Alex Salmond RIP

Author
Discussion

Iamnotkloot

Original Poster:

1,589 posts

154 months

Saturday 12th October
quotequote all

wc98

11,175 posts

147 months

Saturday 12th October
quotequote all
I maybe didn't agree with his politics but capability wise he was light years ahead of most current politicians and an intellectual colossus in comparison to the entire Scottish parliament we have today. RIP.

M3333

2,274 posts

221 months

Saturday 12th October
quotequote all
Sad news. I rarely agreed with his politics but he was always entertaining and interesting to listen to. Sounds sudden. RIP chap.

chemistry

2,448 posts

116 months

Saturday 12th October
quotequote all
Wow, that’s a surprise. Wasn’t a fan, but that’s far too young.

Previous

1,505 posts

161 months

Saturday 12th October
quotequote all
A hugely influential and capable politician. RIP.

ChocolateFrog

28,637 posts

180 months

Saturday 12th October
quotequote all
I don't have strong feelings either way about AS but it made me think if I die at 69 after having received my state pension for a year I'll be haunting someone for refund on my NI.

matchmaker

8,648 posts

207 months

Saturday 12th October
quotequote all
Previous said:
A hugely influential and capable politician. RIP.
Indeed.

bobthemonkey

4,029 posts

223 months

Saturday 12th October
quotequote all
Think Andrew Neil sums it up very well.

https://x.com/afneil/status/1845145082149658772

redrabbit

1,559 posts

172 months

Saturday 12th October
quotequote all
"Sleepy cuddles" rolleyes

Meanwhile , a lot of hypocritical tributes - "towering figure", "passionate patriot" - being rattled off from those who couldn't stand him.

Made a lot of noise. Self interested populist who achieved next to nothing, except sowing division. Sorry, but there it is.

Edited by redrabbit on Saturday 12th October 23:14

Galsia

2,194 posts

197 months

Saturday 12th October
quotequote all
It is a shame that he died so young but he was a bit of a knob. 🤷

Carl_VivaEspana

13,168 posts

269 months

Sunday 13th October
quotequote all
Galsia said:
It is a shame that he died so young but he was a bit of a knob. ??
You'll need to pay for it but here is an articulate reason why you are wrong.

https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/alex-salmond-w...

He was some politician. I didn't agree with almost anything he said but I have to tip my hat to the man.

Roderick Spode

3,448 posts

56 months

Sunday 13th October
quotequote all
I fundamentally disliked his politics and disagreed with most things he stood for, but I've always had a quiet admiration for the man.

Especially after the goings on of the last few years, which alas he shall not see brought to a just resolution.

reddiesel

2,473 posts

54 months

Sunday 13th October
quotequote all
Alex Salmond as a Politician was a Head and Shoulders above any British Politician since Margaret Thatcher and I invite anyone to name better in those intervening Years . Speaking as a Scot who has spent most of his life in England and shared none of his Nationalist aspirations I look at the nonentities past and present , the complete absence of any Political talent and I find it astounding .Salmond could both orate and more importantly like Thatcher he had conviction and that in my humble opinion is what's sorely missing in British Politics . In fact I would go as far to say that its been replaced by disingenuous opportunism .

ianrb

1,561 posts

147 months

Sunday 13th October
quotequote all
redrabbit said:
"Sleepy cuddles" rolleyes

Meanwhile , a lot of hypocritical tributes - "towering figure", "passionate patriot" - being rattled off from those who couldn't stand him.

Made a lot of noise. Self interested populist who achieved next to nothing, except sowing division. Sorry, but there it is.

Edited by redrabbit on Saturday 12th October 23:14
Yep, think that covers it.



FredericRobinson

3,938 posts

239 months

Sunday 13th October
quotequote all
ianrb said:
Yep, think that covers it.
H took the SNP from relatively small to government

Mabbs9

1,253 posts

225 months

Sunday 13th October
quotequote all
One of the few conviction politicians. He was also untainted by ridiculous media-training that makes so many politicians irritating.

I didn't agree with his politics but I respected how effective he was. He never looked particularly healthy but 69 isn't old.

andyA700

3,315 posts

44 months

Sunday 13th October
quotequote all
RIP Alex, a statesman amongst political pygmies.

G-wiz

2,580 posts

33 months

Wednesday 16th October
quotequote all
Sad for family and friends.

What I am unsurprised about is that he died of sudden heart attack.

I always thought of him as a living, walking, fried Mars bar.

cuprabob

15,701 posts

221 months

Wednesday 16th October
quotequote all
G-wiz said:
Sad for family and friends.

What I am unsurprised about is that he died of sudden heart attack.

I always thought of him as a living, walking, fried Mars bar.
Allegedly he was opening a bottle of Tomato Ketchup at the time, which I think it quite fitting.

On the subject of fried Mars bars, I was walking past a Blue Lagoon Chippy the other day and deep fried Mars bar with ice cream was £6.50.

Ari

19,524 posts

222 months

Friday 18th October
quotequote all
G-wiz said:
What I am unsurprised about is that he died of sudden heart attack.
Yes, a lot of that about of late... scratchchin