General Election July 2024

Author
Discussion

Rufus Stone

6,653 posts

59 months

Wednesday 26th June
quotequote all
pingu393 said:
I can only speak for myself, but I am pretty sure that I pay a lot less in tax now than I would be paying if nothing had changed since 2010.

Most of my tax reduction is due to the increase in the basic tax thresholds from £5720(NI) and £6475(Inc Tax) to £12570(both).

Tax and duty on spending are almost impossible to capture.
That's what they want you to think. tongue out

CivicDuties

5,256 posts

33 months

Wednesday 26th June
quotequote all
Speed 3 said:
Anyone with any basic economic understanding knows the UK economy is screwed and even if we took some very significant decisions (Trident/Triple Lock/Raising pension age again) taxes are only heading one way under any flavour of government. They only way not to is increasing overall tax take through GDP growth. That's not happening quickly whoever's in power. At least Labour are having more meaningful discussion with business about blockers to growth (Planning Restrictions / Labour market etc) than the others. Whether they can actually deliver any of it remains to be seen but I don't think anyone posting here is under any illusion that we can have a low tax near-term future if we want any semblance of public services or national infrastructure.
One easy thing could raise GDP by an estimated 4% annually, instantly. Rejoin the EU's SM and CU. LibDems and Greens propose to do this, I expect SNP and Plaid would too.

i4got

5,675 posts

81 months

Wednesday 26th June
quotequote all
CivicDuties said:
Speed 3 said:
Anyone with any basic economic understanding knows the UK economy is screwed and even if we took some very significant decisions (Trident/Triple Lock/Raising pension age again) taxes are only heading one way under any flavour of government. They only way not to is increasing overall tax take through GDP growth. That's not happening quickly whoever's in power. At least Labour are having more meaningful discussion with business about blockers to growth (Planning Restrictions / Labour market etc) than the others. Whether they can actually deliver any of it remains to be seen but I don't think anyone posting here is under any illusion that we can have a low tax near-term future if we want any semblance of public services or national infrastructure.
One easy thing could raise GDP by an estimated 4% annually, instantly. Rejoin the EU's SM and CU. LibDems and Greens propose to do this, I expect SNP and Plaid would too.
You're not taking the 4% projected long term hit and assuming it's an annual figure are you?


Mortarboard

6,244 posts

58 months

Wednesday 26th June
quotequote all
i4got said:
You're not taking the 4% projected long term hit and assuming it's an annual figure are you?
It was hit long ago, and still ongoing. It wasn't a once-off.

Brexit thread ----->

M.


pingu393

8,178 posts

208 months

Wednesday 26th June
quotequote all
Rufus Stone said:
pingu393 said:
I can only speak for myself, but I am pretty sure that I pay a lot less in tax now than I would be paying if nothing had changed since 2010.

Most of my tax reduction is due to the increase in the basic tax thresholds from £5720(NI) and £6475(Inc Tax) to £12570(both).

Tax and duty on spending are almost impossible to capture.
That's what they want you to think. tongue out
I don't think it is. There is never any mention of it. The Tories don't want to win, because they are fed up with bashing their heads against brick walls (mostly self-inflicted). Labour are like a mother who has forgotten the pain of childbirth and want more children.

i4got

5,675 posts

81 months

Wednesday 26th June
quotequote all
Mortarboard said:
Brexit thread ----->

M.
No thanks. I've ventured in there before and its depressing as hell.

JagLover

42,859 posts

238 months

Wednesday 26th June
quotequote all
i4got said:
No thanks. I've ventured in there before and its depressing as hell.
Like Japanese soldiers holed up in pacific islands in the 1950s?

CivicDuties

5,256 posts

33 months

Wednesday 26th June
quotequote all
Mortarboard said:
i4got said:
You're not taking the 4% projected long term hit and assuming it's an annual figure are you?
It was hit long ago, and still ongoing. It wasn't a once-off.

Brexit thread ----->

M.
It's pretty relevant to the General Election, I'd say. Or, at least, it should be, but Labour and Tory want to ignore it.

And it's not about Brexit. That's over, it happened. It's about what we can do to improve GDP, that's the point I was responding to. An easy way to do that is to join the SM and CU, and I intend to vote for a party which has that in its Manifesto.

Edited by CivicDuties on Wednesday 26th June 16:49

loafer123

15,512 posts

218 months

Wednesday 26th June
quotequote all
CivicDuties said:
It's pretty relevant to the General Election, I'd say. Or, at least, it should be, but Labour and Tory want to ignore it.

And it's not about Brexit. That's over, it happened. It's about what we can do to improve GDP, that's the point I was responding to. An easy way to do that is to join the SM and CU, and I intend to vote for a party which has that in its Manifesto.

Edited by CivicDuties on Wednesday 26th June 16:49
It’s really helping the performance of those leading EU economies. /s

captain_cynic

12,561 posts

98 months

Wednesday 26th June
quotequote all
loafer123 said:
CivicDuties said:
It's pretty relevant to the General Election, I'd say. Or, at least, it should be, but Labour and Tory want to ignore it.

And it's not about Brexit. That's over, it happened. It's about what we can do to improve GDP, that's the point I was responding to. An easy way to do that is to join the SM and CU, and I intend to vote for a party which has that in its Manifesto.

Edited by CivicDuties on Wednesday 26th June 16:49
It’s really helping the performance of those leading EU economies. /s
Still doing better than us.

Mortarboard

6,244 posts

58 months

Wednesday 26th June
quotequote all
And similar to the regular waffle in the brexit thread, how is the EU performance, good bad or indifferent, relevant to how the uk government is run?
Or justification for any actions the uk government makes?

M.

Vanden Saab

14,385 posts

77 months

Wednesday 26th June
quotequote all
Mortarboard said:
i4got said:
You're not taking the 4% projected long term hit and assuming it's an annual figure are you?
It was hit long ago, and still ongoing. It wasn't a once-off.

Brexit thread ----->

M.
biglaugh

Kermit power

28,980 posts

216 months

Wednesday 26th June
quotequote all
Who_Goes_Blue said:
I'm looking forward to all the excuses from our leftie commentators when invariable everything is just as st under labour
Without changes to our electoral system, it's pretty inevitable sadly.

Digga

40,645 posts

286 months

Wednesday 26th June
quotequote all
captain_cynic said:
loafer123 said:
CivicDuties said:
It's pretty relevant to the General Election, I'd say. Or, at least, it should be, but Labour and Tory want to ignore it.

And it's not about Brexit. That's over, it happened. It's about what we can do to improve GDP, that's the point I was responding to. An easy way to do that is to join the SM and CU, and I intend to vote for a party which has that in its Manifesto.

Edited by CivicDuties on Wednesday 26th June 16:49
It’s really helping the performance of those leading EU economies. /s
Still doing better than us.
It depends on what “better” means.

On certain GDP growth measures, manufacturing PMIs etc. then the UK is doing well. Now 4th largest exporter, for example.

If we look at roads, hospitals etc. etc. then we’re barely scraping our way into the OECD top ten.

turbobloke

104,861 posts

263 months

Wednesday 26th June
quotequote all
captain_cynic said:
loafer123 said:
CivicDuties said:
It's pretty relevant to the General Election, I'd say. Or, at least, it should be, but Labour and Tory want to ignore it.

And it's not about Brexit. That's over, it happened. It's about what we can do to improve GDP, that's the point I was responding to. An easy way to do that is to join the SM and CU, and I intend to vote for a party which has that in its Manifesto.

Edited by CivicDuties on Wednesday 26th June 16:49
It’s really helping the performance of those leading EU economies. /s
Still doing better than us.
Did the UK not top EU and USA for cumulative real GDP Growth in 2022 and 2023 (% change)? Can't find the actual cumulative real GDP numbers atm.

Mortarboard

6,244 posts

58 months

Wednesday 26th June
quotequote all
turbobloke said:
Did the UK not top EU and USA for cumulative real GDP Growth in 2022 and 2023 (% change)? Can't find the actual cumulative real GDP numbers atm.
Bigger drops mean bigger %age gains.

Like trimming yer pubes....


M.

emicen

8,618 posts

221 months

Wednesday 26th June
quotequote all
CivicDuties said:
Speed 3 said:
Anyone with any basic economic understanding knows the UK economy is screwed and even if we took some very significant decisions (Trident/Triple Lock/Raising pension age again) taxes are only heading one way under any flavour of government. They only way not to is increasing overall tax take through GDP growth. That's not happening quickly whoever's in power. At least Labour are having more meaningful discussion with business about blockers to growth (Planning Restrictions / Labour market etc) than the others. Whether they can actually deliver any of it remains to be seen but I don't think anyone posting here is under any illusion that we can have a low tax near-term future if we want any semblance of public services or national infrastructure.
One easy thing could raise GDP by an estimated 4% annually, instantly. Rejoin the EU's SM and CU. LibDems and Greens propose to do this, I expect SNP and Plaid would too.
SNP absolutely would not.

They want separation from England and full EU re-entry.

Rejoining in part wouldn’t suit their narrative so would be as obstructive as possible.

donkmeister

8,481 posts

103 months

Wednesday 26th June
quotequote all
blueg33 said:
Who_Goes_Blue said:
I'm looking forward to all the excuses from our leftie commentators when invariable everything is just as st under labour
They are all as bad as each other is a very lazy and rather lame statement

If labour get in, they won’t be issued with a magic wand, they have many years of mismanagement to sort out.
They both mess the country up, just in different ways and different motivations (neither of which is "do what is best for the people of Britain", unfortunately).

The trick is to switch before too much damage is done... Something we have failed at for decades.

fourstardan

4,553 posts

147 months

Wednesday 26th June
quotequote all
This is the state of this country a bunch of dipsts protesting outside.

I can't even hear what is being said tonight.

Legacywr

12,344 posts

191 months

Wednesday 26th June
quotequote all
fourstardan said:
This is the state of this country a bunch of dipsts protesting outside.

I can't even hear what is being said tonight.
I heard him say his dad was a toolmaker…