Can Sir Keir Starmer revive the Labour Party? (Vol. 2)

Can Sir Keir Starmer revive the Labour Party? (Vol. 2)

Author
Discussion

valiant

10,717 posts

163 months

Monday 4th March
quotequote all
carlo996 said:
Labour have already started. Hiking taxes for private schools and undermining apprenticeships to fund their new plans. It's standard Labour TBH, this is why most of their councils are fked already....
Councils are fked because funding has not kept pace with costs and the provision of adult and children’s social care has gone through the roof. It’s why ALL councils regardless of what rosette is running it is suffering.

Again it’s a central government caused issue that councils across the land are trying to grapple with.

It’s funny how everything comes back to our inept government isn’t it? But you carry on voting blue as you’re too frightened to do anything else…

julian987R

6,840 posts

62 months

Monday 4th March
quotequote all
carlo996 said:
Labour have already started. Hiking taxes for private schools and undermining apprenticeships to fund their new plans. It's standard Labour TBH, this is why most of their councils are fked already....
The public seem to love it, they could afford to triple taxes for private schools it would actually improve their polling.
As to apprenticeships, make the opportunities even harder = win win, apparently, going by the ‘unbiassed’ polling.

valiant

10,717 posts

163 months

Monday 4th March
quotequote all
Garvin said:
The simple fact is the Conservatives will be swept out of power at the GE, I cannot believe anybody can really think otherwise. However, what will replace them will, in all probability, be no better and quite possibly worse. It really is that simple.

Those rooting for the ‘Tories’ to be eviscerated and replaced by something better are as deluded as those hoping against hope that the Conservatives have a chance of being re-elected.

Now, has Starmer revived the the Labour Party, absolutely not - he’s done fk all which is why we are all going to be horribly pissed off.
I think there’s an element of “they need time in the wilderness” in order to find themselves again.

The Tories have lost their way, of that there is no doubt. They have poor leadership and a poor pool of possible replacements for him. Whatever happens to Rishi, it will be more of the same and the people are tired of it.

I think that even Tory voters what a change and a few years of introspection and rebuilding is no bad thing where they can come back reinvented and reinvigorated and ready for government once again.

Labour won’t do too much damage as the damage has already been done. Public services are all broken and we are generally rudderless at the moment so why not let them have a go? They won’t be able to fix everything and nor should we expect them to. No one is expecting unicorns and rainbows come the Labour victory but a period of calm and hopefully the laying of foundations of better public services all whilst the Tories go away, have their inevitable civil war and then come back stronger in four years time.

julian987R

6,840 posts

62 months

Monday 4th March
quotequote all
valiant said:
No one is expecting unicorns and rainbows come the Labour victory
With the general stupidity of the nation, I think you will find people are expecting unicorns and rainbows.

Garvin

5,259 posts

180 months

Monday 4th March
quotequote all
valiant said:
Garvin said:
The simple fact is the Conservatives will be swept out of power at the GE, I cannot believe anybody can really think otherwise. However, what will replace them will, in all probability, be no better and quite possibly worse. It really is that simple.

Those rooting for the ‘Tories’ to be eviscerated and replaced by something better are as deluded as those hoping against hope that the Conservatives have a chance of being re-elected.

Now, has Starmer revived the the Labour Party, absolutely not - he’s done fk all which is why we are all going to be horribly pissed off.
I think there’s an element of “they need time in the wilderness” in order to find themselves again.

The Tories have lost their way, of that there is no doubt. They have poor leadership and a poor pool of possible replacements for him. Whatever happens to Rishi, it will be more of the same and the people are tired of it.

I think that even Tory voters what a change and a few years of introspection and rebuilding is no bad thing where they can come back reinvented and reinvigorated and ready for government once again.

Labour won’t do too much damage as the damage has already been done. Public services are all broken and we are generally rudderless at the moment so why not let them have a go? They won’t be able to fix everything and nor should we expect them to. No one is expecting unicorns and rainbows come the Labour victory but a period of calm and hopefully the laying of foundations of better public services all whilst the Tories go away, have their inevitable civil war and then come back stronger in four years time.
In the main, nothing to disagree with here . . . except the final paragraph. “Labour won’t do too much damage” - this where we disagree. Labour did plenty of damage when elected with a healthy economy, what they will do with an economy that is not in good health is, how can I put this, concerning.

borcy

3,459 posts

59 months

Monday 4th March
quotequote all
julian987R said:
At this stage I a convinced Labour could increase taxes massively, triple the cost of living, spend the entire gold reserves on helping Gaza, ban petrol, redefine by law what a woman is, harbour terrorists and reopen unlimited immigration and the country would still vote them in......unless, unless, anyone else get this feeling, that the approach to the polls are just so wildly biassed to the left.
What if it turns out the polls are true?

Wombat3

12,433 posts

209 months

Monday 4th March
quotequote all
valiant said:
carlo996 said:
Labour have already started. Hiking taxes for private schools and undermining apprenticeships to fund their new plans. It's standard Labour TBH, this is why most of their councils are fked already....
Councils are fked because funding has not kept pace with costs and the provision of adult and children’s social care has gone through the roof. It’s why ALL councils regardless of what rosette is running it is suffering.

Again it’s a central government caused issue that councils across the land are trying to grapple with.

It’s funny how everything comes back to our inept government isn’t it? But you carry on voting blue as you’re too frightened to do anything else…
A central government that's raising more taxes than ever and still running a massive deficit as well.

What exactly do you think Starmer & co are going to be able to do to overcome that that's going to make everything so much better?

carlo996

6,574 posts

24 months

Monday 4th March
quotequote all
valiant said:
Councils are fked because funding has not kept pace with costs and the provision of adult and children’s social care has gone through the roof. It’s why ALL councils regardless of what rosette is running it is suffering.

Again it’s a central government caused issue that councils across the land are trying to grapple with.

It’s funny how everything comes back to our inept government isn’t it? But you carry on voting blue as you’re too frightened to do anything else…
No, you need to look at how Labour decided to govern them, Weirdly the anomaly was one Corbynomics council.

carlo996

6,574 posts

24 months

Monday 4th March
quotequote all
Garvin said:
The simple fact is the Conservatives will be swept out of power at the GE, I cannot believe anybody can really think otherwise. However, what will replace them will, in all probability, be no better and quite possibly worse. It really is that simple.

Those rooting for the ‘Tories’ to be eviscerated and replaced by something better are as deluded as those hoping against hope that the Conservatives have a chance of being re-elected.

Now, has Starmer revived the the Labour Party, absolutely not - he’s done fk all which is why we are all going to be horribly pissed off.
Exactly right.

julian987R

6,840 posts

62 months

Monday 4th March
quotequote all
borcy said:
julian987R said:
At this stage I a convinced Labour could increase taxes massively, triple the cost of living, spend the entire gold reserves on helping Gaza, ban petrol, redefine by law what a woman is, harbour terrorists and reopen unlimited immigration and the country would still vote them in......unless, unless, anyone else get this feeling, that the approach to the polls are just so wildly biassed to the left.
What if it turns out the polls are true?
Well, it’s then four years of a race baiting Home Secretary yelling on BBC every day. What joy.

borcy

3,459 posts

59 months

Monday 4th March
quotequote all
julian987R said:
borcy said:
julian987R said:
At this stage I a convinced Labour could increase taxes massively, triple the cost of living, spend the entire gold reserves on helping Gaza, ban petrol, redefine by law what a woman is, harbour terrorists and reopen unlimited immigration and the country would still vote them in......unless, unless, anyone else get this feeling, that the approach to the polls are just so wildly biassed to the left.
What if it turns out the polls are true?
Well, it’s then four years of a race baiting Home Secretary yelling on BBC every day. What joy.
You can always change channels smile

Seasonal Hero

7,954 posts

55 months

Monday 4th March
quotequote all
julian987R said:
Both, why not.
It would be nice if you could maintain the thread of your own argument.

julian987R

6,840 posts

62 months

Monday 4th March
quotequote all
borcy said:
You can always change channels smile
Look at how the MSM fawn over Labour as it is!!! Imagine when they are in power... every MSM channel will be a Labour political party broadcast 24/7.

NomduJour

19,261 posts

262 months

Monday 4th March
quotequote all
Wombat3 said:
A central government that's raising more taxes than ever and still running a massive deficit as well.

What exactly do you think Starmer & co are going to be able to do to overcome that that's going to make everything so much better?
How broad are your shoulders?




Wombat3

12,433 posts

209 months

Monday 4th March
quotequote all
NomduJour said:
Wombat3 said:
A central government that's raising more taxes than ever and still running a massive deficit as well.

What exactly do you think Starmer & co are going to be able to do to overcome that that's going to make everything so much better?
How broad are your shoulders?
A question that's going to be asked of everyone (whether they realise its happening or not)

anonymoususer

6,227 posts

51 months

Monday 4th March
quotequote all
I'm not looking forward to the visits we will receive from / on behalf of candidates when the election has been called.

NomduJour

19,261 posts

262 months

Monday 4th March
quotequote all
I’m sure everyone will be very willing to dig deeper for the greater good - people have had enough of Tory austerity.

julian987R

6,840 posts

62 months

Monday 4th March
quotequote all
NomduJour said:
I’m sure everyone will be very willing to dig deeper for the greater good - people have had enough of Tory austerity.
isn't that an oxymoron?

Wombat3

12,433 posts

209 months

Monday 4th March
quotequote all
julian987R said:
NomduJour said:
I’m sure everyone will be very willing to dig deeper for the greater good - people have had enough of Tory austerity.
isn't that an oxymoron?
No, just Anonuser in disguise smile

NomduJour

19,261 posts

262 months

Monday 4th March
quotequote all
If people want better public services, and public spending is at an all-time high, it stands to reason that they’ll be more than happy to pay more. Unless Keith and Rach can think of some other things to spend the non-dom non-money on?