Are Debit Cards becoming unfashionable?

Are Debit Cards becoming unfashionable?

Author
Discussion

DrYazz

Original Poster:

881 posts

185 months

Friday 23rd July 2010
quotequote all
I tried to secure weekend hire car (using firms with worldwide presence) here in Vienna, Austria, only to be told that the booking could only be made with a credit card, not a debit card.

Which I found to be odd.

I don't have credit cards, because I don't do 'credit'.

Anybody got a clue why a debit card could not be used to secure the booking. I find it baffling, myself.

davidjpowell

18,059 posts

190 months

Friday 23rd July 2010
quotequote all
Hertz say this, but took my Visa Debit work card with no issues today,

b2dan

699 posts

206 months

Saturday 24th July 2010
quotequote all
I'm probably wrong here but could it be to do with better protection, I.e if they need to claim the money? Then the account linked to the debit card could be empty with no overdraft whereas the credit card company have an obligation to pay?

I use my credit card for my monthly purchases (as it's not my money so if the card gets cloned then in theory it's the card companies problem) and pay off in full each month. (also helps my credit rating).

There again I could be spouting tripe!

ymwoods

2,183 posts

183 months

Saturday 24th July 2010
quotequote all
It is pretty much this. With a credit card they can debit you for any damage or if you bring it back late without the worry that it will decline (unless you cancel the card) it gives them a little more security.

On top of this, some Debit cards for people with bad credit ratings can ONLY be used with themselves present (IE, Pin & Chip) so if you damaged the car they can not just automaticly debit the money as per the contract and have to chase you through court. If you use a credit card then a CNP (card not present) transaction is pretty much guarenteed to go through and they will be allowed to do this as you will have signed something to agree to a damage cost or what not, should their be any.

nomisesor

983 posts

193 months

Saturday 24th July 2010
quotequote all
b2dan said:
I'm probably wrong here but could it be to do with better protection, I.e if they need to claim the money? Then the account linked to the debit card could be empty with no overdraft whereas the credit card company have an obligation to pay?

I use my credit card for my monthly purchases (as it's not my money so if the card gets cloned then in theory it's the card companies problem) and pay off in full each month. (also helps my credit rating).

There again I could be spouting tripe!
Doesn't necessarily help with credit rating - I had done this for more than 20 years with a blemish-free history but was turned down for one of two £15/month sim cards for my children as my credit score wasn't satisfactory. Turns out that as my card & mortgage are with my own bank they don't show with the credit reference agencies so I had no credit history and was deemed unsuitable ..... apparently a common problem for people who have never had car, furniture loans etc.

b2dan

699 posts

206 months

Saturday 24th July 2010
quotequote all
Ah.

My mortgage & credit cards are also with my bank! But my credit rating is excellent according to expedia. Though I do have my phone contracts with have always been paid.

b2

fluffnik

20,156 posts

233 months

Friday 30th July 2010
quotequote all
There might not be any money behind a debit card...

DrYazz said:
I don't have credit cards, because I don't do 'credit'.
I don't do 'credit' either but I do have credit cards, paid in full by direct debit each month, for the extra protection they offer.

Jackleman

974 posts

172 months

Friday 30th July 2010
quotequote all
I have a pay as you go Mastercard as I don't do "credit" either, great for travel etc. Just put a couple of hundred quid on it for use in emergencys etc.