PHers Top 50 Bands Of All Time
Discussion
So following on from the (questionable) Top 50 rock bands of all time list ( https://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&...), I'm proposing that we have a PHers Top 50 bands of All Time list.
Guidance, as I see it, as follows:
Obviously it'll take quite a few responses to have a sensible top 50.
So go fill yer boots one and all![thumbup](/inc/images/thumbup.gif)
Guidance, as I see it, as follows:
- Post one response,in this thread, listing a maximum of your top 10 bands
- To keep it simple, there's no order of preference, so your first and last bands listed will be treated equally
- Any kind of music goes, from any era and genre; they don't need to be 'Rock', even in the vaguest sense (ref the thread linked above)
- Solo artists should be considered separately to their respective band (in that Ozzy is Ozzy, Dio is Dio and Black Sabbath are Black Sabbath)
- Any more than 10, or multiple posts will be ignored; so 10 or less bands only please
- If you subsequently edit your post to change a band, it's probable that I'll miss your revision
![smile](/inc/images/smile.gif)
So go fill yer boots one and all
![thumbup](/inc/images/thumbup.gif)
Drumroll please ..........
We have the 1st PHers Top 50 bands. But before we get into the details; here's some background info:
We have the 1st PHers Top 50 bands. But before we get into the details; here's some background info:
- 51 PHers votes have been counted (so far)
- A total of 494 votes were counted
- Covering 227 bands
- For people who multiple-posted or posted more than 10, only the 1st 10 on the 1st post counted
- Where bands share a ranking, they are simply sorted alphabetically
- I'm only showing 48 bands, as its conveniently where the bands with 3 votes got to
- I'll update this list every few days/weeks (depending on number of inputs).
Ranking | Band | Votes |
---|---|---|
1 | Pink Floyd | 16 |
2 | AC/DC | 15 |
3 | Led Zeppelin | 13 |
4 | The Beatles | 12 |
5 | Black Sabbath | 11 |
6 | Foo Fighters | 10 |
6 | Guns n Roses | 10 |
6 | The Who | 10 |
9 | Deep Purple | 9 |
9 | The Rolling Stones | 9 |
11 | Fleetwood Mac | 8 |
11 | Metallica | 8 |
11 | Radiohead | 8 |
14 | Joy Division | 7 |
14 | Queen | 7 |
14 | Thin Lizzy | 7 |
17 | David Bowie | 6 |
17 | Muse | 6 |
17 | The Stone Roses | 6 |
20 | Dire Straits | 5 |
20 | Pearl Jam | 5 |
20 | The Smiths | 5 |
23 | Electric Light Orchestra | 4 |
23 | Motorhead | 4 |
23 | Nirvana | 4 |
23 | Rainbow | 4 |
23 | Rolling Stones | 4 |
23 | Soundgarden | 4 |
23 | Steely Dan | 4 |
23 | The Clash | 4 |
23 | The Damned | 4 |
23 | The Jam | 4 |
23 | U2 | 4 |
34 | Arctic Monkeys | 3 |
34 | Bob Dylan | 3 |
34 | Bruce Springsteen | 3 |
34 | Evanescence | 3 |
34 | Iron Maiden | 3 |
34 | Madness | 3 |
34 | Ozzy Osbourne | 3 |
34 | Queens of the Stone Age | 3 |
34 | Rage Against the Machine | 3 |
34 | Talking Heads | 3 |
34 | The Cure | 3 |
34 | The Eagles | 3 |
34 | The Smashing Pumpkins | 3 |
34 | The Stranglers | 3 |
34 | Velvet Underground | 3 |
Drumroll please .......... V2 ![paperbag](/inc/images/paperbag.gif)
I see what happened with the 1st one .... my machine crashed as I was half-way through summarising the data; and I restored the wrong version, so had excluded the amalgamated list I had already done!
Anyway, here we go ....... with slightly tweaked numbers
We have the 1st PHers Top 50 bands. But before we get into the details; here's some background info:
![paperbag](/inc/images/paperbag.gif)
I see what happened with the 1st one .... my machine crashed as I was half-way through summarising the data; and I restored the wrong version, so had excluded the amalgamated list I had already done!
Anyway, here we go ....... with slightly tweaked numbers
We have the 1st PHers Top 50 bands. But before we get into the details; here's some background info:
- 51 PHers votes have been counted (so far)
- A total of 494 votes were counted
- Covering 223 bands
- For people who multiple-posted or posted more than 10, only the 1st 10 on the 1st post counted
- Where bands share a ranking, they are simply sorted alphabetically
- I'm only showing 48 bands, as its conveniently where the bands with 3 votes got to
- I'll update this list every few days/weeks (depending on number of inputs).
Ranking | Band | Votes |
---|---|---|
1 | Pink Floyd | 16 |
2 | AC/DC | 15 |
3 | Led Zeppelin | 13 |
3 | The Rolling Stones | 13 |
5 | The Beatles | 12 |
6 | Black Sabbath | 11 |
7 | Foo Fighters | 10 |
7 | Guns n Roses | 10 |
7 | The Who | 10 |
10 | Deep Purple | 9 |
11 | Fleetwood Mac | 8 |
11 | Metallica | 8 |
11 | Radiohead | 8 |
14 | Joy Division | 7 |
14 | Queen | 7 |
14 | Thin Lizzy | 7 |
17 | David Bowie | 6 |
17 | Muse | 6 |
17 | The Stone Roses | 6 |
20 | Dire Straits | 5 |
20 | Pearl Jam | 5 |
20 | The Smiths | 5 |
20 | The Velvet Underground | 5 |
24 | Electric Light Orchestra | 4 |
24 | Motorhead | 4 |
24 | Nirvana | 4 |
24 | Rainbow | 4 |
24 | Soundgarden | 4 |
24 | Steely Dan | 4 |
24 | The Clash | 4 |
24 | The Damned | 4 |
24 | The Eagles | 4 |
24 | The Jam | 4 |
24 | U2 | 4 |
35 | Arctic Monkeys | 3 |
35 | Bob Dylan | 3 |
35 | Bruce Springsteen | 3 |
35 | Evanescence | 3 |
35 | Iron Maiden | 3 |
35 | Madness | 3 |
35 | Ozzy Osbourne | 3 |
35 | Queens of the Stone Age | 3 |
35 | Rage Against the Machine | 3 |
35 | Talking Heads | 3 |
35 | The Cure | 3 |
35 | The Smashing Pumpkins | 3 |
35 | The Stranglers | 3 |
V3 ![thumbup](/inc/images/thumbup.gif)
![thumbup](/inc/images/thumbup.gif)
- 53 PHers votes have been counted (so far)
- A total of 514 votes were counted
- Covering 228 bands
- I'm only showing 48 bands, as its conveniently where the bands with 3 votes got to
- I'll update this list every few days/weeks (depending on number of inputs).
Ranking | Band | Votes |
---|---|---|
1 | Pink Floyd | 18 |
2 | AC/DC | 15 |
3 | Led Zeppelin | 14 |
4 | The Beatles | 13 |
4 | The Rolling Stones | 13 |
6 | Black Sabbath | 11 |
6 | Foo Fighters | 11 |
7 | Deep Purple | 10 |
7 | Guns n Roses | 10 |
7 | The Who | 10 |
11 | Fleetwood Mac | 8 |
11 | Metallica | 8 |
11 | Queen | 8 |
11 | Radiohead | 8 |
15 | Joy Division | 7 |
15 | Thin Lizzy | 7 |
17 | David Bowie | 6 |
17 | Muse | 6 |
17 | The Stone Roses | 6 |
20 | Dire Straits | 5 |
20 | Pearl Jam | 5 |
20 | Steely Dan | 5 |
20 | The Smiths | 5 |
20 | The Velvet Underground | 5 |
25 | ELO | 4 |
25 | Iron Maiden | 4 |
25 | Motorhead | 4 |
25 | Nirvana | 4 |
25 | Rage Against The Machine | 4 |
25 | Rainbow | 4 |
25 | Soundgarden | 4 |
25 | The Clash | 4 |
25 | The Damned | 4 |
25 | The Eagles | 4 |
25 | The Jam | 4 |
25 | The Stranglers | 4 |
25 | U2 | 4 |
38 | Arctic Monkeys | 3 |
38 | Bob Dylan | 3 |
38 | Bruce Springsteen | 3 |
38 | Depeche Mode | 3 |
38 | Evanescence | 3 |
38 | Madness | 3 |
38 | Ozzy Osbourne | 3 |
38 | Queens of the Stone Age | 3 |
38 | Talking Heads | 3 |
38 | The Cure | 3 |
38 | The Smashing Pumpkins | 3 |
Gassing Station | Music | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff