20,772 posts

194 months

Saturday 22nd June
quotequote all
Belle427 said:
Ive just splashed out £15 on some to try in my Audi with 163k on it, will see how it sounds.
Big spender me.
Let us know how you get on.

I ended up going for 20 litres of Petronas Syntium.

chris1roll

1,713 posts

247 months

Saturday 22nd June
quotequote all
I've been using Smith and Allan
https://www.smithandallan.com/
in the whole families fleet for a few years now.

99 year old company, members of the VLA etc, and distribution partners with Shell.

Their website search function doesn't always work 100% (probably due to short search terms when looking for specs - e.g. "A3") but their service has been second to none so far and they are available to talk to on the phone.