This cash incentive to lose weight / stop smoking

This cash incentive to lose weight / stop smoking

Author
Discussion

Cactussed

Original Poster:

5,303 posts

220 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
What are people's views?

Davi

17,153 posts

227 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
Not heard anything about it, but if there is cash involved I'll take smoking back up so I can get in on it...

Austin.J

888 posts

199 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
Davi said:
Not heard anything about it, but if there is cash involved I'll take smoking back up so I can get in on it...
Spot on what i was thinking, might even get a few Mcdonalds down me, double pay!

VR6time

1,656 posts

217 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
Heard nothing about it?

But if it is as simple as that, I would question why people had not quit already, and saved £6 a day on fags, and £4 a day on cake/McD's ect.

If there is an underlying cause of the eating, and they can afford to smoke, then a cash incentive is not going to solve it.

otolith

58,992 posts

211 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
Losing weight or stopping smoking are difficult and unpleasant, you have to really want to do it - enough that you would spend money to do it. If you have to be bribed, you don't really want it, you're doomed to fail or relapse. Stupid idea.

Dupont666

21,678 posts

199 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
Cactussed said:
What are people's views?
Wasnt aware you smoked and is it just the guns that are over weight now and you need to lose the bingo wings?

Or you offering people cash to stop both?

CypherP

4,387 posts

199 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
What happens when the payments run out then? People will be receiving anti-fatty payments for life just to uphold a healthy lifestyle.

If you need to be paid to stop eating so much st or not smoke so much then in my opinion, there is no helping those people. People have been shown what over-eating/living an unhealthy lifestyle and smoking too much can do to you. If that isn't incentive enough to reconsider their lifestyle, the vast majority must be comfortable doing what they're doing.

Oh, and I'm a smoker. I just know when and how to limit myself.

paoloh

8,617 posts

211 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
How about saying this:

Lose weight/give up smoking or no more treatment?

otolith

58,992 posts

211 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
paoloh said:
How about saying this:

Lose weight/give up smoking or no more treatment?
Will you be refunding them their tax/NI contributions?

jesta1865

3,450 posts

216 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
paoloh said:
How about saying this:

Lose weight/give up smoking or no more treatment?
see thats the problem with this gubbermint, and the previous one, and its a mind set we have go into, its always the big stick approach, never a carrot.

i don't think payments will work, i think they should get other things, but why always a big stick?

sinizter

3,348 posts

193 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
Cactussed said:
What are people's views?
fking nonsense.

CypherP

4,387 posts

199 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
paoloh said:
How about saying this:

Lose weight/give up smoking or no more treatment?
Spot on.

Steamer

13,970 posts

220 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
otolith said:
If you have to be bribed, you don't really want it, you're doomed to fail or relapse. Stupid idea.
yes

First thing I thought.

If you have to pay a fatty to get in shape - will fatty-fatty-bum-bum be paying back that incentive money when they go on a 'family fatty bucket' binge!?

shout Bring back bullying I say!... there was only one token fatty in each class when I was in school.

paoloh

8,617 posts

211 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
otolith said:
paoloh said:
How about saying this:

Lose weight/give up smoking or no more treatment?
Will you be refunding them their tax/NI contributions?
Look at this way, if you flooded your house on purpose, would insurance comapny payout?? Would they refund your premiums??

V8mate

45,899 posts

196 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
Cactussed said:
What are people's views?
Any chance of a link to a slightly more enlightening briefing upon which to have a view?

Ganglandboss

8,369 posts

210 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
The money saved by not buying fags was a big enough cash incentive to make me give up.

paoloh

8,617 posts

211 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
V8mate said:
Cactussed said:
What are people's views?
Any chance of a link to a slightly more enlightening briefing upon which to have a view?
It is all over the news, turn a TV on man.

gareth.e

2,071 posts

196 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
fking stupid Idea.. I'd be pissed it it happened

Miguel Alvarez

4,955 posts

177 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
You know where I was when I saw this shock headline? Running that's right running not walking and hanging onto the heart sensor bar on a fking treadmill at a gym at 6.30am this morning.

I hear all this bullst about about people having issues but I've yet to meet someone fat who isn't a crisps and chocolate eating, coca cola drinking, take away ordering sit on their lazy arse fker!!

I hope for one that this doesn't come out of my tax money!!

Davi

17,153 posts

227 months

Monday 27th September 2010
quotequote all
paoloh said:
V8mate said:
Cactussed said:
What are people's views?
Any chance of a link to a slightly more enlightening briefing upon which to have a view?
It is all over the news, turn a TV on man.
I'd rather remain ignorant than be forced to watch TV hehe