New York for 4 nights where is good value for money?

New York for 4 nights where is good value for money?

Author
Discussion

magpies

Original Poster:

5,142 posts

188 months

Sunday 7th January
quotequote all
Going just after Easter and need 2 bedrooms (my wife and I and our grown up son)
Don't mind hotel or air bnb but need close by amenities (restaurants) and subway (for Manhattan)

shtu

3,640 posts

152 months

Sunday 7th January
quotequote all
magpies said:
air bnb
Be wary of trying to use airbnb or anyone offering short term rentals via facebook, etc., the city council is having a crackdown.

https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2023/oct/23/ne...

z4RRSchris

11,467 posts

185 months

Monday 8th January
quotequote all
also new york and value for money, even more so with the exchange rate, isn't really a thing.

its horrendously expensive.

QuartzDad

2,338 posts

128 months

Monday 8th January
quotequote all
When we did a similar trip ten years ago we stayed in a 2 bedroom suite here http://www.countyinnandsuites.nyc/ Was 2 mins from the subway, simple to get to all the tourist spots and much cheaper than staying in Manhattan.

CivicDuties

5,774 posts

36 months

Monday 8th January
quotequote all
I stayed here this summer for a week, it was jolly reasonably priced given its location:

https://www.sonder.com/destinations/new_york_city/...

Recommended. Easy to get the subway, and also the public ferries which operate all around the city. I ended up using the ferries far more than the subway. Plenty of places to eat and shop around there too.

We are a family of 4, and had a two bedroom/two bathroom apartment. Worked very well for us.

GCH

4,042 posts

208 months

Monday 8th January
quotequote all
Hotels are really insane money here right now, so wherever is cheapest and suitable for you in Manhattan, anywhere below 110th st (which is the north side of central park).

Not above that, and if above 14th st not too far east or west (as it is a subway dead zone by the hudson or east river ).
Not the bronx. Would strongly suggest not queens (possibly an exception for long island city, although it's dead and soulless), definitely not staten island (lol) and if you want to experience brooklyn, then only dumbo/brooklyn heights/park slope/carroll gardens/cobble hill/williamsburg (not east williamsburg, not south williamsburg) should be on your radar. NJ you could do hoboken, but the PATH train is a pain, and all sorts of silliness with the routing at the weekend.

Consider a suite, given you need two beds (the couch will turn into the second bed) and it may be better value for you than two rooms.

Beware the hefty ridiculous city, state, occupancy taxes, and then horrible 'resort fees' which are nothing but a cash grab.
Be careful with airbnb....there are a lot going on still, without issue, but it is technically now illegal in the city for stays below 30 days without the owner being present.


x5tuu

12,095 posts

193 months

Monday 8th January
quotequote all
Corner suite at the Doubletree Jersey City may fit the bill and PATH isn’t too much hassle (not much more than getting a subway normally anyways) but will also depend where you’re flying in/out of too.

I’d also suggest you lose the VFM mindset, it won’t be. I go every year and just got back a couple of days ago and prices were definitely the highest they’ve ever been in the past 20yrs and rates remain poor.

Personally I would always choose the Conrad Downtown (and have done for the past 6+years), it’s all suite so there is a separate lounge with sofa bed etc. and is very pleasant.

magpies

Original Poster:

5,142 posts

188 months

Tuesday 9th January
quotequote all
Thank you for your suggestions - we have booked a 2 bed appt not far from the Empire State Bld for less than £1800. Has good reviews.

x5tuu

12,095 posts

193 months

Tuesday 9th January
quotequote all
magpies said:
Thank you for your suggestions - we have booked a 2 bed appt not far from the Empire State Bld for less than £1800. Has good reviews.
£450/n for a 2bd apt mid-town is exceptional! well done!

Bearings

61 posts

148 months

Wednesday 10th January
quotequote all
magpies said:
Thank you for your suggestions - we have booked a 2 bed appt not far from the Empire State Bld for less than £1800. Has good reviews.
Mind sharing some location details on this? Looking to go to NYC in Aug this year so scouting all possible options at the moment!

magpies

Original Poster:

5,142 posts

188 months

Wednesday 10th January
quotequote all
Bearings said:
Mind sharing some location details on this? Looking to go to NYC in Aug this year so scouting all possible options at the moment!
I'll let you know if any good after we have been. All looks good on the web site.

soxboy

6,513 posts

225 months

Wednesday 10th January
quotequote all
magpies said:
Bearings said:
Mind sharing some location details on this? Looking to go to NYC in Aug this year so scouting all possible options at the moment!
I'll let you know if any good after we have been. All looks good on the web site.
Seconded for a link/ review once you’ve been. We are looking at going in October.

MrBig

3,054 posts

135 months

Friday 12th January
quotequote all
I see that the OP is sorted, but for future reference I would happily recommend the ArLo Nomad https://arlohotels.com/nomad/

Walking distance to Times Square through Korea Town (get yourself a Korean Bouncy Purple Yam Cheesecake!!) we had a great view of the Empire State Building and the service was faultless. Relatively cheap too. They also have locations in Soho and Midtown IIRC too.

magpies

Original Poster:

5,142 posts

188 months

Friday 12th January
quotequote all
MrBig said:
I see that the OP is sorted, but for future reference I would happily recommend the ArLo Nomad https://arlohotels.com/nomad/

Walking distance to Times Square through Korea Town (get yourself a Korean Bouncy Purple Yam Cheesecake!!) we had a great view of the Empire State Building and the service was faultless. Relatively cheap too. They also have locations in Soho and Midtown IIRC too.
This is where we have booked: Address: 38 west 31st street, NoMad, New York, NY 10001

GCH

4,042 posts

208 months

Friday 12th January
quotequote all
magpies said:
This is where we have booked: Address: 38 west 31st street, NoMad, New York, NY 10001
Large doorman residential building. You'll be ok around there, and it's walkable. It may feel a little sketchy at night in the vicinity there right now with the current state of things, but you'll be alright.
Check out Bear Donut (www.beardonut.com) literally next to the entrance of the building - they are exceptional (and now I want to call by there for some, goddammit)

Edited by GCH on Friday 12th January 19:41

magpies

Original Poster:

5,142 posts

188 months

Friday 12th January
quotequote all
GCH said:
Large doorman residential building. You'll be ok around there, and it's walkable. It may feel a little sketchy at night in the vicinity there right now with the current state of things, but you'll be alright.
Check out Bear Donut (www.beardonut.com) literally next to the entrance of the building - they are exceptional (and now I want to call by there for some, goddammit)

Edited by GCH on Friday 12th January 19:41
Looking for a breakfast place and I've been told to go to Dillons for my Premier League footy match (the NUFC fans meet there) we also love NFL (although the season will have finished) and don't mind baseball (will be going to Fenway Park while in Boston) Would have loved to go to a NASCAR race but could not sort out (been to Dover and Concord previously).

GCH

4,042 posts

208 months

Saturday 13th January
quotequote all
magpies said:
Looking for a breakfast place
No shortage of choice in that hood. Ess-a-bagel and black seed bagel (which are wood fired) are a couple of mins walk away and some of the best in the city. There is a Le Pain Quotidien a couple of blocks away, you also have The Grey Dog on 26th/6th which does all day breakfast. The Harold is very close, and there are a couple of diners in the vicinity too.

vladcjelli

3,038 posts

164 months

Saturday 13th January
quotequote all
magpies said:
Looking for a breakfast place and I've been told to go to Dillons for my Premier League footy match (the NUFC fans meet there) we also love NFL (although the season will have finished) and don't mind baseball (will be going to Fenway Park while in Boston) Would have loved to go to a NASCAR race but could not sort out (been to Dover and Concord previously).
We popped to https://www.legends33.com/ to watch premier league when we were there in 2022. Screens all over, lots of supporters in replica shirts and some of the best loaded tater tots we’ve ever had.

MarkJS

1,700 posts

153 months

Sunday 14th January
quotequote all
magpies said:
Looking for a breakfast place and I've been told to go to Dillons for my Premier League footy match (the NUFC fans meet there) we also love NFL (although the season will have finished) and don't mind baseball (will be going to Fenway Park while in Boston) Would have loved to go to a NASCAR race but could not sort out (been to Dover and Concord previously).
You’ll have a great breakfast surrounded by locals at the Skylight Diner which is pretty close to where you’re staying. Can’t imagine they’d have the football on though.

alfabeat

1,183 posts

118 months

Tuesday 16th January
quotequote all
I'm looking to book a surprise trip for my wife and I for November to NYC (her 50th). So following this with interest.