which is the best Doggie Insurance company?

which is the best Doggie Insurance company?

Author
Discussion

Shuvi Tupya

Original Poster:

24,460 posts

254 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
My second dog thread in as many weeks!

I am in the process of adopting a freinds doggie as she can have a much better life with me than her current arrangements allow for.

She is a 10yr old Labradoodle (i think)


Petplan are quoting £27 a month with various excesses, i just thought i would throw it out there to the more knowledgeable doggie owners before i sign on the dotted line?

Are they are any good or should i be looking elsewhere ?

Ta thumbup




condor

8,837 posts

255 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
I'd suggest at 10 years old that you're just giving her/him a comfortable retirement. I wouldn't go for pet insurance at that age, simply because of the age and the exclusions/excesses. Just plan to give her/him the best remaining days that they have left.

tonym911

17,386 posts

212 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
Nice doggie! We did a lot of research on this last year for our spoodle Boots and John Lewis (was Greenbee back then) came out as the best mix of value and 'good name' reliability. Was not impressed by the hardsell (and not good value) approach of Petplan and a couple of others whose names I can't remember.

tonym911

17,386 posts

212 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
condor said:
I'd suggest at 10 years old that you're just giving her/him a comfortable retirement. I wouldn't go for pet insurance at that age, simply because of the age and the exclusions/excesses. Just plan to give her/him the best remaining days that they have left.
That seems a bit pessimistic? I would have thought insurance would play a major part in giving an older dog a good life, otherwise you run the risk of making your own life a bit pants when you have to start shelling out for medical attention. Unless your plan is to put the dog to sleep as soon as they develop an illness or have a problem? Not criticising, just wondering.

mchammer89

3,127 posts

220 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all

spikeyhead

17,974 posts

204 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
tonym911 said:
condor said:
I'd suggest at 10 years old that you're just giving her/him a comfortable retirement. I wouldn't go for pet insurance at that age, simply because of the age and the exclusions/excesses. Just plan to give her/him the best remaining days that they have left.
That seems a bit pessimistic? I would have thought insurance would play a major part in giving an older dog a good life, otherwise you run the risk of making your own life a bit pants when you have to start shelling out for medical attention. Unless your plan is to put the dog to sleep as soon as they develop an illness or have a problem? Not criticising, just wondering.
Never insure any risk you can afford to carry yourself.
Never fail to insure any risk you can't afford to carry.

I know not where other peoples capabilities to carry risks lie, so long as they've done the sums themselves, but we're all different and will have differing needs and risk aversions.

condor

8,837 posts

255 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
tonym911 said:
condor said:
I'd suggest at 10 years old that you're just giving her/him a comfortable retirement. I wouldn't go for pet insurance at that age, simply because of the age and the exclusions/excesses. Just plan to give her/him the best remaining days that they have left.
That seems a bit pessimistic? I would have thought insurance would play a major part in giving an older dog a good life, otherwise you run the risk of making your own life a bit pants when you have to start shelling out for medical attention. Unless your plan is to put the dog to sleep as soon as they develop an illness or have a problem? Not criticising, just wondering.
Not really - dogs age is x7 as compared to ours...so the dog is already 70 years old in human terms. Insurance cover usually negates any pre existing conditions...so nearly everything that happens will not be covered - please some insurance bod post and tell me I'm wrong.
Then you will have large excesses to cover any small thing that hasn't been excluded - in effect, for an old dog paying out insurance premiums is a waste of money as the premiums are very high anyway and little is covered.
What I meant to say, was give the dog the best days left of his lifetime - but at the equivalent of 70 of our years he's not going to go on for ever, so don't subject him/her to treatment that may prolong life and cause pain for a few months but doesn't give quality of life.


tonym911

17,386 posts

212 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
Fair comment. Suspect emotion gets the better of most dog owners though, and you can sort of understand that.

condor

8,837 posts

255 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
tonym911 said:
But in the context of unexpected dog operations which could easily sting you several grand I'm reckoning even fifty notes a year for a decent policy is a decent investment.
Yes, that would be good cover. The OP will be paying £27 a month or roughly £325 a year for an elderly dog.

Shuvi Tupya

Original Poster:

24,460 posts

254 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
Thanks for the comments so far.

The dog doesn't have a bad medical history so i am hoping any conditions that come up are new ones.

John lewis eh? Will look into it!




Piglet

6,250 posts

262 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
Our vet bills for the last 12 months were in excess of £6k of which only £4k was insured. Vet treatment can be stonkingly expensive if, as in our dogs case they develop something that is tricky to diagnose.

Our Springer Spaniel was just over a year old when she developed an Auto Immune condition which led to joint taps, scans, xrays, and in stays at the Uni vet hospital and other treatment. So in my view age isn't a deciding factor to insurance.

Only you can decide whether to insure or not but some things to understand are....the relevance of "whole of life" cover - this means that if your dog develops a condition - say epilepsy, diabetes or an auto immune condition the insurers will continue to cover that condition year on year. Without whole of life cover they will pay for it once and will then exclude it from the policy.

We had Pet Plan Whole life budget cover, PP have been fantastic and paid up to the limit with no quibble and we have covered the rest. They have renewed the policy this year without a huge increase in premium

I wish we'd taken a higher limit - I thought £4k's worth of treatment was a huge amount and I now know that it's not. We couldn't have signed an open ended cheque for the investigations and her treatment when she was so very ill and would have been left with only one option and given that our now pretty healthy two and a bit year old dog is currently snoring on my lap is a pretty awful thought.

If you know the dog's history you'll need to disclose it and any pre-existing conditions will be excluded - this might make a difference to your decision.

Personally I'd insure.

c8bof

368 posts

172 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
Another recommendation for John Lewis (Green Bee) here thumbup

tonym911

17,386 posts

212 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
condor said:
tonym911 said:
But in the context of unexpected dog operations which could easily sting you several grand I'm reckoning even fifty notes a year for a decent policy is a decent investment.
Yes, that would be good cover. The OP will be paying £27 a month or roughly £325 a year for an elderly dog.
Many apologies, I read it as £27 a year… paperbag

tonym911

17,386 posts

212 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
tonym911 said:
condor said:
tonym911 said:
But in the context of unexpected dog operations which could easily sting you several grand I'm reckoning even fifty notes a year for a decent policy is a decent investment.
Yes, that would be good cover. The OP will be paying £27 a month or roughly £325 a year for an elderly dog.
Many apologies, I read it as £27 a year… paperbag
Still, in the context of Piglet's post, even £325 pa suddenly seems 'cheap'.

Jasandjules

70,502 posts

236 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
Halifax are pretty good..... Not as good as they used to be (now they have the "standard" 20% as well IIRC) but they do the special food etc....

mrmaggit

10,146 posts

255 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
You do know there is an "All creatures great and small" forum these days, don't you?

Snails

915 posts

173 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
I used work in customer services for several pet insurance companies up until 2 years ago. You have a few options when it comes to pet insurance.


I don't know how much you know, so i will cover as much as possible.

As stated pre-existing conditions are not covered. You may also find conditions that are related to pre-existing conitions are also not covered.

Some insurance provider offer different levels of cover, so be sure as to which level of cover they are quoting you for.

There are several different types of policy,:

1 year cover: These polices will cover conditions for a maximum of 12 months, up to a certain limit e.g £2000. So for example if you dog develops a skin condition they will cover the costs of that conditon for the first 12 months or up until the cover limit has been reached, whichever is comes first. After whcih cover for that condition will finish.

Continuous per condition cover: These polices will cover each new condition that arises and will cover each conidtion year after year until the limit for that condition is reached (eg £7500 per condition). The benefit of these policies is that they will conditions year after year providing the limit for that condition has not been reached. They also put no limit on the number of conditions that can be claimed for. Your dog could have 5 different conditons and each would be covered year after year, until the maximum for each condition. The limit doesn't reset each year, so if £1000 is paid out in year 1, there will be £6500 remaining for that condition if your renew. These polices do tend to be slightly more expensive due to the higher level of cover provided.

Continuous cover but with a maximum per year: These policy also provide continuous cover for conidtions, but limit the total that can be claimed in any one year for example £6000. These policies will payout year after year for ongoing conditions, providing they are not pre-existing, but limit the total that will be paid in any one year. The limitation of these policies is that if your dog develops several expensive conditions that it is easy to use up the limit for year. However, you know that you will always have some cover for condition providing you keep renewing.

There are some policies are unlimited in the amount that can be claimed year after year. These tend to be the most expensive.

Nearly all policies include public liability cover should your animal be the cause of a claim against you.

Some polices cover the cost of things like hydrotherapy to assist with injuries such as broken legs.

You may find that because your dog is older it now faces a higher excess. Some polices may ask for as much as 20% of the cost of the treatment. Make sure you are clear of the excesses. 20% of a £10000 vet bill is a lot of money!

The premium is based on your postcode (London vets charge more than vets in Aberdeenshire), the dog's breed (crossbreeds are usually cheapest) the dog's age, and the dog's sex (females are cheaper)


There is loads I've missed off, but as always have a read of the policy booklet, they are usually available online.

Also most if not all offer a discount for buying online online.




If it were me and my dog I'd go with a policy that gives you a set amount per year and covers year on year.

Edited by Snails on Tuesday 28th December 17:03

todd69

240 posts

221 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
Pet Plan, we were with them (well the dog was) for 18yrs and whilst we never claimed for the first 9 we used it constantly for the following 9 years, really was fantastic and never had an issue with a payout.

This time round we went to Argos, read a lot of reviews and they came out well and their top insurance (fully covered for life, not just the year) was £14.99, was more than double that for Pet Plans basic option!

tonym911

17,386 posts

212 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
Yep I found Petplan expensive on run-o-the-mill policies and reviewers weren't complimentary about them when I was researching the subject but it sounds like PHers have had good service from them.

Shuvi Tupya

Original Poster:

24,460 posts

254 months

Tuesday 28th December 2010
quotequote all
Thanks for that, Snails smile

You may or may not be interested to hear that Pet Plan quoted the same price when i used my mothers adress on Aberdeenshire, as they for my address in Milton keynes!