Black Swan

[davepoth]

Anybody seen this? I thought it was jolly good.

[Chapppers]

I've just finished watching it. I absolutely loved it but then I reaaaallllyy like Natalie Portman. A lot.

[anonymous-user]

Anyone else struggling to tell the difference between Portman and Knightley these days??

(have they ever been seen in the same room together??)

(wow, imagine having to make THAT choice, what a toughie........ ;-)


Portman:



Knightley:

Edited by anonymous-user on Wednesday 12th January 23:01

[Chapppers]

Portman every time, she's just...more interesting somehow.

[Slagathore]

I've only seen one short clip of this film.

Definitely made me want to watch the rest of the film

Although, I have to say - Mila Kunis is better than both posted above.

[varsas]

Really looking forward to this. Big Arronofsky, Mansell (does amazing soundtracks), Portman and, after watching the esquire 'women we love' vid on you tube, Kunis fan.

Darren Arronofsky's other films are worth checking out, especially The Wrestler (from what I understand it has similarities to Black Swan), The Fountain and Requiem for a Dream (both a bit more esoteric, both with stunning soundtracks by Clint Mansell).

[qube_TA]

I enjoyed it but thought it should have been longer to allow for more of a back-story on the characters. There was so much ballet in it there wasn't much time for anything else.

Looked fantastic though.

[Uriel]

I loved it. Then I read a few online discussions about it, picked up on bits and pieces that I missed the first time.

Saw it again with that in mind and liked it even more, though now I have about 3 different interpretations/theories on what exactly is going on throughout the film.

[Nom de ploom]

that is arguably the worst ever picture of portman....she looks more like Hilary swank

but I think she'd just edge it over KN, who still looks like she needs a good meal...but a toughie...cud be a thread idea...a babe style death match...hmmmm

[audidoody]

I dunno. I preferred her in "Leon".

[MATTP77]

Film was ok, i may have overlooked the storyline with the constant obsession with Natalie and Mila kunis....

Dreamy eyes on Mila K..!

But yeah, a good film i thought. the dream/halucination Natalie Portman had was AMAZING. that is all

[Nom de ploom]

audidoody said:

I dunno. I preferred her in "Leon".

wasn't she 13 in that????

care to revise your statement?

[TankRizzo]

Nom de ploom said:

audidoody said:

I dunno. I preferred her in "Leon".

wasn't she 13 in that????

care to revise your statement?

Whoosh?

[davepoth]

One problem I had was Peter Griffin saying "Shut up Meg" in my ear every time Mila Kunis was speaking.

[MacW]

Max_Torque said:

Anyone else struggling to tell the difference between Portman and Knightley these days??

(have they ever been seen in the same room together??)

(wow, imagine having to make THAT choice, what a toughie........ ;-)


Portman:



Knightley:

Edited by Max_Torque on Wednesday 12th January 23:01

I'm assuming you did that to illustrate your point?

[Dr Jekyll]

Max_Torque said:

(

wow, imagine having to make THAT choice, what a toughie........ ;-)

As a well known writer said to a slightly different question.

"Like asking a man dying in the desert whether he'd prefer Malvern or Perrier"

[DevilYellowCV8]

Kiera Knightly played the part of Padme's (Natalie Portman) 'decoy' in 'SW:The Phantom Menace' An obscure bit of info there..

[Skywalker]

DevilYellowCV8 said:

Kiera Knightly played the part of Padme's (Natalie Portman) 'decoy' in 'SW:The Phantom Menace' An obscure bit of info there..

I never knew that. Thankee.