dog help

Author
Discussion

parapaul

2,828 posts

201 months

Sunday 5th April 2009
quotequote all
My GSD does the same - but she'll only do it when she's wearing her Halti harness. I thought she was just trying to get the harness off because she won't roll in crap at all if she's not wearing it.

Bloody stinks though! biggrin

Lefty Guns

16,289 posts

205 months

Sunday 5th April 2009
quotequote all
MartinQ said:
You're lucky. My dog not only rolls around in st, but also eats it. She's quite fond of our cat's deposits.
Yeah I had to "discipline" my dog out of that habit. fking disgusting.

johnnywgk

Original Poster:

2,579 posts

185 months

Sunday 5th April 2009
quotequote all
lefty guns,

what did you do to stop it,

think i might have her put down,



















and sell her for horse food.

Scraggles

7,619 posts

227 months

Sunday 5th April 2009
quotequote all
carry a belt and lash the dog a few times when it rolls in poo, must be so much fun in the car on the way home nsmile

Lefty Guns

16,289 posts

205 months

Sunday 5th April 2009
quotequote all
She started doing it from a very young age so every time she did it she got told off and a whack with a newspaper or suchlike.

Doesn't do it anymore...

I must admit, I'm old-school (which some would class as cruel) when it comes to dog training. She gets lots of love, attention, cuddles, encouragment when she's good and gets punished when she's bad.

johnnywgk

Original Poster:

2,579 posts

185 months

Sunday 5th April 2009
quotequote all
nice one.
cheers for all your ideas

parapaul

2,828 posts

201 months

Sunday 5th April 2009
quotequote all
Lefty Guns said:
She started doing it from a very young age so every time she did it she got told off and a whack with a newspaper or suchlike.

Doesn't do it anymore...

I must admit, I'm old-school (which some would class as cruel) when it comes to dog training. She gets lots of love, attention, cuddles, encouragment when she's good and gets punished when she's bad.
Punish? Punish a cutie-wutie doggy-woggy? Cripes, the lentilists will be beating down your door...

My GSD knows to run and hide if she's chewed anything while we're out wink

Simond001

4,519 posts

280 months

Sunday 5th April 2009
quotequote all
My dog hates being washed.

She still rolls at every fresh opportunity, even though it means a thorough wash with mint and tea tree shower gell (best for getting rid of the smell).

Fresh fox poo is like au de horny to dogs.

Mr POD

5,153 posts

195 months

Sunday 5th April 2009
quotequote all
johnnywgk said:
usual funnies welcome, but serious replies, more welcome

Why does my dog (female) roll in horse/fox poo

it's driving me mad

ETA. just tried to make above a bit more readable

Edited by johnnywgk on Saturday 4th April 21:17
Because you let her off the lead ?

johnnywgk

Original Poster:

2,579 posts

185 months

Monday 6th April 2009
quotequote all
mrpod, i like to let her run free, just wish she did'nt have a thing
for other animals crap

becksW

14,682 posts

214 months

Monday 6th April 2009
quotequote all
johnnywgk said:
mrpod, i like to let her run free, just wish she did'nt have a thing
for other animals crap
Whacking with a newspaper may work but more likely to end up with a dog who'll run away, become fearful etc, verbal should work most of the time if you watch them carefully. Does your dog stop doing something when you say no. This is the most basic command your dog should respond to, first of all be watchful of what your dog is doing, don't allow her to wander too far away, as soon as she appears to show an interest in a patch of ground distract her with treats, play etc. If she does look like she is going to go in for the roll very very firmly say her name and follow with a definite no. Hopefully the sudden unexpected command will stop her in her tracks but then immediately say her name and no again and distract with treats. It will take a few attempts and won't work 100% of the time, but trying to run over to her to whack her with a paper is going to either make it into a chase game or make her fearful. Plus you will get some people not taking too kindly to seeing a dog being hit by a paper.

Jasandjules

70,095 posts

232 months

Monday 6th April 2009
quotequote all
One of the things I do (though it hasn't worked completely) is that she is told off when she starts to roll, and if she doesn't stop, she is put back on the lead for the rest of the walk.

It pretty much worked, 95% of the time she doesn't roll in poo anymore, BUT now and again she just can't help herself..... She hasn't worked out that when she gets home she gets a bath as a result (Which she hates!).

XJSJohn

15,993 posts

222 months

Monday 6th April 2009
quotequote all
Timmy35 said:
johnnywgk said:
was expecting a lot more funnies than that.

how can i stop her
Bum her every time she does it.
I see that travelling has not improved your humour there Tim wink

You still lurking in countries with no UK Extradition treaties?


Lefty Guns

16,289 posts

205 months

Monday 6th April 2009
quotequote all
becksW said:
johnnywgk said:
mrpod, i like to let her run free, just wish she did'nt have a thing
for other animals crap
Whacking with a newspaper may work but more likely to end up with a dog who'll run away, become fearful etc, verbal should work most of the time if you watch them carefully. Does your dog stop doing something when you say no. This is the most basic command your dog should respond to, first of all be watchful of what your dog is doing, don't allow her to wander too far away, as soon as she appears to show an interest in a patch of ground distract her with treats, play etc. If she does look like she is going to go in for the roll very very firmly say her name and follow with a definite no. Hopefully the sudden unexpected command will stop her in her tracks but then immediately say her name and no again and distract with treats. It will take a few attempts and won't work 100% of the time, but trying to run over to her to whack her with a paper is going to either make it into a chase game or make her fearful. Plus you will get some people not taking too kindly to seeing a dog being hit by a paper.
From a young age, my dog has known that if she's naughty she gets a whack and if she's good she gets praise. It has worked very well for me and my dog is obedient and loving. She doesn't run away, she always comes to me when I whistle her, she sits when I tell her to sit, stops when I tell her to stop, stays when I tell her to stay, lies down, gives me her paw, etc etc when she's told to.

Can I be clear: It's not like i beat her repeatedly with 3x Sunday times rolled around a bit of iron bar, she gets a light slap with a newspaper and a telling off (just her name in a grumpy tone) to remind her that she's been bad. She'll do her sad face for a few seconds (or minutes) until she gets a kind word, pat on the head or whaetever to let her know she's not in trouble in more. The time between whack and forgiveness depends on the severity of her crime!

becksW

14,682 posts

214 months

Monday 6th April 2009
quotequote all
Lefty Guns said:
becksW said:
johnnywgk said:
mrpod, i like to let her run free, just wish she did'nt have a thing
for other animals crap
Whacking with a newspaper may work but more likely to end up with a dog who'll run away, become fearful etc, verbal should work most of the time if you watch them carefully. Does your dog stop doing something when you say no. This is the most basic command your dog should respond to, first of all be watchful of what your dog is doing, don't allow her to wander too far away, as soon as she appears to show an interest in a patch of ground distract her with treats, play etc. If she does look like she is going to go in for the roll very very firmly say her name and follow with a definite no. Hopefully the sudden unexpected command will stop her in her tracks but then immediately say her name and no again and distract with treats. It will take a few attempts and won't work 100% of the time, but trying to run over to her to whack her with a paper is going to either make it into a chase game or make her fearful. Plus you will get some people not taking too kindly to seeing a dog being hit by a paper.
From a young age, my dog has known that if she's naughty she gets a whack and if she's good she gets praise. It has worked very well for me and my dog is obedient and loving. She doesn't run away, she always comes to me when I whistle her, she sits when I tell her to sit, stops when I tell her to stop, stays when I tell her to stay, lies down, gives me her paw, etc etc when she's told to.

Can I be clear: It's not like i beat her repeatedly with 3x Sunday times rolled around a bit of iron bar, she gets a light slap with a newspaper and a telling off (just her name in a grumpy tone) to remind her that she's been bad. She'll do her sad face for a few seconds (or minutes) until she gets a kind word, pat on the head or whaetever to let her know she's not in trouble in more. The time between whack and forgiveness depends on the severity of her crime!
I'm not saying it doesn't work for you and your dog however I can't agree with the approach because most people will use it incorrectly and it is far more likely to cause a dog to turn to fear aggression. There are other and better ways (in my opinion) to deal with inappropriate behaviour of this kind. We will have to agree to disagree with the approach on this occasion. (I am also aware that for a very very small number of dogs physical punishmnent will be needed but I really don't think it is needed for this situation)

Can I also add that I don't think anyone here was accusing you of beating your dog repeatedly let alone with an iron bar!

davemac250

4,499 posts

208 months

Monday 6th April 2009
quotequote all
Try a water squirt collar.

Some places are now letting you hire them for a month at a time.

Works a treat at correcting unwanted behaviour.


megamaniac

1,060 posts

219 months

Monday 6th April 2009
quotequote all
Try making a loud enough noise and call her to distract her from what she's doing,a whistle or airhorn should do the trick.As for the st eating our two think rabbit purlies are caviar and the fresher the better.We haven't managed to stop that.

RobCrezz

7,892 posts

211 months

Monday 6th April 2009
quotequote all
You need Ceasar Milan!

Mr POD

5,153 posts

195 months

Monday 6th April 2009
quotequote all
RobCrezz said:
You need Ceasar Milan!
Barbara Woodhouse did a few books. Most libary's will have a shelf devoted to her work.