What 4x4

Author
Discussion

egor110

Original Poster:

17,365 posts

210 months

Sunday 20th September 2015
quotequote all
After 11 years I think we are finally going to sell out trusty mazda bongo as it's going to need wheelarches replaced plus there's a bit of rust on the front of the subframe and now we have less dogs we just don't use it much.

Obviously owning the bongo were not scared of low mpg but we had a 4.0 grand Cherokee and that was to low even compared to the bongo.

We'd like auto and for it to be comfy and cheap £3000 max, so after a look online the contenders are :

xtrail 2.2dci , freelander td4 or a Volvo xc70 d5 would also consider the xtail petrol as it returns pretty good mpg.

I also like the merc ml looking at the mpg's it pretty similar to what our bongo does now 29 compared to the bongos 25mpg.

Edited by egor110 on Sunday 20th September 10:45

bearman68

4,795 posts

139 months

Sunday 20th September 2015
quotequote all
That's a hard choice I would think, as you haven't picked much that's good to start off with. (No opinion on the Volvo)
I have driven the X-trail 2.2 diesel, and I hated that. And the ones I saw had lots of trouble with the injectors and things.
I'd completely avoid avoid avoid the German stuff,unless you have a very good repair budget. Electrical gremlins will not be pleasant. (I've thought and looked at one of these as a replacement for our 4*4)

Surprisingly, I did drive a 55 plate Cr-v 2.0 Auto on a 55 plate the other day. 168kmiles, and was as smooth as you like. Lovely lovely car, and one that I would have bought.
I've also has a Rav 4 - and I like those a lot too.

egor110

Original Poster:

17,365 posts

210 months

Sunday 20th September 2015
quotequote all
I'd consider the 2.0 petrol x trial as that does mpg.

Trouble is I'd really prefer a auto and that kind of rules out most x trails, santa fe's .


sim16v

2,177 posts

208 months

Sunday 20th September 2015
quotequote all
If you liked the Grand Cherokee apart from the fuel, what about one with LPG?

Mine does 150-170 miles on about £30 worth of LPG, even when towing 2.5T.

deltashad

6,731 posts

204 months

Sunday 20th September 2015
quotequote all
Maybe stretch a little and go for an x3 2.0d?

egor110

Original Poster:

17,365 posts

210 months

Sunday 20th September 2015
quotequote all
deltashad said:
Maybe stretch a little and go for an x3 2.0d?
No , a diesel is a risk anyway with injectors, turbos and dmf all poised ready to fail so I'd rather hedge my bets with a cheaper car.

alias2002

32 posts

116 months

Tuesday 22nd September 2015
quotequote all
Long time on Mazda. Congrats for this. Now what's the problem. Why did you want to sell?

egor110

Original Poster:

17,365 posts

210 months

Tuesday 22nd September 2015
quotequote all
alias2002 said:
Long time on Mazda. Congrats for this. Now what's the problem. Why did you want to sell?
Both wheel arches need cutting out and replacing there was a advisory on the mot for corrosion on the front subframe which needs looking at , and we just don't need it anymore as we used to have 3 dogs now we have 1.

However I've priced up the wheel arches and I can get them sorted for £600 so maybe it's worth spending out on it as we know it's spot on mechanically and it's never broken down , I could spend 3k on something else and end up with a money pit.

mpg the bongo does 25 combined other than the Volvo most the other 4x4's we were looking at were only doing around 30 so no massive advantage there either.

alias2002

32 posts

116 months

Thursday 24th September 2015
quotequote all
egor110 said:
Both wheel arches need cutting out and replacing there was a advisory on the mot for corrosion on the front subframe which needs looking at , and we just don't need it anymore as we used to have 3 dogs now we have 1.

However I've priced up the wheel arches and I can get them sorted for £600 so maybe it's worth spending out on it as we know it's spot on mechanically and it's never broken down , I could spend 3k on something else and end up with a money pit.

mpg the bongo does 25 combined other than the Volvo most the other 4x4's we were looking at were only doing around 30 so no massive advantage there either.
Happy to know the issue. Thank You!

97BlackC5

352 posts

245 months

Sunday 11th October 2015
quotequote all
I know you said no diesel but....... my Jeep Grand Cherokee Overland 2.7 CRD (the same engine as the Merc ML) is currently for sale in the adds, Its been a fantastic car for me for the last 4 years, fully stamped up service history etc etc only £250 over your budget......

http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/j...

Edited by 97BlackC5 on Sunday 11th October 15:57

egor110

Original Poster:

17,365 posts

210 months

Sunday 11th October 2015
quotequote all
97BlackC5 said:
I know you said no diesel but....... my Jeep Grand Cherokee Overland 2.7 CRD (the same engine as the Merc ML) is currently for sale in the adds, Its been a fantastic car for me for the last 4 years, fully stamped up service history etc etc only £250 over your budget......

http://www.pistonheads.com/classifieds/used-cars/j...

Edited by 97BlackC5 on Sunday 11th October 15:57
When push came to shove we just couldn't let the bongo go.

Goes in next month to have rear wheel arches replaced and wax oiled.