Nightsleeper

Author
Discussion

MXRod

Original Poster:

2,800 posts

154 months

Monday 16th September
quotequote all
BBC started Sunday 6 Episodes
Totally implausible , more holes than a Swiss cheese

Kamov

345 posts

18 months

Monday 16th September
quotequote all
Absolutely daft, insane, non sensical...............................................

I loved it.

cerb4.5lee

33,619 posts

187 months

Monday 16th September
quotequote all
We enjoyed it as well.

MitchT

16,230 posts

216 months

Monday 16th September
quotequote all
Tried to watch it but couldn't work out what on earth was going on. Nothing seemed to join up or make any sense.

mick987

1,458 posts

117 months

Monday 16th September
quotequote all

As someone said totally mental but I loved it.

mooseracer

2,114 posts

177 months

Monday 16th September
quotequote all
Biggest issue (amongst many) for me was the acting/casting of the head of whatever gchq type thing it is. Totally and utterly unbelievable. So, obviously, I'll be watching the rest.

Jordie Barretts sock

6,018 posts

26 months

Monday 16th September
quotequote all
Radio 2 trailering this heavily. Sounds awful from the clips.

Guess being on iplayer only is the BBC equivalent of a film going straight to DVD? laugh

Think I'll pass.

Old Man Peabody

622 posts

214 months

Monday 16th September
quotequote all
It's full of 'they would never do that', 'why are they doing that' moments, but it's strangely compelling...

First 2 episodes watched, will persevere for a bit....


cuprabob

15,704 posts

221 months

Monday 16th September
quotequote all
Jordie Barretts sock said:
Guess being on iplayer only is the BBC equivalent of a film going straight to DVD? laugh
It's not iPlayer only, it's airing on BBC1 Sunday & Monday at 9pm,



Kamov

345 posts

18 months

Monday 16th September
quotequote all
Yep to expand, wife was working on lap top, stuck this on, thought the whole approach, camera work, script, sort of comedy sort of serious, was akin to watching bi polar, kept loudly saying 'this is terrible' to my wife in the other room.
It ended after one nonsensical thing to the next with an air of Cbeebies Balamory to it and me exclaiming loudly one final time 'that was absolutely awful' to my wife who wasn't really listening to me, and 'i can't wait for the next one'.

Which i can't.... the formula for so bad its good is a fine Art, it should not be underestimated the skill level to pull it off, Tom Cruise is the Picasso of this.
I feel that the makers of this are fully aware of what they are doing and would smugly brush off any critique as people not having the brain to get the little nuances, 'that was the point, idiot'
A bit like how saying Banksy is actually a bit st somehow makes you the idiot...

(in case of any offence to any words I am an Artist and have bi polar)

Edited by Kamov on Monday 16th September 14:37

Sheepshanks

35,033 posts

126 months

Monday 16th September
quotequote all
I'm amazed a train operator let them film it - it will give some nervous travellers nightmares!

57Ford

4,529 posts

141 months

Monday 16th September
quotequote all
We watched the first episode last night. As said above, some fairly unbelievable stuff but we are hooked. We’re going to try to watch it as it goes out on tv rather than on iPlayer.

Hadn’t spotted that it was filmed in real-time and not entirely sure what that means but is it all a single take with multiple cameras? If so, it was quite good in that regard.

Jordie Barretts sock

6,018 posts

26 months

Monday 16th September
quotequote all
cuprabob said:
Jordie Barretts sock said:
Guess being on iplayer only is the BBC equivalent of a film going straight to DVD? laugh
It's not iPlayer only, it's airing on BBC1 Sunday & Monday at 9pm,
Oh Lord! biggrin

Vizsla

1,057 posts

131 months

Monday 16th September
quotequote all
Sheepshanks said:
I'm amazed a train operator let them film it - it will give some nervous travellers nightmares!
All the 'in train' action is apparently done in a studio set with back projection of the moving scenery.

Vizsla

1,057 posts

131 months

Monday 16th September
quotequote all
mooseracer said:
Biggest issue (amongst many) for me was the acting/casting of the head of whatever gchq type thing it is. Totally and utterly unbelievable. So, obviously, I'll be watching the rest.
+1

Female lead has zero credibility or gravitas for that role, the copper is a bit wet, and back at HQ they have a 12 year old nerd doing the techie bits. The archetypal cut-out Scots drunk is woeful and the train conductor seems to be speaking Bulgarian a lot of the time. laugh

And what is James Cosmo doing in this train crash mess (apart from paying his mortgage?

So am-dram that it must be a tongue-in-cheek parody (isn't it?). I'll deffo be watching tonight!

cuprabob

15,704 posts

221 months

Monday 16th September
quotequote all
Vizsla said:
And what is James Cosmo doing in this train crash mess (apart from paying his mortgage?
He must need the money because I saw him recently in an ITV drama called Six Four which also was a bit below him.

It's good that some of the River City cast offs have got another gig along with Boaby from The Clansman who is the train driver. I'm half expecting Jack & Victor to make an appearance smile

Bluevanman

7,882 posts

200 months

Monday 16th September
quotequote all
57Ford said:
We watched the first episode last night. As said above, some fairly unbelievable stuff but we are hooked. We’re going to try to watch it as it goes out on tv rather than on iPlayer.

Hadn’t spotted that it was filmed in real-time and not entirely sure what that means but is it all a single take with multiple cameras? If so, it was quite good in that regard.
I thought the real time referred to it being 6 hourly episodes for a journey that takes 6 hours,no jumping back in time,that sort of thing.
Going off the reviews on here it sounds like I'll absolutely hate it lol

Sheepshanks

35,033 posts

126 months

Monday 16th September
quotequote all
Vizsla said:
Sheepshanks said:
I'm amazed a train operator let them film it - it will give some nervous travellers nightmares!
All the 'in train' action is apparently done in a studio set with back projection of the moving scenery.
Sure, but there was quite a bit of external train and platform stuff.

DoctorX

7,541 posts

174 months

Monday 16th September
quotequote all
Given that they’re on the west coast mainline, they could of course just cut the power to the overhead lines hehe

That was a class 397 electric on the front nerd

Kamov

345 posts

18 months

Monday 16th September
quotequote all
Sheepshanks said:
I'm amazed a train operator let them film it - it will give some nervous travellers nightmares!
Anyone who watches this, and is nervous of travelling on a train, shouldn't be allowed out unchaperoned anyway, IMO.
It's bat st mental, it would be like never going on a bus because of the film Speed, or never flying because of Cast Away and not because of 9/11.

If anything it showed that these expensive Marxist train drivers don't really do anything but moan about how little they get paid for doing nothing.
Can you imagine pressing a button then sitting back for 2 to 6 hours just thinking about how you should be paid more for it... i guess when they go on strike its the most work they ever do.

Edited by Kamov on Monday 16th September 19:35


Edited by Kamov on Monday 16th September 19:36