Maldives - small island

Author
Discussion

Trikster

Original Poster:

860 posts

211 months

Saturday 21st December 2024
quotequote all
Ok, it's not even Christmas 2024 and we're planning 2025's

Having been to the Maldives a couple of times, once in 2004, and once 3 years ago we're looking to go again.

Both times previously we've been to islands that have comparatively few villas (<40) and are looking for something similar again (the place we went to in 2004 has changed it's name and has been completely redeveloped with loads of over water bungalows), and more recently Kandolhu, which we'd be more than happy to go to again if we can't find an alternate.

Wondering if any recommendations from the PH crowd as trying to 'filter' by number of villas/size of island for our search is proving a challenge...


nordboy

2,070 posts

59 months

Saturday 21st December 2024
quotequote all
Went to Komandoo in 2019, I think it's been sold to another company since, but it was absolutely spectacular. The most relaxing 10 days I've ever spent anywhere. great house reef. Adults only and only about 40 villas. We booked a water villa but swapped to a beach one half way through.
I didn't like the travel time though, but that's just me.

interstellar

4,019 posts

155 months

Saturday 21st December 2024
quotequote all
I am not sure of the size of you & me Maldives (think it’s bigger villa wise) but it’s a small island. We have been twice and it’s adults only and very quiet, great service and it’s a lovely place.

Sheetmaself

5,803 posts

207 months

Saturday 21st December 2024
quotequote all
Another vote for Komandoo.

You can walk the whole island in about 15-20 mins and you can swim from the water bungalows to the bar!

Welcome to
Komandoo
Hope you have a nice
Holiday

Bring back memories?

GiantEnemyCrab

7,749 posts

212 months

Saturday 21st December 2024
quotequote all
Just over from Komandoo https://www.hurawalhi.com/

JQ

6,153 posts

188 months

Saturday 21st December 2024
quotequote all
Another vote for Komandoo, we had an absolutely amazing time there.

Guyr

2,366 posts

291 months

Saturday 21st December 2024
quotequote all
Baros?

Went there 30 years ago and it still wins awards every year.

nordboy

2,070 posts

59 months

Saturday 21st December 2024
quotequote all
Sheetmaself said:
Another vote for Komandoo.

You can walk the whole island in about 15-20 mins and you can swim from the water bungalows to the bar!

Welcome to
Komandoo
Hope you have a nice
Holiday

Bring back memories?
Lol, yes. Glad they weren't employed as full time musicians.

GeneralBanter

1,120 posts

24 months

Saturday 21st December 2024
quotequote all
We’re looking at the Maldives for 2025, my reservations are that it’s I’m told it’s full of Russians (is it?) and once there it’s going to be eye wateringly expensive- the island transfers alone are over a grand!

interstellar

4,019 posts

155 months

Saturday 21st December 2024
quotequote all
Lots of assumptions that are mostly dependent on when and where you go.

We had a handful of Russians the last time we went but they weren’t any different to anyone else.

Transfers depend where you go , pick an island closer to Male and you can get a cheaper speedboat or just budget for that as part of your hols.

Some resorts do free transfers May to November so look on travelbag as a good place to start.

Best advice is go half board and if you have two- three drinks a day your bar bill will be about £400 at the end of 10 days.

It’s 10 dollars a beer or cocktail really. It’s a lot cheaper to go half board and have a decent breakfast than full board or AI, a lot cheaper!!

Edited by interstellar on Saturday 21st December 20:15

ffc

692 posts

168 months

Saturday 21st December 2024
quotequote all
We went to Vilamendhoo last month. It was fabulous, very good snorkelling and a mixture of nationalities including Russians. Not many Brits.

ffc

692 posts

168 months

Saturday 21st December 2024
quotequote all
We went to Vilamendhoo last month. It was fabulous, very good snorkelling and a mixture of nationalities including Russians. Not many Brits.

redrabbit29

1,995 posts

142 months

Monday 6th January
quotequote all
Having been at other destinations with Americans and Russians, I'd be more keen to avoid the Americans to be honest.

The russians I've encountered have either been very pleasant, or outright rude. But not loud.

So many Americans I've been near, particularly in Cancun, were loud, brash, arrogant, rude and hard to ignore.

(Stumbled on this thread as I'm trying to decide on where to go in march and April)

r1ch

2,922 posts

205 months

Monday 6th January
quotequote all
I must admit when I went it was mostly Germans on our islands. I’d agree with the poster above about going half board. I’d imagine most islands include the transfer when you book the holiday, our boat transfers were free but islands were 30-45 mins from Male.

GeneralBanter

1,120 posts

24 months

Monday 6th January
quotequote all
I’m ditching the Maldives after thinking further, having been to Jamaica in the meantime. We aren’t keen on the man made paradise with no history aspect or being at the behest of an economy where nearly everything is non native and has to be imported. So now looking elsewhere where there’s a bit more depth to the whole experience.

jhiker

116 posts

119 months

Monday 6th January
quotequote all
Have you considered Sri Lanka?

DT1975

704 posts

37 months

Monday 6th January
quotequote all
GeneralBanter said:
I’m ditching the Maldives after thinking further, having been to Jamaica in the meantime. We aren’t keen on the man made paradise with no history aspect or being at the behest of an economy where nearly everything is non native and has to be imported. So now looking elsewhere where there’s a bit more depth to the whole experience.
It's certainly paradise, there is a history there as well as for man made, struggling with that as most islands are natural but I get the import thing. Each to their own but its the only place I've visited that's blown me away in relation to Isolation, beauty, beaches, clarity of seawater and abundance of sea life on your doorstep. There's nothing remotely comparable in the Caribbean in that respect, you won't get near it.

That said its not for everyone, whereas I spend hours snorkelling house reefs meters from the beach with sharks, rays and every fish imaginable some people don't even stick their heads in the water.

We mix and match, we do Antigua, St Lucia most years with friends (easier flights) and also the Maldives but price wise there isn't much difference. We enjoy them for different reasons, personally I prefer the Maldives for the reasons I've given.

One thing of note for anyone who Vapes -its been banned in the Maldives from December.

nordboy

2,070 posts

59 months

Monday 6th January
quotequote all
DT1975 said:
GeneralBanter said:
I’m ditching the Maldives after thinking further, having been to Jamaica in the meantime. We aren’t keen on the man made paradise with no history aspect or being at the behest of an economy where nearly everything is non native and has to be imported. So now looking elsewhere where there’s a bit more depth to the whole experience.
It's certainly paradise, there is a history there as well as for man made, struggling with that as most islands are natural but I get the import thing. Each to their own but its the only place I've visited that's blown me away in relation to Isolation, beauty, beaches, clarity of seawater and abundance of sea life on your doorstep. There's nothing remotely comparable in the Caribbean in that respect, you won't get near it.

That said its not for everyone, whereas I spend hours snorkelling house reefs meters from the beach with sharks, rays and every fish imaginable some people don't even stick their heads in the water.

We mix and match, we do Antigua, St Lucia most years with friends (easier flights) and also the Maldives but price wise there isn't much difference. We enjoy them for different reasons, personally I prefer the Maldives for the reasons I've given.

One thing of note for anyone who Vapes -its been banned in the Maldives from December.
The same for me, hours snorkelling on the reef, or a bit of scuba. The 10 days I sent on Komandoo I think was the most relaxed I've ever felt when away? And it literally felt like i was in the middle of nowhere and so far away from work and hassle. It was fantastic. But saying that, i didn't much care for the travelling to get there and back.

interstellar

4,019 posts

155 months

Monday 6th January
quotequote all
I’m a big fan, only been twice but are going this December again.

Like the previous poster I felt the most relaxed and away from everything I have ever felt.

So relaxed, for me it was pure paradise.

I have found nothing close to it.

K50 DEL

9,421 posts

237 months

Monday 6th January
quotequote all
nordboy said:
The same for me, hours snorkelling on the reef, or a bit of scuba. The 10 days I sent on Komandoo I think was the most relaxed I've ever felt when away? And it literally felt like i was in the middle of nowhere and so far away from work and hassle. It was fantastic. But saying that, i didn't much care for the travelling to get there and back.
Back in 2013 I paid for my Sister's honeymoon to the Constance Moofooshi specifically for that reason...

The marriage is a speck in the rear-view now but she still talks about the snorkelling, diving and general aquatic life in the Maldives.