Record A' Level Results - Again

Record A' Level Results - Again

Author
Discussion

Iain H

Original Poster:

390 posts

199 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
What utter bks these claims are. Most people I have come across that have left school in the last 10 years can't even spell, yet they achieved higher levels of education than I did when I did my A' levels in 89. Utter bks!! The only reason the results are better is because the exams are easier, end of!! Everyone knows it but politicians keep spouting bks about how they have improved standards!!

I have a friend who is a secondary Science teacher, some of the thing she tells me about how they help pupils get better results leaves me dumb founded. When I did mine we had 2 exams at the end of a 2 year course, if you fked up in those exams, it was re sit time, now they virtually know their results by the time they finsh the course.

Unbelievable!


Eric Mc

122,699 posts

271 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
So...?

nonegreen

7,803 posts

276 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
Iain H said:
What utter bks these claims are. Most people I have come across that have left school in the last 10 years can't even spell, yet they achieved higher levels of education than I did when I did my A' levels in 89. Utter bks!! The only reason the results are better is because the exams are easier, end of!! Everyone knows it but politicians keep spouting bks about how they have improved standards!!

I have a friend who is a secondary Science teacher, some of the thing she tells me about how they help pupils get better results leaves me dumb founded. When I did mine we had 2 exams at the end of a 2 year course, if you fked up in those exams, it was re sit time, now they virtually know their results by the time they finsh the course.

Unbelievable!
yu just dont underfkingstand m8. innit. wots impartunt is all ve wickle gurls n boyz wurk very hard. bein clevoh is elitist st. wots impartunt now is that more people doin sciunceright at collige innit speshly global warming sciunceright innit cos vats very impartunt. see fick people vote laboh innit right an ve plan is to pack ve house of lords wiv fick people wiv A levuls innit. An when Charlie takes ovoh from ve witch is appy days innit both chambers and ve monach all fick as pigst innit right.

Funk Odyssey

1,983 posts

235 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
Iain H said:
What utter bks these claims are. Most people I have come across that have left school in the last 10 years can't even spell, yet they achieved higher levels of education than I did when I did my A' levels in 89. Utter bks!! The only reason the results are better is because the exams are easier, end of!! Everyone knows it but politicians keep spouting bks about how they have improved standards!!

I have a friend who is a secondary Science teacher, some of the thing she tells me about how they help pupils get better results leaves me dumb founded. When I did mine we had 2 exams at the end of a 2 year course, if you fked up in those exams, it was re sit time, now they virtually know their results by the time they finsh the course.

Unbelievable!
isn't that the point of a course?

Iain H

Original Poster:

390 posts

199 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
So...?
Well if you are happy with the education system turning out below standard pupils and Politicians believing everything is rosey then you are OK aren't you!!

You clearly don't have to work with any of these so called best ever achievers that the schools are putting into the work place. I am amazed some of them can even dress themselves in the morning! Obviously there are some that are very bright and some with intelligence and common sense, but I would say they aren't the majority!

AndrewW-G

11,968 posts

223 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
Nice to see that tractor production is up again this year!

Eric Mc

122,699 posts

271 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
Iain H said:
Eric Mc said:
So...?
Well if you are happy with the education system turning out below standard pupils and Politicians believing everything is rosey then you are OK aren't you!!

You clearly don't have to work with any of these so called best ever achievers that the schools are putting into the work place. I am amazed some of them can even dress themselves in the morning! Obviously there are some that are very bright and some with intelligence and common sense, but I would say they aren't the majority!
We get this debate/argument/rant this time every year. I agree that educational standards aren't as giood as they used to be - the evidence is everywhere.

HOWEVER, good, intelligent students still exist and I certainly don't want to belittle those who hhave genuinely done well.

Plotloss

67,280 posts

276 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
HOWEVER, good, intelligent students still exist and I certainly don't want to belittle those who hhave genuinely done well.
No one wants to belittle them, the education system does that by removing higher education and employer's ability to separate the exceptional from the merely bright.

Iain H

Original Poster:

390 posts

199 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
Eric Mc said:
Iain H said:
Eric Mc said:
So...?
Well if you are happy with the education system turning out below standard pupils and Politicians believing everything is rosey then you are OK aren't you!!

You clearly don't have to work with any of these so called best ever achievers that the schools are putting into the work place. I am amazed some of them can even dress themselves in the morning! Obviously there are some that are very bright and some with intelligence and common sense, but I would say they aren't the majority!
We get this debate/argument/rant this time every year. I agree that educational standards aren't as giood as they used to be - the evidence is everywhere.

HOWEVER, good, intelligent students still exist and I certainly don't want to belittle those who hhave genuinely done well.
I agree, those that have done well and go on to achieve should be congratulated. It is sad that the achievements of those students is lost because a student that in the past would have struggled to get a grade E is now getting a B/C because of all the help the teachers seem to be giving them.


Iain H

Original Poster:

390 posts

199 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
Funk Odyssey said:
Iain H said:
What utter bks these claims are. Most people I have come across that have left school in the last 10 years can't even spell, yet they achieved higher levels of education than I did when I did my A' levels in 89. Utter bks!! The only reason the results are better is because the exams are easier, end of!! Everyone knows it but politicians keep spouting bks about how they have improved standards!!

I have a friend who is a secondary Science teacher, some of the thing she tells me about how they help pupils get better results leaves me dumb founded. When I did mine we had 2 exams at the end of a 2 year course, if you fked up in those exams, it was re sit time, now they virtually know their results by the time they finsh the course.

Unbelievable!
isn't that the point of a course?
I suppose it is, I don't really disagree with that aspect of the current courses, although it does remove the pressure of the final exams, that we all have to cope with. And in life in the work place you will have to cope with pressure, which I am not sure the current courses/education system is adequately preparing students for.

okgo

39,147 posts

204 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
Plotloss said:
Eric Mc said:
HOWEVER, good, intelligent students still exist and I certainly don't want to belittle those who hhave genuinely done well.
No one wants to belittle them, the education system does that by removing higher education and employer's ability to separate the exceptional from the merely bright.
You have said that before, those exact words.

And I agree this time too.

But are there really that many people out there that come out with 1st degree's from the top 3 Uni's?

JagLover

43,594 posts

241 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
Plotloss said:
Eric Mc said:
HOWEVER, good, intelligent students still exist and I certainly don't want to belittle those who hhave genuinely done well.
No one wants to belittle them, the education system does that by removing higher education and employer's ability to separate the exceptional from the merely bright.
Agreed

With results that would have got a C a generation ago now resulting in an A grade how can you differentiate between the sheer numbers of straight A students?. It was once the sign of an exceptional student, now it is routine.


mattviatura

2,996 posts

206 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
AndrewW-G said:
Nice to see that tractor production is up again this year!
Yup.

I would not bet against this lot getting in again.

Cameron needs to start shouting. Loudly.

Gedon

3,097 posts

182 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Outcome-based_educati...

Read, learn, think, realise.

I'm a teacher and the usual outcomes are huge grades and minimal understanding. Teach the exam, not the subject.

Remember, people making me feel good about me is the most important thing and other people feeling good, valued and successful is to them. When everyone improves again, we can all say "well done us" and revel in our success. We do deserve a pay rise as we're great and the students are better than ever. By embracing forward thinking buzzword laden bullst, we can perfect our indoctrination to levels where we will actually come in our pants.

Bring back grading to a curve and actually teaching a subject (ok, for those of you of a buzzword loving nature, "facilitating learning" of a subject) so that the students get it and can manipulate the subject matter to the best of their intelligence.

It isn't going to happen as everyone knows the only way to succeed is to put in more red tape and "objectives". It is total bullst. Sadly, it's where my money comes from and in order to tick box and not have my arse fail to meet it's objective, I have to send out kids with A' and GCSE bits of paper, which are frankly a joke.

I did mickey mouse science at school and science A's. It was a big step and when I attempted a 1966 O' Level Chemistry, I could barely do it. It was fundamental stuff which had been ignored all the way through. It's an embarrasment and only by self education have I filled in the gaps.

I feel for this bunch of leavers. They are going into a cut throat contest where the actual subject matter has been devalued.

Even degrees are now doing "directed learning" based on objectives and you have 1.1 Chem Grads who wouldn't be able to make Copper metal out of Copper Chloride and Zinc metal and a bit of dil HCl. Useless.

At least Oxbridge are keeping the bar up.

I don't think IB's are the problem, they will just employ more of the same techniques.

The snag isn't directed learning. It's using these methods and pressure of statistics to teach an exam, not a subject. The results are usually worthless and the ability of the student with the subject is usually via his/her own cross links. This system does enable staff, which are products of the ste system to appear better than they are. The quality is definately going down. I'm well educated a fair few of my colleagues are not fit for purpose, even though the may have all the boxes ticked.

I will not put my child through this system.......

(Experience of a whole spectrum of schools)

Anyway.....on that note smile Well done those who did well and remember that it's true graft that equals success.

Plotloss

67,280 posts

276 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
Gedon, do you put any weight on the BL (I have to contract it due to me not being able to spell it - bloody education system wink) system that the Universities and some prominent teachers would like to convert us to?

JonRB

75,724 posts

278 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
They had that 'Chipmunk' fella being interviewed on Radio 1 this morning, and Moyles was talking to him about his A-level results that he's due to get today. The guy could hardly string a sentence together yet one of his A-levels is in "Cognitive Reasoning" (or something like that) where, apparently, he had to "read newspapers an' novels an' stuff an' work out their flaws and stuff, innit" and "it's really hard, man". Moyles must have liked him because instead of tearing him to shreds over it he merely made some remark about that clearly not being his best subject.

Kind of stunned TBH.

JonRB

75,724 posts

278 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
JagLover said:
With results that would have got a C a generation ago now resulting in an A grade how can you differentiate between the sheer numbers of straight A students?. It was once the sign of an exceptional student, now it is routine.
That's why they now have "A*" - a grade above an A. Which is just stupid. Why not just make it harder to get an A? So now we have A*, A, B, C, etc. instead of A, B, C, D, etc.

It's like having your amp go up to 11. smile

chris watton

22,478 posts

266 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
I was talking to my friend’s wife’s’ son a few weeks back, and he told me that if he didn’t think he wasn’t going to do well in a particular A-level exam, he sits down with the teacher and the teacher asks him what he would like the questions to be. After, if he still wasn’t sure, the teacher then armed him with the answers for the exam! What he was essentially saying is, if you do not know the answers, or haven’t revised for your exam, don’t worry, because the teachers will do their best to give you the answers beforehand, with little to no intellectual input from the student!

It seems that for the schools, and the spectre of having funding taken away, failure is not an option – except of course, for the student’s when they are out in the real world, where spin and dodgy statistics don’t count.

mattviatura

2,996 posts

206 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
Ahem

It's 'definitely' and 'Mickey Mouse'.

pimpin gimp

3,295 posts

206 months

Thursday 20th August 2009
quotequote all
JonRB said:
They had that 'Chipmunk' fella being interviewed on Radio 1 this morning, and Moyles was talking to him about his A-level results that he's due to get today. The guy could hardly string a sentence together yet one of his A-levels is in "Cognitive Reasoning" (or something like that) where, apparently, he had to "read newspapers an' novels an' stuff an' work out their flaws and stuff, innit" and "it's really hard, man". Moyles must have liked him because instead of tearing him to shreds over it he merely made some remark about that clearly not being his best subject.

Kind of stunned TBH.
Critical reading, innit blud. shoot