Alternative to Lilly's Kitchen Dog Food

Alternative to Lilly's Kitchen Dog Food

Author
Discussion

cliffords

Original Poster:

1,814 posts

30 months

Sunday 22nd September
quotequote all
My dogs love it and it's good for them judging by what I pick up and bag each day .
However it's got so expensive. It's £3 plus per can and it's just getting too expensive for us now .

Can anyone suggest a near or equally good alternative, perhaps at a lower price .

Thanks

Silvanus

6,036 posts

30 months

Sunday 22nd September
quotequote all
James Well beloved is a fair bit cheaper and has pretty good ingredients for the price.

dave123456

2,822 posts

154 months

Sunday 22nd September
quotequote all
I use skinners dry and wet. Probably not the best quality but my hound is healthy and her poo is pretty consistent and ok.

I find Morrisons yellow sticker section often has decent offal at peanuts which supplements it well, although stinks the kitchen to high heaven.

evoivboy

952 posts

153 months

Sunday 22nd September
quotequote all
We use Tails, very good our dog loves it, you get a big discount too with first order

Smurfsarepeopletoo

896 posts

64 months

Sunday 22nd September
quotequote all
We feed our dog raw food, buy it pre made from a local pet shop, comes complete and frozen, and around £4-£5 for a kg.

spookly

4,193 posts

102 months

Sunday 22nd September
quotequote all
My two dogs go through 60Kg of dog food a month, so value is important.
We bought Millies Wolfheart on recommendation of someone else with the same breed. And they've thrived on it.
Their dry food is anything from 40 to 80% meat. They also do wet food for £26 for 12 cans, but we never use that as mine just eat the dry food and all the household leftovers.
Best thing is the next day DPD delivery.

Vizsla

1,053 posts

131 months

Sunday 22nd September
quotequote all
We use Purina chicken-based kibble for our Vizsla (yep, apt username etc laugh). Plus assorted treats (pizzles, pig ears, bones from the butcher etc)

He's now 7 yr old, never needed the vets apart from annual injections, VERY lively fun dog, lean and athletic, most people we meet think he's 'still a young dog'.

As a pup we took him to a local training place (poor choice, our fault) where the trainer rubbished any 'mainstream' foods such as Purina, Hills, Royal Canin etc, claiming they contained (amongst other 'nasties' laugh) sugar beet process residues (they do, fibre, but with virtually zero free sugar) which gave the pup a 'sugar high' leading to manic behaviour. I happen to know from my (clinical/science-based) career that this is nonsense, the urban myth of a 'sugar high' in children following the eating of sweets has been pretty well debunked by the medical profession.

The lady in question didn't react well when I told her 'I could agree with you, but then we'd both be wrong' argue Oh well.

HelenT

269 posts

146 months

Sunday 22nd September
quotequote all
Our working cocker has been on Millies Wolfheart for probably 10 years now, changed from Barking Heads, she loves it, now on lower fat versions as not quite active as she used to be at 12.5 years old but still more active than most dogs and absolutely loves their "Porky Strings" as a treat. Great customer service and advice as well.

SoliD

1,203 posts

224 months

Monday 23rd September
quotequote all
Vizsla said:
We use Purina chicken-based kibble for our Vizsla (yep, apt username etc laugh). Plus assorted treats (pizzles, pig ears, bones from the butcher etc)

He's now 7 yr old, never needed the vets apart from annual injections, VERY lively fun dog, lean and athletic, most people we meet think he's 'still a young dog'.

As a pup we took him to a local training place (poor choice, our fault) where the trainer rubbished any 'mainstream' foods such as Purina, Hills, Royal Canin etc, claiming they contained (amongst other 'nasties' laugh) sugar beet process residues (they do, fibre, but with virtually zero free sugar) which gave the pup a 'sugar high' leading to manic behaviour. I happen to know from my (clinical/science-based) career that this is nonsense, the urban myth of a 'sugar high' in children following the eating of sweets has been pretty well debunked by the medical profession.

The lady in question didn't react well when I told her 'I could agree with you, but then we'd both be wrong' argue Oh well.
We've used the Purina Beta for Puppies with Chicken for Puck which was suggested by the breeder, he says it's the only stuff he feeds his dogs through their lives. Opposite to you when we went to puppy class we were the only ones who they didn't suggest an alternative food to.

She still loves it and it's still my primary training aid, being a lab any food will be scoffed in second. But it must be alright as my sisters dog who is excessively fussy and takes forever to eat absolutely gobbles it down and also will take it as a treat which she only really does for extremely smelly items.

Tickle

5,265 posts

211 months

Monday 23rd September
quotequote all
spookly said:
My two dogs go through 60Kg of dog food a month, so value is important.
We bought Millies Wolfheart on recommendation of someone else with the same breed. And they've thrived on it.
Their dry food is anything from 40 to 80% meat. They also do wet food for £26 for 12 cans, but we never use that as mine just eat the dry food and all the household leftovers.
Best thing is the next day DPD delivery.
Millie's here too, forerunner dry mixed with Millie's canned (tracker and riverside at the moment)

German Shorthaired Pointer if the breed adds any context OP.