Any Forester Drivers?

Any Forester Drivers?

Author
Discussion

stedaley

Original Poster:

643 posts

131 months

Wednesday 23rd March 2016
quotequote all
Anyone on here with a forester? That dont use it to ship family around?

Im only 24 and have been looking at various cars but seem to always come back to the forester, Not really sure why, but i think the fact it can be used all year, and can be enjoyed whilst doing tasks you need a big car for! And it is liked by insurers being a car you wouldnt think could do a sub 6 second 0-60. It also has that innocent 'im a estate car' look which really classes it as a sleeper to me!

I have never actually seen a STI Forester, or a Spec'd up XT as these two are the ones id be looking at, but having been on a few subaru forums, im looking to get some info on the ownership side and possibly have a nice Samaritan take me out in one/let me come have a look!

Im in either the South (Portsmouth) or The NW (Liverpool)

Ive heard the engines are pretty bullet proof if looked after, i 6 month service my current car even though it really doesnt need it, so this shouldnt be much different.

Ive also noticed the price on these is quite high as its an import, (STI) and stay fairly consistent, if i was to buy one at around 9k and keep it for a few years, it doesnt look like id lose anything going off the last 3 years with prices? anyone sold one/bought one for this reason?


jonesof63

947 posts

144 months

Wednesday 23rd March 2016
quotequote all
Hi, the Forester is a great choice and a brilliant all rounder, you will find lots of help and expert opinions on the link I've posted. Have a look at some of the Fsti's the guys in the U.K own, they're fabulous. http://www.subaruforester.org/vbulletin/f75/

lavaJava

103 posts

115 months

Thursday 24th March 2016
quotequote all
I bought my XTEn in August and am still grinning. No mods (yet, saving up £60 at a time). Mine is burgundy with cream leather - like sitting in a greenhouse with all the glass around - proper 'old man' spec - though it can embarrass quite a lot of prestige metal. I love mine.

I do find myself browsing AT looking at the STIs though - *only* a few grand more than mine, but *soooo* much more car smile

I'm Leeds-based, so unable to help with the test drive.

Do it - you'll love it!

BurgerKing

44 posts

175 months

Thursday 24th March 2016
quotequote all
XTen PPP here, still loving it despite forking out for an engine rebuild due to failed head gaskets. Very practical, great mid-range power from the 2.5 and there's still nothing else quite like it available.

I would like the 6 speed box and sports seats from the STI though, my car is black with cream leather armchairs!!

I work near Manchester Airport, but I doubt that's much help to you.

MDMA .

9,210 posts

108 months

Thursday 24th March 2016
quotequote all
I have a FSTI. in Wigan if you are passing and want a look. there is a breakfast meet at GTCARS in Appleton on 3rd April. will be there if you have a drive over.



exhaust clip. was a cold night :

Edited by MDMA . on Thursday 24th March 14:35



now fitted with smaller plates :



Edited by MDMA . on Thursday 24th March 14:39

Russ T Bolt

1,695 posts

290 months

Thursday 24th March 2016
quotequote all
stedaley said:
Ive heard the engines are pretty bullet proof if looked after
I bought a 2.5 XT new in Jan 2006, I don't cart family around and loved it, right up to the point where the head gasket(s) failed in 2012. I never skimped on maintenance and it was always looked after by the Subaru dealer I bought it from.

Prior to that I had 3 Imprezza's of varying types, they all had the 2.0 engine, which I did find to be bullet proof.

v8250

2,735 posts

218 months

Friday 25th March 2016
quotequote all
Russ T Bolt said:
I bought a 2.5 XT new in Jan 2006, I don't cart family around and loved it, right up to the point where the head gasket(s) failed in 2012. I never skimped on maintenance and it was always looked after by the Subaru dealer I bought it from.

Prior to that I had 3 Imprezza's of varying types, they all had the 2.0 engine, which I did find to be bullet proof.
Genuine question...how many miles had the engine, at point of head gasket failure?

I too have a 2006 XT, it's now at 72,000 miles. We hear lots of doom and gloom notes about the 2.5ltr engine...head gasket and ringland failure...but it's also been shown that failures lie within a certain group of engine numbers; this, primarily from US model feedback.

themanwithnoname

1,634 posts

220 months

Friday 25th March 2016
quotequote all
MDMA . said:
I have a FSTI. in Wigan if you are passing and want a look. there is a breakfast meet at GTCARS in Appleton on 3rd April. will be there if you have a drive over.
Likewise i'll be there in my facelift FSTI all being well.

MDMA .

9,210 posts

108 months

Friday 25th March 2016
quotequote all
themanwithnoname said:
Likewise i'll be there in my facelift FSTI all being well.
That or a gt3 ! See you there.

Russ T Bolt

1,695 posts

290 months

Friday 25th March 2016
quotequote all
v8250 said:
Genuine question...how many miles had the engine, at point of head gasket failure?

I too have a 2006 XT, it's now at 72,000 miles. We hear lots of doom and gloom notes about the 2.5ltr engine...head gasket and ringland failure...but it's also been shown that failures lie within a certain group of engine numbers; this, primarily from US model feedback.
From memory it was around 76,000. It always ran fine, then one morning having picked my sister up from Heathrow got almost home and the temp went off the gauge. I stopped let it cool down and drove home.

Took it into the Subaru dealer who looked after it and they had just fixed an identical car with same symptoms so could tell me what was wrong and likely cost.

Real shame because I loved the car and haven't yet found anything to replace it with, the Toyota was a stopgap. I keep looking at the new XT but auto only puts me off.


Edited by Russ T Bolt on Friday 25th March 10:40

MDMA .

9,210 posts

108 months

Friday 25th March 2016
quotequote all
Was it not worth fixing and keeping if you liked it that much ?

Russ T Bolt

1,695 posts

290 months

Friday 25th March 2016
quotequote all
MDMA . said:
Was it not worth fixing and keeping if you liked it that much ?
It was going to be between £5 and £6k from memory, depending on what they found when they got the engine out.

The same car they had just fixed was around £5700 so didn't make financial sense.

MDMA .

9,210 posts

108 months

Friday 25th March 2016
quotequote all
Main stealers ! Basic head gasket job no more than 1k at a specialist. You can get a forged engine for 4k. Total rip-off merchants.

v8250

2,735 posts

218 months

Friday 25th March 2016
quotequote all
MDMA . said:
Main stealers ! Basic head gasket job no more than 1k at a specialist. You can get a forged engine for 4k. Total rip-off merchants.
This +1.

76k miles...so have another 4k miles to go. Will report back when all goes bang, temp needle off the gauge wink

vxr2010

2,597 posts

166 months

Friday 25th March 2016
quotequote all
I have an fSti , the only ever issues I have had with it was crank bearings and head gasket , it's a very quick capable car it works well with a cat back system a remap and a thicker rear arb , fuel economy I have had 32.5 to 35 mpg, I have a ver 7 Sti it leaves the ver 7 for dead on the initial move off till the turbo on the ver 7 spools up , the fsti has so much more torque , the Sti with forged Pistons welded oil pick up pipe race spec crank bearings and arp head bolts is problem solved , it was probably quicker than my friends spec d in same tune due to smaller turbo on Sti and quicker spool up , when my fsti finally gets beyond economical repair I will get another one

Codd

81 posts

178 months

Sunday 27th March 2016
quotequote all
I've a 99 S turbo. Not as quick as all these STI and XTs, but still makes me smile : )

corvus

431 posts

159 months

Monday 28th March 2016
quotequote all
I've had a 2.0XT for three years. Brilliant, reliable car that is great in all weathers and a bit different. I haven't seen another one in my colour (blue/silver) since I bought it! I can't honestly see what I could replace mine with apart from another Forester.

BurgerKing

44 posts

175 months

Monday 28th March 2016
quotequote all
My head gaskets went at 88k miles, as described earlier, running normally and then the temperature gauge just kept going up. It cooled down, the air lock seemed to move and it got me home but it was pretty clear what the fault was and Prosport confirmed it. It would run all day off boost but where's the fun in that?

Anyway I went with the forged rebuild option and even without a remap it feels superb again, very tempted to do some upgrades (4 pot brakes etc.) and a remap. When they stripped the engine down it was very clean as it had been serviced by the book and always run on Shell Helix Ultra oil, the cylinder bores were in excellent shape and there were no signs of abuse, basically I did nothing wrong. Prosport didn't do the build btw.

It was a close call but I decided to fix the car and run it until it really dies, it's just too good. The radiator went last month as well, not a big thing but still annoying.

vxr2010

2,597 posts

166 months

Wednesday 30th March 2016
quotequote all
I think I will run my fsti into the ground , it's prob on 135 k miles now , it makes the odd noise but I think rear diff is the culprit on over run but it's not worn , gearbox is good , engine was rebuilt and it goes like a stabbed rat

MikeyLCR

501 posts

188 months

Wednesday 30th March 2016
quotequote all
vxr2010 said:
I think I will run my fsti into the ground , it's prob on 135 k miles now , it makes the odd noise but I think rear diff is the culprit on over run but it's not worn , gearbox is good , engine was rebuilt and it goes like a stabbed rat
smile I must admit I'm starting to think this is the way to go for me too, mines on 94+k and hasn't shown any signs of problems, had a clutch a while back and a second timing belt as a precaution. I've tried selling it but I'm thinking engine rebuild and some more goodies and keep going, to get anything new that's this capable will cost so much.