Budget 2023

Author
Discussion

Rufus Stone

Original Poster:

7,698 posts

62 months

Friday 10th March 2023
quotequote all
Here we go again, will we win, will we lose ...

As appears customary these days, proposals/intentions are leaked in advance. This one concerns personal/occupational pensions.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11841951/...

Inflation has seriously affected pension provision possibilities.

KingNothing

3,205 posts

159 months

Friday 10th March 2023
quotequote all
I'm sure people struggling with food, fuel and housing bills will be happy to know they'll soon be able to put more than £40k into their pension each year laugh

anonymous-user

60 months

Friday 10th March 2023
quotequote all
A better pension in twenty years time doesn't pay my mortgage bill this month... Do they really think we're all that stupid?

My guess is he will postpone the energy price cap scheduled to come in to force on 01 Apr... He has to surely? There are a few inches of snow on the ground across the north and he's going to let them add 20% to the energy bills?!

Rufus Stone

Original Poster:

7,698 posts

62 months

Friday 10th March 2023
quotequote all
pablo said:
A better pension in twenty years time doesn't pay my mortgage bill this month... Do they really think we're all that stupid?

My guess is he will postpone the energy price cap scheduled to come in to force on 01 Apr... He has to surely? There are a few inches of snow on the ground across the north and he's going to let them add 20% to the energy bills?!
It has been rumoured that he will continue the current cap for further three months.

Gecko1978

10,334 posts

163 months

Friday 10th March 2023
quotequote all
KingNothing said:
I'm sure people struggling with food, fuel and housing bills will be happy to know they'll soon be able to put more than £40k into their pension each year laugh
Also its not the reason many Dr's quit. IR35 banned Dr's working as a PSC so thoes close to retirement saw tax earnings go up about 30% when forced onto payroll with no expenses allowed (travell costs to another hospital). So they simply quit.

Happened across the UK again in 2020 but the government doesn't want to admit it aggressive tax is bringing in less as strangling growth

Gecko1978

10,334 posts

163 months

Friday 10th March 2023
quotequote all
Rufus Stone said:
pablo said:
A better pension in twenty years time doesn't pay my mortgage bill this month... Do they really think we're all that stupid?

My guess is he will postpone the energy price cap scheduled to come in to force on 01 Apr... He has to surely? There are a few inches of snow on the ground across the north and he's going to let them add 20% to the energy bills?!
It has been rumoured that he will continue the current cap for further three months.
Capping energy is one thing but people need cash in there pockets to buy food, petrol, clothing etc. Freezing tax allowances and raising tax on higher earners is not going to help people spend now an boost the economy.

Even HS2 that giant money pit is being scalled back

Ivan stewart

2,792 posts

42 months

Friday 10th March 2023
quotequote all
I think they are

Ivan stewart

2,792 posts

42 months

Friday 10th March 2023
quotequote all
FUBAR !!!!

fido

17,216 posts

261 months

Friday 10th March 2023
quotequote all
I cannot afford to retire in the UK. Who knows they might extend the Rwanda scheme (or some other suitably warm destination) to retirees!

Rufus Stone

Original Poster:

7,698 posts

62 months

Friday 10th March 2023
quotequote all
Gecko1978 said:
Capping energy is one thing but people need cash in there pockets to buy food, petrol, clothing etc. Freezing tax allowances and raising tax on higher earners is not going to help people spend now an boost the economy.

Even HS2 that giant money pit is being scalled back
Are people not getting any pay rises?

pghstochaj

2,469 posts

125 months

Friday 10th March 2023
quotequote all
Gecko1978 said:
KingNothing said:
I'm sure people struggling with food, fuel and housing bills will be happy to know they'll soon be able to put more than £40k into their pension each year laugh
Also its not the reason many Dr's quit. IR35 banned Dr's working as a PSC so thoes close to retirement saw tax earnings go up about 30% when forced onto payroll with no expenses allowed (travell costs to another hospital). So they simply quit.

Happened across the UK again in 2020 but the government doesn't want to admit it aggressive tax is bringing in less as strangling growth
It had a huge impact, what are you talking about? My wife's department lost numerous doctors for this specific issue. It is why the BMA has made such a big issue of it over the recent years.

Countdown

41,681 posts

202 months

Friday 10th March 2023
quotequote all
Gecko1978 said:
Capping energy is one thing but people need cash in there pockets to buy food, petrol, clothing etc. Freezing tax allowances and raising tax on higher earners is not going to help people spend now an boost the economy.

Even HS2 that giant money pit is being scalled back
It's not only "people spending" that boosts the economy, "Government spending" (funded by taxation) has the same effect. In fact arguably it has a greater effect because the Govt. doesn't stick it in a long term savings account or pension.

pghstochaj

2,469 posts

125 months

Friday 10th March 2023
quotequote all
Rufus Stone said:
Gecko1978 said:
Capping energy is one thing but people need cash in there pockets to buy food, petrol, clothing etc. Freezing tax allowances and raising tax on higher earners is not going to help people spend now an boost the economy.

Even HS2 that giant money pit is being scalled back
Are people not getting any pay rises?
The average pay rise is behind the inflation figure and with tax thresholds fixed, people are less well off even with good pay rises.

The £100k threshold on personal allowance means people have to overload their pension rather than taking out 40p of a pound (therefore have less usable money today). The fixing of the 40% tax rate threshold means that people have less money in their pocket compared to if the tax rate was increased in line with the value of money. Etc. etc.

anonymous-user

60 months

Friday 10th March 2023
quotequote all
pghstochaj said:
Gecko1978 said:
KingNothing said:
I'm sure people struggling with food, fuel and housing bills will be happy to know they'll soon be able to put more than £40k into their pension each year laugh
Also its not the reason many Dr's quit. IR35 banned Dr's working as a PSC so thoes close to retirement saw tax earnings go up about 30% when forced onto payroll with no expenses allowed (travell costs to another hospital). So they simply quit.

Happened across the UK again in 2020 but the government doesn't want to admit it aggressive tax is bringing in less as strangling growth
It had a huge impact, what are you talking about? My wife's department lost numerous doctors for this specific issue. It is why the BMA has made such a big issue of it over the recent years.
The fact the post goes on to say the bit above in bold means we can probably deduce the post is in agreement to yours and the word not is typo?

Ian Geary

4,701 posts

198 months

Friday 10th March 2023
quotequote all
Rufus Stone said:
Are people not getting any pay rises?
Public sector rises have generally been well under inflation (mine was 2.5% for 22-23) although the ones with a more powerful negotiating position have obviously used it.

Some private sector companies have been reported in the news as dishing out reasonable pay rises (ie supermarkets) but there is little data on it imo

But it would be political suicide for anyone to say "actually, most people can afford these rises, they just don't want to."

So instead the Guardian will root out some example of a single mum who has had to choose heating or eating, and ignore that for a lot of people, it will just mean cutting back on things like clothes.

As reported by the Mail: the majority of people surveyed are still planning an oversees holiday.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-11304895/...

So not quite at the point where "people don't have money in their pockets" as was suggested earlier in this thread.

No one wants to hear that of course, and it will be cold comfort for those who genuinely are up again it.

With a progressive tax system, the sensible thing to do now would be increase tax in the middle and top income levels, and direct more welfare support to those at the bottom.

But no one wants to hear that, either.

Or perhaps reduce taxes, so that the 1% who shield their wealth offshore can magically generate wealth for the UK, which will trickle down like a warm shower over all the UK's grateful poor.

If anyone believes that, they have obviously missed the last 40 years.





Rufus Stone

Original Poster:

7,698 posts

62 months

Friday 10th March 2023
quotequote all
pghstochaj said:
The average pay rise is behind the inflation figure and with tax thresholds fixed, people are less well off even with good pay rises.

The £100k threshold on personal allowance means people have to overload their pension rather than taking out 40p of a pound (therefore have less usable money today). The fixing of the 40% tax rate threshold means that people have less money in their pocket compared to if the tax rate was increased in line with the value of money. Etc. etc.
The Government loves fiscal drag, I hate it with a passion.

Biker 1

7,859 posts

125 months

Friday 10th March 2023
quotequote all
Rufus Stone said:
It has been rumoured that he will continue the current cap for further three months.
I watched a bit of the Martin Lewis show the other night featuring Grant Shapps. I thinks its a dead cert that the scheme will be extended.

Gecko1978

10,334 posts

163 months

Friday 10th March 2023
quotequote all
Rufus Stone said:
Gecko1978 said:
Capping energy is one thing but people need cash in there pockets to buy food, petrol, clothing etc. Freezing tax allowances and raising tax on higher earners is not going to help people spend now an boost the economy.

Even HS2 that giant money pit is being scalled back
Are people not getting any pay rises?
Well unless you get 10% plus then no

Gecko1978

10,334 posts

163 months

Friday 10th March 2023
quotequote all
sebdangerfield said:
pghstochaj said:
Gecko1978 said:
KingNothing said:
I'm sure people struggling with food, fuel and housing bills will be happy to know they'll soon be able to put more than £40k into their pension each year laugh
Also its not the reason many Dr's quit. IR35 banned Dr's working as a PSC so thoes close to retirement saw tax earnings go up about 30% when forced onto payroll with no expenses allowed (travell costs to another hospital). So they simply quit.

Happened across the UK again in 2020 but the government doesn't want to admit it aggressive tax is bringing in less as strangling growth
It had a huge impact, what are you talking about? My wife's department lost numerous doctors for this specific issue. It is why the BMA has made such a big issue of it over the recent years.
The fact the post goes on to say the bit above in bold means we can probably deduce the post is in agreement to yours and the word not is typo?
Yeah typo sorry should have read income/ earnings go down

Gecko1978

10,334 posts

163 months

Friday 10th March 2023
quotequote all
Countdown said:
Gecko1978 said:
Capping energy is one thing but people need cash in there pockets to buy food, petrol, clothing etc. Freezing tax allowances and raising tax on higher earners is not going to help people spend now an boost the economy.

Even HS2 that giant money pit is being scalled back
It's not only "people spending" that boosts the economy, "Government spending" (funded by taxation) has the same effect. In fact arguably it has a greater effect because the Govt. doesn't stick it in a long term savings account or pension.
You have to assume government spending is efficient v private spending. Also if input my mythical million in a savings account the bank uses that to fund lending and investment (it's why I get interest) that will allow houses to be bought, cars, business to be started etc and this will create jobs. Government spending can do the same but it doesn't have to be efficient as there is no investor to answer too