HMRC and Student Loans Company - Whose responsibility?

HMRC and Student Loans Company - Whose responsibility?

Author
Discussion

Sideways Rich

Original Poster:

1,110 posts

183 months

Friday 9th April 2010
quotequote all
Here's the scenario, When I first started at my current company in the 06/07 tax year, I was put on a BR tax code which meant no student loan deductions were taken via PAYE. I managed to sort out the tax code pay the tax that was due (owing to me being on the wrong code) and student loan contributions were taken automatically through PAYE monthly.

In the subsequent 12 months I have paid off the loan in full and in actual fact I've overpaid and am owed about £4k from Student Loans.

The challenge is HMRC are asking me for an amount outstanding (student loan contribution for when I was on a BR tax code) retrospectively for the 07/08 tax year but they are not taking into account the fact I have actually repaid the loan in full and am actually owed a rebate.

I call Student Loans and they confirm I have over-paid and am due a rebate but direct me to HMRC to sort it out, I then call HMRC and I'm met with a "Well I only did 3hrs training on Student Loans 10 years ago, it's complicated, you'll need to talk to Student Loans Company!"!!

Has anyone been in this situation, I'd appreciate any help/tips to resolve it!!

Thanks
Rich

Mattt

16,663 posts

224 months

Sunday 11th April 2010
quotequote all
Can't help with this, but wish you all the best of luck.

The Student Loans repayment scheme is one of the biggest farces around.

scirocco265

421 posts

182 months

Wednesday 14th April 2010
quotequote all
Was in a similar situation myself(-ish). Call the Student Loans Co again, they're really hit and miss but if you're lucky, you'll get one of the really good advisors. If still no joy, write them a letter. This way your query should find it's way to the person who can actually help you, rather than some bint with a FAQ on their PC screen, getting paid NMW to file their nails.

Sideways Rich

Original Poster:

1,110 posts

183 months

Thursday 15th April 2010
quotequote all
Seem to be making some progress, they are sending me a statement of account which will clearly show I have over-paid and am due a rebate from HMRC, I'm hoping this letter will be enough for HMRC to pull their finger out and provide the rebate.

Only issue is the letter is a "manual letter" so it appears to be taking more than a week to arrange, very frustrating must have called them 5 times just to get to this stage! Ah well, will keep persevering as the rebate is worth it!

soprano

1,598 posts

206 months

Thursday 15th April 2010
quotequote all
How did you manage to over pay by £4k?!

Mattt

16,663 posts

224 months

Thursday 15th April 2010
quotequote all
soprano said:
How did you manage to over pay by £4k?!
Not sure in this case, but:

The system is set up so that even if you have a balance of £2.50 left to pay, for the whole of the next tax year they will take full deductions off you. They then only credit the account at the end of the tax year - meanwhile interest accrues even though you've 'paid' the loan off.

So you build up a huge surplus, then have to pursue incompetent QUANGOS to get it back.

BluePurpleRed

1,137 posts

232 months

Friday 16th April 2010
quotequote all
Mattt said:
soprano said:
How did you manage to over pay by £4k?!
Not sure in this case, but:

The system is set up so that even if you have a balance of £2.50 left to pay, for the whole of the next tax year they will take full deductions off you. They then only credit the account at the end of the tax year - meanwhile interest accrues even though you've 'paid' the loan off.

So you build up a huge surplus, then have to pursue incompetent QUANGOS to get it back.
To be fair, they do back calculate the interest at he end of the year as if you were making the monthly payments. I got my over payment back in 7 - 10 days. Its not a bad system, its just low maintenance. Imagine the extra cost of having to administer monthly payments rather than just get one big lump sum and a simple back calc of what interest is owed?

Sideways Rich

Original Poster:

1,110 posts

183 months

Monday 19th April 2010
quotequote all
It's automatically deducted out of my monthly pay packet, it came to light when HMRC sent me a snotty letter demanding 6k, I investigated and found out they actually owe me 4k!

Sideways Rich

Original Poster:

1,110 posts

183 months

Friday 30th April 2010
quotequote all
Does anyone know the fastest route to get hold of your P60 from previous tax years (I've changed employer twice), I need to get hold of mine for 05/06.

Thanks

scirocco265

421 posts

182 months

Friday 30th April 2010
quotequote all
Contact the Company you were employed with at the beginning of April 2006