Weighted vests for walking

Weighted vests for walking

Author
Discussion

Pflanzgarten

Original Poster:

4,663 posts

30 months

Saturday 5th August 2023
quotequote all
Currently doing around 7 miles (up to 9 on a good day/weekend) a day walking, bloody great for the dog!

However realistically fitting in 3 to 4 miles is much easier, especially as I get busier into autumn. Although I switch up with some weights I just love getting out and walking and it's so damn easy especially as my local walks have some good gradient in them and really keeps the weight off (lost a stone just doing this this summer for instance).

If I was to cut down the miles I thought about buying a weighted vest to keep up the cardio aspect. For less than £100 they seem like a no brainer-if they work!

Does anyone have any experiences with them? I can't imagine a backpack with a 10kg kettlebell in it would be as comfy but neither do I want to look like I'm wearing a bullet proof vest in Fallujah whilst hiking through the woods!

PositronicRay

27,344 posts

188 months

Saturday 5th August 2023
quotequote all
Some footwear makes walking harder.

How about some steel toe cap wellies?

Pflanzgarten

Original Poster:

4,663 posts

30 months

Saturday 5th August 2023
quotequote all
PositronicRay said:
Some footwear makes walking harder.

How about some steel toe cap wellies?
I actually do have steel toe cap'd and soled wellies for site work;
https://www.ace-safetywear.co.uk/boots--2/snugboot...

Brilliant things!

If it's been super wet and boggy I do actually use them on walks but I'm thinking more like adding 10kg

g3org3y

20,893 posts

196 months

Saturday 5th August 2023
quotequote all
Be interested to see the recommendations as it's something I've looked into as well.

Quite a few on Amazon, quite varied results. Seems to me the fit is key and whether you are going to be just using it for walking or other activities as well.

Pflanzgarten

Original Poster:

4,663 posts

30 months

Saturday 5th August 2023
quotequote all
g3org3y said:
Be interested to see the recommendations as it's something I've looked into as well.

Quite a few on Amazon, quite varied results. Seems to me the fit is key and whether you are going to be just using it for walking or other activities as well.
That's my main query, the army style ones look the most comfortable but also look maximum "Walt".

SmithCorona

712 posts

34 months

Saturday 5th August 2023
quotequote all
Nothing wrong with a good fitting backpack and a Kettlebell. I alternate between 16 and 24kg on my runs.

Wrap the kettlebell in fabric to prevent it digging. Bonus of the backpack is that you can carry water and wallet etc.

Alternately you could buy a ruck plate and a goruck backpack.

If you aren't used to going with weight you will fk up your legs and feet, so start slow.

Olivera

7,560 posts

244 months

Saturday 5th August 2023
quotequote all
SmithCorona said:
Nothing wrong with a good fitting backpack and a Kettlebell. I alternate between 16 and 24kg on my runs.

Wrap the kettlebell in fabric to prevent it digging. Bonus of the backpack is that you can carry water and wallet etc.
Doesn't running with a kettlebell look very 'special' ?

bigandclever

13,911 posts

243 months

Saturday 5th August 2023
quotequote all
As daft as they look, ankle weights can make a normal walk more strenuous than you'd think.

When I do my daft ultra training / time on feet training I use a regular running backpack with a 10kg plate in it and 2*2kg ankle weights from decathlon.

SmithCorona

712 posts

34 months

Saturday 5th August 2023
quotequote all
It's in a backpack. And I'm not concerned with how I look when keeping fit.

Good shout on ankle weights.

Bill

53,839 posts

260 months

Saturday 5th August 2023
quotequote all
100g on the feet is reckoned to be as tiring as 1kg in a pack.

Pflanzgarten

Original Poster:

4,663 posts

30 months

Saturday 5th August 2023
quotequote all
There is always conflicting advice but I have read that ankle weights really shouldn't be used for walking or running due to the different stresses and muscle groups you'll end up using.

For walking and running I think I'm right in saying this is specifically what weighed vests are designed for.

PiesAreGreat

163 posts

45 months

Saturday 5th August 2023
quotequote all
bigandclever said:
As daft as they look, ankle weights can make a normal walk more strenuous than you'd think.

When I do my daft ultra training / time on feet training I use a regular running backpack with a 10kg plate in it and 2*2kg ankle weights from decathlon.
I would second this, although I am quite allergic to anything but walking, one of my friends is one of the running, military types that enjoys exercise, and swears by the ankle weights.

Pflanzgarten

Original Poster:

4,663 posts

30 months

Saturday 5th August 2023
quotequote all
PiesAreGreat said:
bigandclever said:
As daft as they look, ankle weights can make a normal walk more strenuous than you'd think.

When I do my daft ultra training / time on feet training I use a regular running backpack with a 10kg plate in it and 2*2kg ankle weights from decathlon.
I would second this, although I am quite allergic to anything but walking, one of my friends is one of the running, military types that enjoys exercise, and swears by the ankle weights.
Just one of many quick Google’s…


https://www.health.harvard.edu/staying-healthy/wea...

I’m not saying your friend is wrong but there’s plenty more studies out there that don’t recommend ankle weights for walking or running.

DodgyGeezer

41,847 posts

195 months

Saturday 5th August 2023
quotequote all
surely the easiest would be a rucksack with a bag of sand/rock-salt in it. You get a few small bags you can vary the weights all without ruining your rucksack....

Pflanzgarten

Original Poster:

4,663 posts

30 months

Thursday 24th August 2023
quotequote all
Just an update on this, I bought a bargain second hand vest on eBay for £16 and some spare weights (again eBay were cheaper than Amazon) and have been using this for the last couple of weeks.

I can easily put on half a stone and it properly gets you sweating! No back pain or in my joints.

Obviously it's difficult to monitor these things when you're not a pro athlete but I 100% feel I'm getting a better workout for my time than just plugging away doing more miles.

No doubt you look a tt though!

bigandclever

13,911 posts

243 months

Thursday 24th August 2023
quotequote all
Pflanzgarten said:
No doubt you look a tt though!
Pop a t-shirt on over the top. Cover your shame smile


mikebradford

2,638 posts

150 months

Thursday 24th August 2023
quotequote all
With regard to ankle weights I understand the concerns over muscle imbalance, but its no different to being in the gym and concentrating more on on exercise than the other.

Pflanzgarten

Original Poster:

4,663 posts

30 months

Thursday 24th August 2023
quotequote all
mikebradford said:
With regard to ankle weights I understand the concerns over muscle imbalance, but its no different to being in the gym and concentrating more on on exercise than the other.
My understanding is it isn’t, it’s more that you re-train your body to walk using the wrong muscles which leads to problems.

Edited by Pflanzgarten on Friday 25th August 09:15

simon_harris

1,632 posts

39 months

Friday 25th August 2023
quotequote all
Surely the answer here was a proper chain mail shirt?

KobayashiMaru86

1,280 posts

215 months

Friday 25th August 2023
quotequote all
I use a 10kg vest I bought in Argos. Helped me a lot to start dropping weight just by walking. I can't run in it as it bounces on my shoulders too much. But walk 10-15 miles and you really feel it. The extra weight will make shoes wear a bit quicker and build up to it if it's a lot more weight than you've been to avoid tendonitis in your feet as get this on and off since I've been exercising.