Super Unleaded Petrol

Super Unleaded Petrol

Author
Discussion

havard01

Original Poster:

108 posts

182 months

Friday 23rd March 2012
quotequote all
I've been using Shell V-Power since I bought my car, but I've just been to my local Shell garage to find the pump locked off, when I asked the girl at the counter she said the petrol station was closing, so there goes my source of V-Power.

Does anybody use any other type of Super Unleaded or should I travel out of my way to get V-Power?

ScoobieWRX

4,863 posts

233 months

Friday 23rd March 2012
quotequote all
Tesco 99RON (now called Momentum), same deal as V-Power 99RON.

Vixpy1

42,674 posts

271 months

Friday 23rd March 2012
quotequote all
ScoobieWRX said:
Tesco 99RON (now called Momentum), same deal as V-Power 99RON.
What he said

Baryonyx

18,064 posts

166 months

Monday 26th March 2012
quotequote all
VPower is 98 RON. Mind you, I've never used Tesco 99 RON as far as I can recall. VPower has always been my 'go to' fuel when I've driven cars that needed it.

You may find BP Ultimate suitable, as it's 97 RON. I had to use that when I drove my MR2 Turbo to Wetherby services, and I did find it a bit 'pingy' but then the MR2 Turbo was meant to take Japanese 100 RON fuel! I'm currently in the middle of an experiment with my Impreza GX, trying to measure if it's worth using VPower. So far, mpg and performance seems neck and and neck between standard and VPower so I might be on the cheap stuff permanently soon.

markCSC

2,987 posts

222 months

Monday 26th March 2012
quotequote all
Baryonyx said:
VPower is 98 RON.
I think it is 99 RON

Vixpy1

42,674 posts

271 months

Monday 26th March 2012
quotequote all
Subaru's do not like BP ultimate!

mrmr96

13,736 posts

211 months

Monday 26th March 2012
quotequote all
markCSC said:
Baryonyx said:
VPower is 98 RON.
I think it is 99 RON
optimax was 98
vpower is 99
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shell_V-Power#V-Power...

ScoobieWRX

4,863 posts

233 months

Monday 26th March 2012
quotequote all
Vixpy1 said:
Subaru's do not like BP ultimate!
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
What he said and then some!!

JollyGrnMonster

887 posts

204 months

Monday 26th March 2012
quotequote all
Assuming the car wasnt mapped for the shell then esso super isnt bad and is consistent.
Tesco momentum though if you can get it as suggested.

havard01

Original Poster:

108 posts

182 months

Monday 26th March 2012
quotequote all
Thanks for the tips guys, I'm buggered either way for Tesco or Shell fuel as they are now both as far away as each other.

It's not all bad though as I've found out the local garage is only closing for a couple of months as they refit it to have a Costa (lot) Coffee and Subway.

They are probably paying for it with the price they charged for V-Power!

ScoobieWRX

4,863 posts

233 months

Monday 26th March 2012
quotequote all
The only other options you might have for the next couple of weeks then is to get the best fuel you can and chuck a bottle of Octane Booster in with a full tank of fuel, something like Millers. I know there are others. It might do you until you get your V-power back smile

dabiscuit

53 posts

172 months

Tuesday 27th March 2012
quotequote all
ScoobieWRX said:
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
What he said and then some!!
Is that true? I use it because I get Nectar points. Are the super market super unleadeds good enough?

markCSC

2,987 posts

222 months

Tuesday 27th March 2012
quotequote all
dabiscuit said:
ScoobieWRX said:
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
What he said and then some!!
Is that true? I use it because I get Nectar points. Are the super market super unleadeds good enough?
1) Where I live BP is 5p a litre more expensive than anywhere else near by
2) I always seem to get crap MPG when I use BP SUL

so I use it in emergencies only smile

ScoobieWRX

4,863 posts

233 months

Tuesday 27th March 2012
quotequote all
dabiscuit said:
ScoobieWRX said:
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
What he said and then some!!
Is that true? I use it because I get Nectar points. Are the super market super unleadeds good enough?
You've just partly answered your own question. The only reason you buy BP is because you get nectar points not becausae it's any good.

Tesco have been doing 99RON now for a long time and were always the first supermarket brand to have the best super unleaded. I used Tesco 99RON for a long time but these days because i mostly drive diesel and have a Shell garage less than a few hundred yards away i go there instead, but i used to travel several miles for Tesco 99RON when my scoob was still on the road because it was worth it.

Main Petrol companies like BP, Texaco, Total, etc... should be ashamed of themselves for selling the ste superunleaded they do, and charging silly money at only 97RON octane levels from yesteryear, which is nothing less than a total pisstake, and that's why i never ever use them.

These days there is no excuse not to use 99RON either shell or tesco if you drive a scoob or any other high performance N/A or FI car. There are plenty of forecourts up and down the country selling 99RON for you never to be too far away from one wherever you are.

Alex

9,975 posts

291 months

Tuesday 27th March 2012
quotequote all
Interesting.

I recently bought an Impreza P1. They can suffer from big-end failure and it is often speculated on forums that this is due to UK sub-100RON Super Unleaded.

I am not sure about this myself. I could understand low octane fuel causing piston failure, but big-ends?

Anyway, my local filling station is Esso, so my P1 mostly gets Esso Supreme 97RON. What is the opinion of Esso fuels in Subarus?

ScoobieWRX

4,863 posts

233 months

Tuesday 27th March 2012
quotequote all
Same as all the others, ESSO should be doing 99RON same as Tesco and Shell. 97RON is old hat!!

Knock/Det causes BigEnd failure the same as it can cause piston failure or both at the same time.

When you get detonation it puts a lot of stress on the bigends because the piston is in effect being knocked/pushed back down when it's on the upstroke.

Imagine your piston coming up and you're trying to knock it back down with a large hammer. Not only does that pit the top of the piston to the point where eventually you'll knock a hole in the piston, but each of those hammer blows is stressing and damaging those bigend bearings to the point of evetuall failure.

That's happening many thousand of times a minute.

Too much timing, runing to lean, low octane fuel, too much boost etc...Any or all of these issues can and will cause knock to the point of catastrophic failure.

JollyGrnMonster

887 posts

204 months

Tuesday 27th March 2012
quotequote all
No longer agree. You just on the band wagon francis wink

Main reason for bearing failure is oil change routine imho.

The p1 being the car it is fails more due to higher rpm and owners drive harder etc

Seen so many cars come in for mapping detting their heads off on standard map with mods and no issue, relucantly remap so no det and they continue without issue.

Agree it could cause piston damage and do so, but seen no evidence of bearing failure. Seems imho down to oil change routine and high speed runs causing high oil temp and therefore thin bearing film.

Simon

ScoobieWRX

4,863 posts

233 months

Tuesday 27th March 2012
quotequote all
JollyGrnMonster said:
No longer agree. You just on the band wagon francis wink

Main reason for bearing failure is oil change routine imho.

The p1 being the car it is fails more due to higher rpm and owners drive harder etc

Seen so many cars come in for mapping detting their heads off on standard map with mods and no issue, relucantly remap so no det and they continue without issue.

Agree it could cause piston damage and do so, but seen no evidence of bearing failure. Seems imho down to oil change routine and high speed runs causing high oil temp and therefore thin bearing film.

Simon
Band wagon came and went Simon.

And i've seen first hand plenty examples now of *remapped* newage cars, with less than 50K, with full service history and in-between oil changes all the way through, well looked after cars, but with properly buggered bottom ends. And this at between 4000-6000rpm. Not very high rpms in subaru terms and neither would you see very high oil temps at these rpms. A lot of them went quickly too. Pistons OK, end shells fubah!!

Driven hard yes but plenty of evidence from the ECU pulling lots of timing, high knock counts and some very low IAM's in some cases.

I totally agree hard use and sustained high oil temps will kill bearings but knock will do the same and quick smart if not kept in check!! smile

JollyGrnMonster

887 posts

204 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
Its the dealer oil change without priming I mean that causes it.

But the ecu will have pulled timing because it is listenning to the knock.


ScoobieWRX

4,863 posts

233 months

Wednesday 28th March 2012
quotequote all
Even though dealership services and most home DIY oil changes go ahead without disconnecting the crank sensor to prime the oil pump and oil galleries before proper startup, i have to say I've not heard about too many scoobs going pop straight after a service. I'm not saying it doesn't happen but i can't remember too many instances of this happening.

It's fair to say the ECU will have pulled the majority if not all the timing it's going to pull way before big ends started knocking, up to the last point of det.

Thereafter i'm not sure knocking bearings are detected by the ECU are they?? Isn't the resonating frequency of noisy/knocking bearings way outside of 5Khz-6Khz the ECU picks up when det occurs on a Subaru?