Junior Doctors' Pay Claim Poll

Poll: Junior Doctors' Pay Claim Poll

Total Members Polled: 1034

Full 35%: 11%
Over 30% but not 35%: 2%
From 20% to 29%: 6%
From 10% to 19%: 18%
From 5% to 9%: 41%
From 1% to 4%: 11%
Exactly 0%: 5%
Don't know / no opinion / another %: 6%
Author
Discussion

Evanivitch

20,736 posts

124 months

Sunday 9th June
quotequote all
loafer123 said:
Evanivitch said:
And is by no choice of GPs...
GP practices are mainly owned by senior GPs. Of course they want to maximise their profits.
dmsims said:
It most definitely is - follow the money.............

Evanivitch said:
And is by no choice of GPs...
Ignorance is bliss, eh lads?

PA are paid more than a junior doctor with equivalent training. If GPs could hire doctors with the same experience and equivalent training, then that would make "maximise profits", wouldn't it? So why can't they do that?

GPs (businesses with only one customer...) will not receive additional funding if they try to grow their practice through hiring more GPs. Instead they have to employ PA, paramedics, care coordinators etc to fund further patient-facing roles.

People complain they can't get an appointment at their GP.

6500 doctors couldn't get ST1 trainee roles because NHS has been told not to fund it.

Follow the money. Yeah, who's?

dmsims

6,603 posts

269 months

Sunday 9th June
quotequote all
People in glass houses.

I suggest you go away and spend some more time understanding how it all works.

Evanivitch said:
Ignorance is bliss, eh lads?

PA are paid more than a junior doctor with equivalent training. If GPs could hire doctors with the same experience and equivalent training, then that would make "maximise profits", wouldn't it? So why can't they do that?

GPs (businesses with only one customer...) will not receive additional funding if they try to grow their practice through hiring more GPs. Instead they have to employ PA, paramedics, care coordinators etc to fund further patient-facing roles.

People complain they can't get an appointment at their GP.

6500 doctors couldn't get ST1 trainee roles because NHS has been told not to fund it.

Follow the money. Yeah, who's?

Oliver Hardy

2,788 posts

76 months

Monday 10th June
quotequote all
PAs, nurses and paramedics could do a lot of the job GPs do now.

JagLover

42,847 posts

237 months

Monday 10th June
quotequote all
Evanivitch said:
Ignorance is bliss, eh lads?

PA are paid more than a junior doctor with equivalent training.
Last time I looked at the pay scales that was potentially the case for the first two years of employment only.

https://www.prospects.ac.uk/job-profiles/physician...

Evanivitch

20,736 posts

124 months

Monday 10th June
quotequote all
Oliver Hardy said:
PAs, nurses and paramedics could do a lot of the job GPs do now.
They certainly can, but we clearly have a huge back log in the GP system, we have an abundance of applicants that want to do the role, and yet it's government policy that is driving us down one solution, and not medical practice.

Evanivitch

20,736 posts

124 months

Monday 10th June
quotequote all
dmsims said:
People in glass houses.

I suggest you go away and spend some more time understanding how it all works.

oddman

2,423 posts

254 months

Monday 10th June
quotequote all
Oliver Hardy said:
PAs, nurses and paramedics could do a lot of the job GPs do now.
Undoubtedly. The trick is spotting which jobs.

They don't know what they don't know

spaximus

4,251 posts

255 months

Monday 10th June
quotequote all
The PA assistant type role is spreading throughout the NHS.
My Daughter has trained hard taken many exams and now has to help supervise Anasthetic Assistants who are administering anaesthetics with just two years training.
The last one did not know what an F1 would be expected to yet are allowed to do the role. As she says anyone can administer the drugs once they have worked out the amounts and taken full history themselves, the trick is keeping them asleep during the procedure and then waking them up.
What others have reported to the BMA is the AA’s are reluctant to ask for help and then a fully qualified Dr has to fix their mess.
This is all cost savings to allow people not good enough to become a qualified Dr to try to fill gaps. How it is in th UK is not how it is in the US where PA’s are wanting to become DR’s and this role allows them to work toward it

Oliver Hardy

2,788 posts

76 months

Monday 10th June
quotequote all
oddman said:
Oliver Hardy said:
PAs, nurses and paramedics could do a lot of the job GPs do now.
Undoubtedly. The trick is spotting which jobs.

They don't know what they don't know
True, but I have been to the GP quite a few times over my life time, I really don't think I ever really needed to see a Doctor though. If a paramedic/nurse doesn't know they can always refer to a doctor, as happens now if you call an ambulance or go to A&E

272BHP

5,302 posts

238 months

Monday 10th June
quotequote all
Oliver Hardy said:
PAs, nurses and paramedics could do a lot of the job GPs do now.
It still smarts that it was difficult to see a GP during Covid as doctors were too busy pocketing £12 per jab instead.

A job that you could train anyone off the street to do in 10 minutes.

AstonZagato

12,799 posts

212 months

Monday 10th June
quotequote all
spaximus said:
...Snip...

As she says anyone can administer the drugs once they have worked out the amounts and taken full history themselves, the trick is keeping them asleep during the procedure and then waking them up.
A friend is a consultant anaesthetist. He was asked by a private patient to discount his fee on an operation. He said, "Sure. I do three jobs. Putting you to sleep. Keeping you asleep and waking you up. Which one do you want me to miss out?"
The patient paid his full fee.

Evanivitch

20,736 posts

124 months

Monday 10th June
quotequote all
272BHP said:
It still smarts that it was difficult to see a GP during Covid as doctors were too busy pocketing £12 per jab instead.

A job that you could train anyone off the street to do in 10 minutes.
Did I dream about the massive vaccine centres in every town?

pavarotti1980

5,113 posts

86 months

Monday 10th June
quotequote all
Evanivitch said:
Did I dream about the massive vaccine centres in every town?
You must have yeah

NWTony

2,857 posts

230 months

Tuesday 11th June
quotequote all
AstonZagato said:
A friend is a consultant anaesthetist. He was asked by a private patient to discount his fee on an operation. He said, "Sure. I do three jobs. Putting you to sleep. Keeping you asleep and waking you up. Which one do you want me to miss out?"
The patient paid his full fee.
A friend of mine is a taxi driver and a passenger wanted a discount on a trip to the airport, he said "Sure, I do three jobs, I pick you up, I drive you there and then I drop you off, which one do you want me to miss out?" He paid the full fair!!

272BHP

5,302 posts

238 months

Tuesday 11th June
quotequote all
pavarotti1980 said:
Evanivitch said:
Did I dream about the massive vaccine centres in every town?
You must have yeah
Lots of GPs were doing the jabs as well, this is well known.

pavarotti1980

5,113 posts

86 months

Tuesday 11th June
quotequote all
272BHP said:
Lots of GPs were doing the jabs as well, this is well known.
That and community pharmacists were doing huge amounts of them. It obviously wasnt well known to the poster who thinks only vaccination centres were the only route to a jab

djc206

12,502 posts

127 months

Tuesday 11th June
quotequote all
272BHP said:
pavarotti1980 said:
Evanivitch said:
Did I dream about the massive vaccine centres in every town?
You must have yeah
Lots of GPs were doing the jabs as well, this is well known.
My GP surgery was but they got the cheaper staff to do the actual jabbing if memory serves. They were funny about face to face appointments but I reckon getting a telephone or FaceTime appointment became a lot easier. Forcing GP’s to adopt technology and offer remote consultations was one of the few benefits of Covid.

dbdb

4,356 posts

175 months

Friday 21st June
quotequote all
I suspect there will be a lot of strikes in the public sector after the election.

Vanden Saab

14,365 posts

76 months

Friday 21st June
quotequote all
dbdb said:
I suspect there will be a lot of strikes in the public sector after the election.
No doubt Labour have public sector pay cave-ins as a 'fully costed' part of their manifesto.