Supermarket Brand Drugs

Supermarket Brand Drugs

Author
Discussion

cslgirl

Original Poster:

2,215 posts

227 months

Wednesday 16th June 2010
quotequote all
I have a stinking cold and when at the supermarket, instead of buying the Beechams Lemsip, I had a look at Tesco's lemsip at half the price and bought that. It doesn't seem to be helping at all (hence being awake now feeling like st). Do you "pays your money" with these things? Are supermarket brand cold drugs rubbish and should always pay for the leading brands? They seemed to have the same ingredients in them, but it has been a long while since I have felt this rough when taking cold remedies.

Dr John

555 posts

223 months

Wednesday 16th June 2010
quotequote all
cslgirl said:
I have a stinking cold and when at the supermarket, instead of buying the Beechams Lemsip, I had a look at Tesco's lemsip at half the price and bought that. It doesn't seem to be helping at all (hence being awake now feeling like st). Do you "pays your money" with these things? Are supermarket brand cold drugs rubbish and should always pay for the leading brands? They seemed to have the same ingredients in them, but it has been a long while since I have felt this rough when taking cold remedies.
Don't buy expensive rubbish.
Take paracetamol and (if you can tolerate it) ibuprofen, both at the maximum recommended doses. Ask the pharmacist if you need to know the dose. Don't buy branded medicine - it has no advantage.
If you need something soothing than a cup of fruit tea.

John

Edited by Dr John on Wednesday 16th June 14:20

illmonkey

18,598 posts

205 months

Thursday 17th June 2010
quotequote all
A fried working in a drug factory said the same batches would be packaged as the premium brands, they'd change the packaging and keep packing them into supermarket packets.

You can take paracetamol and ibuprofen along side each other. I was advised to take 2 paracetamol then 2 hours later 2 ibuprofen, repeat. But this is not official advise, ask a doctor wink

cslgirl

Original Poster:

2,215 posts

227 months

Thursday 17th June 2010
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies. I took the paracetamol/codeine route and it has worked wonders!

8Ace

2,758 posts

205 months

Thursday 17th June 2010
quotequote all
Echo the above.

Tesco 200mg Ibuprofen = about 40p for 16.

Nurofen 200mg Ibuprofen = 2.40 for 16.

Nurofen Migraine (containing 200mg Ibuprofen, but in a different coloutred box) = 2.80 for 12.

It's the same stuff. Buy the cheapest.




Six Fiend

6,067 posts

222 months

Thursday 17th June 2010
quotequote all
illmonkey said:
You can take paracetamol and ibuprofen along side each other. I was advised to take 2 paracetamol then 2 hours later 2 ibuprofen, repeat. But this is not official advise, ask a doctor wink
I do that to give constant cover/pain relief. Docs told me it was sensible way to do it.

Beardy10

23,742 posts

182 months

Thursday 17th June 2010
quotequote all
You can even do the Ibuprofen/Paracetemol double act on young children though obviously in the correct dosage and not regularly. We took our 1 yr old to hospital with a 40 deg temperature last year after the gobste GP had prescribed antibiotics to "fight the infection" and not prescribed anything to help with the temp. Consultant at A&E basically put our little boy on Ibuprofen and Paracetemol alternately and threw the anitbiotics in the bin (politely)....within three hours his temp was back to normal and he was a much happier little man.

parapaul

2,828 posts

205 months

Friday 18th June 2010
quotequote all
illmonkey said:
You can take paracetamol and ibuprofen along side each other. I was advised to take 2 paracetamol then 2 hours later 2 ibuprofen, repeat. But this is not official advise, ask a doctor wink
Every 3 hours... Not every 2 wink

Ibuprofen is usually listed as no more than 1200mg per day. If you're taking 2x200mg tablets at a time, that makes 3 doses per day, better 6 hours apart than 4 smile

vit4

3,507 posts

177 months

Friday 18th June 2010
quotequote all
Dr John said:
Don't buy expensive rubbish.
Take paracetamol and (if you can tolerate it) ibuprofen, both at the maximum recommended doses. Ask the pharmacist if you need to know the dose. Don't buy branded medicine - it has no advantage.
If you need something soothing than a cup of fruit tea.

John

Edited by Dr John on Wednesday 16th June 14:20
Have to agree with paracetemol/ibuprofen.

My concoction is usually a couple of the mildly impressive sounding "Tesco extra power pain relievers" (Paracetemol, aspirin and caffeine) and ibuprofen that kind of appears in the cupboard. Probably Tesco or Asda or sommin. 2 or 3 of each (at same time, not leaving any gap), and all is usually better. smile

Rollcage

11,327 posts

199 months

Friday 18th June 2010
quotequote all
Just look at the relevant active ingredients, and buy the cheapest possible. Dont be fooled into paying extra for caffeine either!

In my experience, cheapy 200mg Ibuprofen is no different to 200mg Nurofen! I don't really know how the big pharma companies get away with it.

illmonkey

18,598 posts

205 months

Friday 18th June 2010
quotequote all
parapaul said:
illmonkey said:
You can take paracetamol and ibuprofen along side each other. I was advised to take 2 paracetamol then 2 hours later 2 ibuprofen, repeat. But this is not official advise, ask a doctor wink
Every 3 hours... Not every 2 wink

Ibuprofen is usually listed as no more than 1200mg per day. If you're taking 2x200mg tablets at a time, that makes 3 doses per day, better 6 hours apart than 4 smile
I like to live life dangerously.

samdale

2,860 posts

191 months

Friday 18th June 2010
quotequote all
illmonkey said:
parapaul said:
illmonkey said:
You can take paracetamol and ibuprofen along side each other. I was advised to take 2 paracetamol then 2 hours later 2 ibuprofen, repeat. But this is not official advise, ask a doctor wink
Every 3 hours... Not every 2 wink

Ibuprofen is usually listed as no more than 1200mg per day. If you're taking 2x200mg tablets at a time, that makes 3 doses per day, better 6 hours apart than 4 smile
I like to live life dangerously.
i asked at the pharmacy in tescos about what i could do to help numb the pain of a torn trapezius as i was about to sit some long exams which really hurt my shoulder. they said (but not advised) that it is possible to take 600mg ibuprofen i one dose and just make sure you had plenty to eat. this method was obviously for a lot of relief for a short time (my exam) which i failed

Nicol@

3,850 posts

243 months

Friday 18th June 2010
quotequote all
Rollcage said:
In my experience, cheapy 200mg Ibuprofen is no different to 200mg Nurofen! I don't really know how the big pharma companies get away with it.
Someone has to pay for their advertising, so it gets pushed to the end user.

Rollcage

11,327 posts

199 months

Friday 18th June 2010
quotequote all
Nicol@ said:
Rollcage said:
In my experience, cheapy 200mg Ibuprofen is no different to 200mg Nurofen! I don't really know how the big pharma companies get away with it.
Someone has to pay for their advertising, so it gets pushed to the end user.
Obviously - I was thinking more of end user ignorance!

Amused2death

2,502 posts

203 months

Friday 18th June 2010
quotequote all
If you want to take "Lemsip" or similar then its a darn site easier to make your own. Lemon juice, honey, soluble aspirin and hot water.

IMHO just as effective, and for a tenth of the price.

grumbledoak

31,839 posts

240 months

Friday 18th June 2010
quotequote all
Rollcage said:
Just look at the relevant active ingredients, and buy the cheapest possible.
^^^ This. Generics are exactly the same and far, far cheaper (a packet of aspirin is 16p in my corner shop). You can normally find them on the same shelf as the branded stuff in the supermarket.

parapaul

2,828 posts

205 months

Tuesday 22nd June 2010
quotequote all
samdale said:
illmonkey said:
parapaul said:
illmonkey said:
You can take paracetamol and ibuprofen along side each other. I was advised to take 2 paracetamol then 2 hours later 2 ibuprofen, repeat. But this is not official advise, ask a doctor wink
Every 3 hours... Not every 2 wink

Ibuprofen is usually listed as no more than 1200mg per day. If you're taking 2x200mg tablets at a time, that makes 3 doses per day, better 6 hours apart than 4 smile
I like to live life dangerously.
i asked at the pharmacy in tescos about what i could do to help numb the pain of a torn trapezius as i was about to sit some long exams which really hurt my shoulder. they said (but not advised) that it is possible to take 600mg ibuprofen i one dose and just make sure you had plenty to eat. this method was obviously for a lot of relief for a short time (my exam) which i failed
They're not wrong... Prescribing guidelines allow for 800mg doses 3 times daily IIRC, but that's for the anti-inflammatory effect, not the analgesia smile

bull996

1,442 posts

216 months

Tuesday 22nd June 2010
quotequote all
Well, some are bit different.

For example, I think Lemsip have 500 whatsits of Paracetamol in a sachet and the supermarket brand "only" have 200, so there is the difference. However, its probably cheaper to have 2 supermarket sachets than 1 Lemsip.

5harp3y

1,960 posts

206 months

Tuesday 22nd June 2010
quotequote all
buy from the pharmacy section of boots / supermarkets.

can buy generic parcetemol and ibuprofen in bulk for a couple of quid

Munter

31,326 posts

248 months

Tuesday 22nd June 2010
quotequote all
One difference I have found. The own brand liquid ibuprofen that the OH got really really scratch on the way down! While the nurofen ones which look almost identical do not.

However once down there's no difference in the effect that I ever noticed.