Can Sir Keir Starmer revive the Labour Party? (Vol. 2)

Can Sir Keir Starmer revive the Labour Party? (Vol. 2)

Author
Discussion

carlo996

6,581 posts

24 months

Wednesday 6th March
quotequote all
President Merkin said:
Oh Carlo, you are just so credible. party
And you are so blinkered. I cannot wait until the enormous tax hikes and misery in the coming years and to see how you will try and spin this as progress. It's inevitable, just like Brexit was, that's what happens when you let daft people make big decisions when they aren't able to separate emotions and reality wink

119

7,644 posts

39 months

Wednesday 6th March
quotequote all
Christ, the Labour love in in this thread is fking hilarious!

Blue62

9,126 posts

155 months

Wednesday 6th March
quotequote all
carlo996 said:
When Labour left office in May 2010, unemployment had risen by 23%.It was running at 8%.

Utopia.
You stated that unemployment was 23% in 2010, now you’re saying it had risen by that figure but provided no timeline. Do you think everyone is as stupid as you are?

chrispmartha

15,891 posts

132 months

Wednesday 6th March
quotequote all
carlo996 said:
Blue62 said:
The rate was just under 8% in 2010, as the GFC had rocked economies across the developed world. The rate for 16-24 year olds rose to 22% by the end of 2011, a year or more after the coalition took power.

I know we are all make mistakes, but we are either dealing with a moron or an outright liar, not sure which.
When Labour left office in May 2010, unemployment had risen by 23%.It was running at 8%.

Utopia.
That’s not what you claimed though is it.

carlo996

6,581 posts

24 months

Wednesday 6th March
quotequote all
chrispmartha said:
carlo996 said:
Blue62 said:
The rate was just under 8% in 2010, as the GFC had rocked economies across the developed world. The rate for 16-24 year olds rose to 22% by the end of 2011, a year or more after the coalition took power.

I know we are all make mistakes, but we are either dealing with a moron or an outright liar, not sure which.
When Labour left office in May 2010, unemployment had risen by 23%.It was running at 8%.

Utopia.
That’s not what you claimed though is it.
Yes, it was a misquote, but the info is valid. Sorry, we are all make mistakes.

carlo996

6,581 posts

24 months

Wednesday 6th March
quotequote all
Blue62 said:
You stated that unemployment was 23% in 2010, now you’re saying it had risen by that figure but provided no timeline. Do you think everyone is as stupid as you are?
Ah the personal insults begin. Always good to understand a level.

It was 8%, so slightly more than it is now. Do you accept that, or was this something else we can blame the Conservatives for?

chrispmartha

15,891 posts

132 months

Wednesday 6th March
quotequote all
carlo996 said:
chrispmartha said:
carlo996 said:
Blue62 said:
The rate was just under 8% in 2010, as the GFC had rocked economies across the developed world. The rate for 16-24 year olds rose to 22% by the end of 2011, a year or more after the coalition took power.

I know we are all make mistakes, but we are either dealing with a moron or an outright liar, not sure which.
When Labour left office in May 2010, unemployment had risen by 23%.It was running at 8%.

Utopia.
That’s not what you claimed though is it.
Yes, it was a misquote, but the info is valid. Sorry, we are all make mistakes.
It’s ok giving a percentage rise but you need to give a timeline otherwise it’s meaningless

chrispmartha

15,891 posts

132 months

Wednesday 6th March
quotequote all
https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/countri...



Heres the figures and a nice little graph for you.

You’ll notice a big spike around 2008-2010.

Wonder why that would be?

You might also notice it was at its highest when the tories were in power.

NomduJour

19,289 posts

262 months

Wednesday 6th March
quotequote all
How many Keith fans genuinely think they’ll be better off under his government? Something has to give. (Not a tacit approval of the current lot).


chrispmartha

15,891 posts

132 months

Wednesday 6th March
quotequote all
NomduJour said:
How many Keith fans genuinely think they’ll be better off under his government? Something has to give. (Not a tacit approval of the current lot).
Keith?

Anyway personally I probably won’t be better off (if you are talking money wise) but then again it’s not really all about me is it, we need the country to be better off.

Wether Labour will do that i don’t know, but I and a lot of other people can see that the tories aren’t making thr country better

President Merkin

3,981 posts

22 months

Wednesday 6th March
quotequote all
carlo996 said:
And you are so blinkered. I cannot wait until the enormous tax hikes and misery in the coming years and to see how you will try and spin this as progress. It's inevitable, just like Brexit was, that's what happens when you let daft people make big decisions when they aren't able to separate emotions and reality wink
This is all very interesting but only in the context that you punted a made up lie & are now trying to wriggle out of it as a ahem, 'misquote'.

Bit rich banging on about reality when it's demonstrably just an abstract concept to you.

Edited by President Merkin on Wednesday 6th March 11:03

Blue62

9,126 posts

155 months

Wednesday 6th March
quotequote all
chrispmartha said:
https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/countri...



Heres the figures and a nice little graph for you.

You’ll notice a big spike around 2008-2010.

Wonder why that would be?

You might also notice it was at its highest when the tories were in power.
I don’t think this particular individual wants to be educated in anything, he’ll probably come back with another senseless retort but he’s laid himself bare again. Odd that you’d want to continue really.

carlo996

6,581 posts

24 months

Wednesday 6th March
quotequote all
chrispmartha said:
https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/countri...



Heres the figures and a nice little graph for you.

You’ll notice a big spike around 2008-2010.

Wonder why that would be?

You might also notice it was at its highest when the tories were in power.
Yep. And you know why that happened yes?

NomduJour

19,289 posts

262 months

Wednesday 6th March
quotequote all
chrispmartha said:
Anyway personally I probably won’t be better off (if you are talking money wise) but then again it’s not really all about me is it, we need the country to be better off
Who is it about, then? Everyone knows who won’t be worse off.

chrispmartha

15,891 posts

132 months

Wednesday 6th March
quotequote all
carlo996 said:
chrispmartha said:
https://www.macrotrends.net/global-metrics/countri...



Heres the figures and a nice little graph for you.

You’ll notice a big spike around 2008-2010.

Wonder why that would be?

You might also notice it was at its highest when the tories were in power.
Yep. And you know why that happened yes?
Im just trying to get your timeline of the 23% figure.

And I know you will obviously have an excuse for the high tory figure but discount the one for the Labour figure.

BigMon

4,439 posts

132 months

Wednesday 6th March
quotequote all
carlo996 said:
yes
Neither Labour or Conservative are great options. A case of picking the least worse or making a protest vote which does absolutely nothing in reality.
Exactly.

It is giving me a small measure of amusement watching a few posters on this thread who have surgically implanted blue contact lenses gibbering frenziedly and nonsensically as the scale of the potential Tory election battering unfolds.

However that is more than offset by the depression of the paucity of political talent available of any colour and the realisation that whoever gets in will, in all likelihood, not make a jot of difference to the pothole lined bumpy road ahead.

chrispmartha

15,891 posts

132 months

Wednesday 6th March
quotequote all
NomduJour said:
chrispmartha said:
Anyway personally I probably won’t be better off (if you are talking money wise) but then again it’s not really all about me is it, we need the country to be better off
Who is it about, then? Everyone knows who won’t be worse off.
It’s about everyone, not my personal finances.

It might be a better place if people dropped the im alright jack attitude.

carlo996

6,581 posts

24 months

Wednesday 6th March
quotequote all
chrispmartha said:
It’s about everyone, not my personal finances.

It might be a better place if people dropped the im alright jack attitude.
A classic piece of socialist bingo biggrin

How far would you personally go, for the 'greater good'. I'd suggest about the same as the rest of us?

NomduJour

19,289 posts

262 months

Wednesday 6th March
quotequote all
chrispmartha said:
It’s about everyone, not my personal finances.

It might be a better place if people dropped the im alright jack attitude
Yeah. How much more tax would you like to pay? Another 2%? Another 20%? Are you happy to be poorer if your money helps others not be?

chrispmartha

15,891 posts

132 months

Wednesday 6th March
quotequote all
NomduJour said:
chrispmartha said:
It’s about everyone, not my personal finances.

It might be a better place if people dropped the im alright jack attitude
Yeah. How much more tax would you like to pay? Another 2%? Another 20%? Are you happy to be poorer if your money helps others not be?
I think the tax system probably needs reform, what it doesn’t need is a 2% cut to NI which will make the square root of bugger all difference to the people who actually could do with the extra money