CATs for 2009 - I'm confused?

CATs for 2009 - I'm confused?

Author
Discussion

shortshift

Original Poster:

133 posts

214 months

Sunday 8th February 2009
quotequote all
Now that the MSA have decreed that everyone with a post 2000 car must have a CAT fitted for 2009 I've been looking at CAT's on tinternet and I'm totally confused. Do I get a 200 cpi or a 100 cpi? Are there any restrictions on cpi? I'm racing a Westfield 1.8 zetec in the Westfield championship and possibly one or two rounds of the magnificent 7's. Does anyone have any idea of which CAT I should fit?

RogueMotorsport

246 posts

193 months

Monday 9th February 2009
quotequote all
Although the regulations say that a cat must be fitted, it doesn't say where. Mine's going in the passenger footwell.

wink

Graham

16,368 posts

289 months

Monday 9th February 2009
quotequote all
RogueMotorsport said:
Although the regulations say that a cat must be fitted, it doesn't say where. Mine's going in the passenger footwell.

wink
im sure they'll cotton on at some point... but i dont know how they are going to police it a total waste of time... most of the cats will be ruined within a lap, so quite how mining and wasting heavy metals and then burning them up in a race car exhaust is good for the environment i dont know !!!


something better would have been a recycling program for oil and tyres...

What do you do with a car on carbs... how is that going to work....

strangely my new car is built on an existing chassis from 31 dec 1999...

trophies

237 posts

197 months

Tuesday 10th February 2009
quotequote all
Cat in the footwell!! Love it haha

Lew

456lbft

321 posts

232 months

Tuesday 10th February 2009
quotequote all
Rules are that it must be fitted in the exhaust, and scrutes need to be able to see that it is there by way of an inspection hole. 100 cells per square inch offer less restriction and more power. There are quite a few cheap ones on the market now, make sure whatever you use has a metallic core, ceramic ones although much cheaper will break up. You don't need an FIA approved cat for UK, only for international events. So far the MSA has no way of measuring catalytic efficiency AFAIK, so it doesn't really matter if it is off an old road car or whatever, just make sure it is not melted internally or blocked in any way. Don't be tempted to put one on behind the silencer or any stuffing that comes out of the silencer will block the cat, which could damage your engine.

Edited by 456lbft on Tuesday 10th February 17:55

Barrie C

3 posts

186 months

Friday 13th March 2009
quotequote all
Went to the NEC this year to find out about catalytic converters. The size of Cat depends on your engine capacity to cope with air throughput. Found Piper Exhausts (Cams) to be the chepeast, prices varied from about £150 to £500, nothing fancy, not stainless or chromed. Tell them the engine size and they will tell you whether you need the 100 or 200.
Location of the Cat will I think be a contentious issue this season and I think we will see clarification in next years Blue Book.
Barrie...

shortshift

Original Poster:

133 posts

214 months

Sunday 15th March 2009
quotequote all
456lbft said:
Rules are that it must be fitted in the exhaust, and scrutes need to be able to see that it is there by way of an inspection hole. 100 cells per square inch offer less restriction and more power. There are quite a few cheap ones on the market now, make sure whatever you use has a metallic core, ceramic ones although much cheaper will break up. You don't need an FIA approved cat for UK, only for international events. So far the MSA has no way of measuring catalytic efficiency AFAIK, so it doesn't really matter if it is off an old road car or whatever, just make sure it is not melted internally or blocked in any way. Don't be tempted to put one on behind the silencer or any stuffing that comes out of the silencer will block the cat, which could damage your engine.

Edited by 456lbft on Tuesday 10th February 17:55
'An inspection hole'? How is that going to work? Does anyone have any pictures of a CAT fitted to a Westfield?

Edited by shortshift on Sunday 15th March 18:03

custardtart

1,731 posts

258 months

Monday 16th March 2009
quotequote all
shortshift said:
456lbft said:
Rules are that it must be fitted in the exhaust, and scrutes need to be able to see that it is there by way of an inspection hole. 100 cells per square inch offer less restriction and more power. There are quite a few cheap ones on the market now, make sure whatever you use has a metallic core, ceramic ones although much cheaper will break up. You don't need an FIA approved cat for UK, only for international events. So far the MSA has no way of measuring catalytic efficiency AFAIK, so it doesn't really matter if it is off an old road car or whatever, just make sure it is not melted internally or blocked in any way. Don't be tempted to put one on behind the silencer or any stuffing that comes out of the silencer will block the cat, which could damage your engine.

Edited by 456lbft on Tuesday 10th February 17:55
'An inspection hole'? How is that going to work? Does anyone have any pictures of a CAT fitted to a Westfield?

Edited by shortshift on Sunday 15th March 18:03
I think the general consensus among us Westy racers is not to fit them as our cars are all pre 200o - aren't they?

Edited by custardtart on Monday 16th March 08:57

mat205125

17,790 posts

218 months

Monday 16th March 2009
quotequote all
The regulations stipulate that a cat must be fitted, however this does not mean by implication that the car must comply with the emissions regulations of that particular car/age/engine.

I have been told by a respected engine builder that CATS are fitted close to the manifold in road applications as that is where they are most effective, however for race applications (where we don't acually give a st how effective they are), we are better mounting them as far back in the system as possible - BUT, be careful that your silencers aren't filled with fibreglass wadding that could dislodge and block the Cat, and potentially blow your engine.

claryclan

35 posts

189 months

Monday 16th March 2009
quotequote all
You could always try the method as used by fellow competitors on the Continent last year with a motorcycle catalyst fitted in the end of the exhaust pipe. Complies with the letter of the regulations and is easily checked. Also very cheap, I believe they were paying 25 euros from bike breakers.

Kevp

584 posts

256 months

Tuesday 17th March 2009
quotequote all
custardtart said:
I think the general consensus among us Westy racers is not to fit them as our cars are all pre 200o - aren't they?

Edited by custardtart on Monday 16th March 08:57
My understanding of the blue book is - you do not need a CAT if the car is pre 2000. However the 750MC seem to have made a CAT compulsary for their events. So I guess it depends on your race series & regs.

mat205125

17,790 posts

218 months

Wednesday 18th March 2009
quotequote all
Hello Mr Scruitineer. I've fitted mine. Look! You can easily see it through the inspection hole behind me!


custardtart

1,731 posts

258 months

Wednesday 18th March 2009
quotequote all
Kevp said:
custardtart said:
I think the general consensus among us Westy racers is not to fit them as our cars are all pre 200o - aren't they?

Edited by custardtart on Monday 16th March 08:57
My understanding of the blue book is - you do not need a CAT if the car is pre 2000. However the 750MC seem to have made a CAT compulsary for their events. So I guess it depends on your race series & regs.
Yep it's dependent on the race series however, in the westy series there's much debate at the moment about what to do as the series regs tell us to comply with the blue book but with westfields' it's not that easy to identify the age of the car, well it's certainly a grey area so at the moment the general consensus is that no-one fits them as they assume all the cars are pre-2000 until proven otherwise by the scruts. At the 750mc snett meeting last weekend my understansding was the scruts didn't show much interest in CATS.

I certainly don't want another £200 added to the cost of racing this year, we're trying to attract people to come and race in the Westfield series not put them off.

shortshift

Original Poster:

133 posts

214 months

Wednesday 18th March 2009
quotequote all
Does anyone know how many places the chassis number is displayed on a Westfield? I can't find one on mine!?

custardtart

1,731 posts

258 months

Wednesday 18th March 2009
quotequote all
Usually just one, on one of the cross members in the engine bay, the good news is it will be impossible to verify that your car is not a pre 2000.

Graham

16,368 posts

289 months

Thursday 19th March 2009
quotequote all
custardtart said:
Usually just one, on one of the cross members in the engine bay, the good news is it will be impossible to verify that your car is not a pre 2000.
until the msa say you have to prove that your car is pre 2000 to allow you to not run cats, rather than them having to prove its post 2000 to make you...


Its probably too late now that its in place but is there any merit in starting a campaign to prove how damaging to the enviroment the use of cats in motorsport it, and put forward a sensible alternative i.e. tyre and oil recycling and planting trees!!!! that would actually do some good...

for a start motorsport stops some land development i.e. brands would easily be a housing estate if it were not a race track !! and other places would probably be industrial estates

teamHOLDENracing

5,089 posts

272 months

Thursday 19th March 2009
quotequote all
I received this the other day:

You will be delighted to hear the MSA have confirmed with us that none of the cars running in the GT Cup in 2009 will be required to have Catalytic Converters fitted.

Which is interesting!

custardtart

1,731 posts

258 months

Thursday 19th March 2009
quotequote all
Graham said:
custardtart said:
Usually just one, on one of the cross members in the engine bay, the good news is it will be impossible to verify that your car is not a pre 2000.
until the msa say you have to prove that your car is pre 2000 to allow you to not run cats, rather than them having to prove its post 2000 to make you...


Its probably too late now that its in place but is there any merit in starting a campaign to prove how damaging to the enviroment the use of cats in motorsport it, and put forward a sensible alternative i.e. tyre and oil recycling and planting trees!!!! that would actually do some good...

for a start motorsport stops some land development i.e. brands would easily be a housing estate if it were not a race track !! and other places would probably be industrial estates
It's a fair point although there's no clarification around who has the burden of proof and trust me, they need every car they can get at the moment so wont take this approach ; )

shortshift

Original Poster:

133 posts

214 months

Friday 20th March 2009
quotequote all
teamHOLDENracing said:
I received this the other day:

You will be delighted to hear the MSA have confirmed with us that none of the cars running in the GT Cup in 2009 will be required to have Catalytic Converters fitted.

Which is interesting!
I thought the ruling in the blue book was universal across all formulas? How can some be exempt and not others? I doubt that the GT Cup cars are less environmentally damaging than little Westfield Zetecs?

teamHOLDENracing

5,089 posts

272 months

Friday 20th March 2009
quotequote all
Quite! I find the whole thing quite bizarre. (Although personally I am relieved to have an e mail from the MSA confirming that my car does not need cats as it is built on a 1989 launched non-production car)