Which chainsaw?

Author
Discussion

Tuna

Original Poster:

19,930 posts

290 months

Friday 15th May 2009
quotequote all
Looking for a small chainsaw for general tree maintenance (long term) and a little bit of hacking around with some old railway sleepers (short term). The little 38cc models look good, but does anyone have any recommendations?

jjones

4,435 posts

199 months

Friday 15th May 2009
quotequote all
stihl ms260, (or older model designation 026).



Tuna

Original Poster:

19,930 posts

290 months

Friday 15th May 2009
quotequote all
jjones said:
stihl ms260, (or older model designation 026).
At that price, I'd expect it to peel grapes, make my tea and automatically carve the wood into a working model of the London Eye.

Something nearer to 100 quid would be more appropriate (yes, I know).

DavidY

4,469 posts

290 months

Saturday 16th May 2009
quotequote all
Buy a smaller Stihl then, such as the MS170 around £140 with a 14" bar.

davidy

astroarcadia

1,712 posts

206 months

Saturday 16th May 2009
quotequote all
We bought the Stihl ms171 last week . I think its a good entry level chainsaw, I personally would not want to go much bigger as a novice. Maybe its a bit more than you want to spend, think we paid about £165, but it will last much longer and be more reliable than anything from Homebase.

Funnily enough we bought it beacuse we had a job that involved cutting 9x4 timbers to build two large planters for a school. I have been using it all week and it has been great, no problems. Its now living in my garage and will be used for firewood and around the garden, very managable.

Go and pick up the Stihl 2009 catalogue (some great photos in it), you will soon be convincing the wife you need a new strimmer, hedgecutter and blower!

Edited by astroarcadia on Saturday 16th May 08:34

Pickled Piper

6,381 posts

241 months

Saturday 16th May 2009
quotequote all
Stihl or Husquana

pp

mrsxllifts

2,501 posts

205 months

Saturday 16th May 2009
quotequote all
We bought a cheap and cheerful 2 stroke one from b & Q, a few years back when our big one packed up and we needed to cut sleepers there and then. It was aout £60 and did the job and does little fiddlely bits around the garden but nothing too horrendous. We cut about 8 sleepers up before the chain was knackered but found it wasn't worth mucking around with a file when a new chain was about £8! It won't ever cut up oak trees but will do what you need by the sounds of it.

Tuna

Original Poster:

19,930 posts

290 months

Saturday 16th May 2009
quotequote all
mrsxllifts said:
We bought a cheap and cheerful 2 stroke one from b & Q, a few years back when our big one packed up and we needed to cut sleepers there and then. It was aout £60 and did the job and does little fiddlely bits around the garden but nothing too horrendous. We cut about 8 sleepers up before the chain was knackered but found it wasn't worth mucking around with a file when a new chain was about £8! It won't ever cut up oak trees but will do what you need by the sounds of it.
That's what I was leaning towards. I've got a Stihl strimmer and it's a fine bit of kit, but a base chainsaw from them is three times the price of a boggo one from B&Q - and also smaller and less powerful.

Slothario

258 posts

185 months

Saturday 16th May 2009
quotequote all
Try AMA (Italian made) for the best budget machine around.

Nicholas Blair

4,109 posts

290 months

Saturday 16th May 2009
quotequote all
If you are cutting railway sleepers, remember and clean it during and afterwards.

I lent mine to a mate to do the same thing - what a f****n mess it came back in!

theboyfold

10,993 posts

232 months

Saturday 16th May 2009
quotequote all
Tuna said:
mrsxllifts said:
We bought a cheap and cheerful 2 stroke one from b & Q, a few years back when our big one packed up and we needed to cut sleepers there and then. It was aout £60 and did the job and does little fiddlely bits around the garden but nothing too horrendous. We cut about 8 sleepers up before the chain was knackered but found it wasn't worth mucking around with a file when a new chain was about £8! It won't ever cut up oak trees but will do what you need by the sounds of it.
That's what I was leaning towards. I've got a Stihl strimmer and it's a fine bit of kit, but a base chainsaw from them is three times the price of a boggo one from B&Q - and also smaller and less powerful.
I'm hoping to pick one up from them tomorrow to chop up a few sleepers I picked up today. I'll let you know which I get and how I get on

Tuna

Original Poster:

19,930 posts

290 months

Monday 18th May 2009
quotequote all
theboyfold said:
I'm hoping to pick one up from them tomorrow to chop up a few sleepers I picked up today. I'll let you know which I get and how I get on
Is it hard to type after you've chopped your fingers off?

theboyfold

10,993 posts

232 months

Monday 18th May 2009
quotequote all
Tuna said:
theboyfold said:
I'm hoping to pick one up from them tomorrow to chop up a few sleepers I picked up today. I'll let you know which I get and how I get on
Is it hard to type after you've chopped your fingers off?
Haha! Got put off by the weather and wedding stuff frown So not sure when I can pick one up now...

robwilk

818 posts

186 months

Tuesday 19th May 2009
quotequote all
For cutting railway sleepers I found it easier to use my circular saw mush quicker and cleaner cut, once from the front turn it over then from the back. Perhaps the chain saw I borrowed was past it but the circular saw made light work of straight end cuts. Just a thought.

Fume troll

4,389 posts

218 months

Tuesday 19th May 2009
quotequote all
Railway sleepers will be hellish with a chainsaw, especially if they are old.

For £100 I'd be looking at electric. Plenty of power if you don't mind the cable, less hassle, less maintenance and more reliable, and still have plenty of power.

Cheers,

FT.

s3fella

10,524 posts

193 months

Tuesday 19th May 2009
quotequote all
I got a 13 inch ryobi one from screwfix for £70 in their sale and its been perfect! " seasons of garden and chopping firewood, seems excellent for the money!

RT/10Dave

6,364 posts

214 months

Wednesday 20th May 2009
quotequote all
Got to echo what has already been said, Stihl MS170 is a great chainsaw, I have one and I am really impressed with it.

Must also agree with what has already been said regarding the sleepers, if you are cutting sleepers definitely a good circular saw is the way to go, I always cut them like that, do one side, turn over and do the other, much easier, and a much cleaner cut.

eddie1980

419 posts

194 months

Wednesday 20th May 2009
quotequote all
I cannot recommend Stilh enough.

I have been using chainsaws for years and am currently running a 15" Black & Decker electric for light jobs and noise sensitive times, a 15" Husqvarna petrol and a 20" Husqvarna Petrol for the larger jobs.

I cannot tell you how much I regret not getting a 15" Stihl a year ago when my last 15" Husqvarna died. Its not much more money and the quality is a level above.

If you want something quick and dirty then an electric one will cost you about £50 and come with a nice 2 year warranty. (currently on my 4th :-)) If you want something for your grand kid's to inherit and not have to maintain it in the mean time get a Stihl

I am currently replacing all my garden tools with Stihl when they fail and all my DIY tools with Bosch Professional when they die.

Edited by eddie1980 on Wednesday 20th May 13:37